The new coronavirus rules only work if you’re rich

Boris Johnson announcing new coronavirus rules

Boris Johnson revealed the Tory government’s latest coronavirus (Covid-19) measures on Tuesday 22 September. But some of the advice will only work for richer people. And it shows that once again the Tories are abandoning the poorest people in the UK.

Follow the rules…

The government has outlined several new rules along with advice. BBC News summed them up. It said that in England, the new rules included:

  • “Office workers are being told to work from home again if possible”.
  • “Penalties for not wearing a mask or gathering in groups of more than six will increase to £200 on the first offence”.
  • “From Thursday 24 September, all pubs, bars and restaurants will be restricted to table service only. Takeaways can continue”.
  • “Also from Thursday, hospitality venues must close at 22:00 – which means shutting then, not calling for last orders”.

But the work from home advice is a problem. Not least because many of the poorest workers simply can’t do this.

…unless you’re poor

Research by the think tank the Resolution Foundation found that rich people’s “ability” to work from home is greater than the poorest workers:

Resolution Foundation Home Working Research

This also shows in its industry-by-industry analysis. The lowest paid sectors often provide the least ability to work from home:

Industry Specific Home Working figures

The Welsh government has partly addressed this issue.  If low-paid workers have to self-isolate due to coronavirus, it is paying them £500. This is to cover the 14 days of lost earnings.


BBC News reported that the furlough scheme is ending on 31 October:

Almost 10 million jobs have been supported by furlough, which pays the wages of those who cannot work because of coronavirus.

It also said that:

Chancellor Rishi Sunak has ruled out extending the scheme.

But the Resolution Foundation disagreed with that figure. It said on 1 August:

this is simply not true. Although it is true to say that in total nine million [since then, 10 million] people have been furloughed for at least one three-week period since March, this cumulative figure does not reflect what’s happening right now.

In other words, 10 million people is the total figure – not the figure at any one time. It said on 18 September that:

Our latest estimates suggest that take-up of the JRS in late August was around 3 million, highlighting that while we’re seeing significant numbers returning to work, there is a real risk of a large rise in unemployment as the scheme is phased out over the next six weeks.

The Resolution Foundation said that people working in hospitality and leisure were at risk.

A perfect storm brewing

So, low-paid workers are facing a perfect storm. Many are unable to work from home. The furlough scheme is coming to an end. And for some, there’s no guarantee they’ll keep their jobs.

Maja Gustafsson from the Resolution Foundation said:

Lockdown has meant a working from home revolution…

But, while widespread home working has been essential for controlling the pandemic and has worked for many people, it is not an option for millions of other workers – particularly for low-paid workers in customer-facing roles who will again face the biggest health risks from the rising virus caseload. There’s also a world of difference between older home-owners, and those living in crowded flats or alone, for whom enforced home working has big downsides.

The blame game

All this comes against a backdrop of Johnson blaming rising coronavirus cases on “too many breaches” of the rules by people. But it’s been some of the government initiatives that have helped spread the virus. The government told people to “Eat Out to Help Out“. So, they did. And then it turns out the scheme could have helped cause the rise in cases.

Johnson also said that people’s common sense was the “greatest weapon”. But when the government sets rules which are impossible for the poorest people to follow, it’s unclear what he thinks will happen. Moreover, as always it’s the people at the bottom of society who suffer the most. The Tories’ call to work from home is just another example of institutionalised classism against society’s poorest people. And the richest? They just keep on getting richer.

Featured image via Sky News – YouTube

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us