NINE former health secretaries have joined forces to condemn the government

Ignacio Amigo

Nine former health secretaries have addressed a letter (paywall) to The Times to criticise the inaction of the current government in dealing with mental health. The signatories complain that, despite “promised increases in funding” and “warm words”, people with mental health issues are still being neglected.

Norman Lamb, the Liberal Democrat former health minister who arranged the letter, added that:

It is a stain on our country that people with mental ill health are so often treated as second-class citizens.

More than 15% of adults in the UK live with mental health problems. Of those, only a quarter receive some kind of treatment.


The letter makes the case that mental health problems are not being treated on equal grounds with physical disease. It also points out growing economic difficulties for mental health trusts. It mentions that two in five mental health trusts have had their budgets slashed during the last financial year. Not only that, but more than £100m aimed at children’s services has not materialised.

The former health secretaries also highlight that the situation has worsened for women. They see a “growing mental health crisis among young women” that remains unaddressed. The numbers seem to confirm this. The latest rates of women taking their own lives, from 2014, indicate a slight increase. They also call attention to the fact that 20% of women aged 16-24 have self-harmed. This rate that has tripled in seven years.

Another dramatic case is that of children with eating disorders. According to the letter, the institutions are tackling these cases too late, when the children are already too thin and have self-harming tendencies.

The government

In her first speech after becoming Prime Minister in July, Theresa May acknowledged the situation of those with mental health issues. She said that “there’s not enough help at hand” for them. But just three months later, she claimed that the government was investing “an estimated record £11.7 bn” in mental health services.

Current Health Secretary, Jeremy Hunt, also shares this optimistic view:

We are making progress against our goal to address the difficulties faced by those with mental health problems – spending by clinical commissioning groups has increased by £693m, every area in the country has put together plans to transform children’s mental health services, and our suicide prevention strategy is to be refreshed, all backed by added investment.

But some people disagree. Figures obtained by Labour MP Luciana Berger indicate that 57% of the clinical commissioning groups are planning to reduce their mental health budgets. She urged the government to take action:

The government must urgently step in and prevent a dangerous situation developing. Time and time again ministers have promised that mental health spending would increase. Yet for the third year in a row this has not happened, with a majority of local areas planning to spend less of their budget on mental health.

The former health secretaries also throw some figures in their letter that are at odds with this optimistic view. Namely, that 5,500 of patients with mental health issues have to travel long distances for treatment because of a lack of beds. And that some parts of the country spend a mere £2 a head on children’s mental health.

The letter ends with a pledge to the chancellor to “make good the promise to achieve genuine equality”. The Autumn Statement, that will be released next week, will be a good opportunity to do it.

Get Involved!

– Support Work Wise UK and call Mind if you need mental health support.

– If you need to talk to someone, call The Samaritans on 116 123.

– See more Health and mental health articles at The Canary.

– Support the People’s Assembly and UK Uncut.

Featured image via Flickr/rana ossama

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us

Comments are closed