A staggering fact in the Universal Credit chaos just emerged

DWP and Universal Credit logos against a fireball
Steve Topple

New research has plunged Universal Credit into further chaos. It involves the debate around the £20 a week uplift. A charity has claimed that without this, Universal Credit will be worth less than in 2013.

But The Canary has done its own research. And we’ve found that the problems with the Department for Work and Pensions’ (DWP) flagship benefit and the uplift are actually worse than even this new research thought. Because some people could be nearly £440 a month worse off than before.

DWP and the Treasury: at war

In April 2020, the DWP increased the rate of Universal Credit by around £20 a week. But ever since then, uncertainty has existed over what will happen this April. Now we know the Tories are ending this increase in April, and people will see a £20 per week cut to their payments.

Chaos has ensued in government. At first, chancellor Rishi Sunak talked about giving Universal Credit claimants a one-off £500 payment. Then, he was allegedly thinking about making this £1,000. But the DWP boss Thérèse Coffey ‘slapped down‘ Sunak’s idea. She said it was not her department’s “preferred approach”, but did not say what the DWP’s answer would be.

On 9 February, the Work and Pensions Select Committee warned of a rise in poverty not seen since the 1980s if the government did not keep the uplift. And now, research has further strengthened the argument for keeping the extra £20 a week.

Universal Credit: worth less than in 2013

Citizens Advice Scotland (CAS) has done some calculations. It has looked at the standard allowance rates. These are fixed amounts the DWP pays people depending on their circumstances. It was this part that the government increased by £20 a week. CAS has worked out how much the allowance is worth in real terms; that is, what the actual amount of money the DWP pays is worth when you factor in inflation. It said that, if the government removes the £20 a week uplift, then across all circumstances the standard allowance will be worth less in real terms than it was in 2013:

Standard Allowance Real Terms Value

CAS is calling for the government to keep the uplift. It noted some case studies of how a reduction in Universal Credit would affect people:

A West of Scotland CAB reports of a client with a young baby facing financial difficulties as a result of unexplained deductions to her benefits. Client’s deductions are around £50 a month, meaning removal of the uplift will push her into more severe hardship.

An East of Scotland CAB reports of a client moved over to UC as she would be £12 a week better off than on legacy benefits. Cutting the £20 a week UC uplift will make her materially worse off than she was pre-pandemic.

But CAS has missed another point about the uplift. Because it hasn’t calculated the effects of inflation on overall payments; not just on the standard allowance.

Canary number crunching

The Canary has crunched the numbers. DWP figures for mean (average) overall Universal Credit payments only go back to 2015. But as its figures show, couples with children already on average got less money in August 2020 than they did in August 2015. This is with the uplift:

UC averages couples with children

Then, factor inflation into these figures. The results are shocking.

Systemically broken

This would mean that:

  • Lone parents are £137 a month worse off. Without the uplift, this would go up to around a £217 a month loss (based on four calendar weeks, without inflation).
  • Couples with children are £359 a month worse off. Without the uplift, the figure is around £439.
  • Couples with no children are £8.31 a month worse off. Without the uplift, this is around £88.

The only group which is better off now than in 2015 is single people with no children; to the tune of £144 a month. But even this is reduced to just £64 if you take off the uplift.

All this is without even touching on the around 1.5 million claimants of things like Employment and Support Allowance (ESA). The government hasn’t given any extra support to these people at all during the pandemic.

Universal Credit has been a disaster from the start. And while an extra £20 a week is crucial, it’s just a tweak in a system that’s already broken. Entrenched poverty and inequality are now a systemic fault in our social security system. No amount of tinkering around the edges with £20 here and there is going to solve that.

Featured image via geralt – pixabay, Wikimedia and Wikimedia 

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. To all Tory party member including its Tory voters
      Some home truths be you like them or not
      They are true Tory party members as of 11.2.2021.
      //
      A staggering fact in the Universal Credit chaos just emerged
      //
      This C**p problems with Tory made Scam U-Credits as not
      just come to light it been with U-Credit from day one and Tory
      Govt Minster know about the mess including its M.P.
      Prime Ministers of Tory party. they all voted for it’ years ago
      //
      I personally have been telling you of the Big problem about
      Tory Scam U-Credit benefits for years now but you just did not listen,
      Tory Govt DW.P. Ministers or Treasury Dept. Now Tory voter middle class people out of work because of Virus L-Down (loss of their jobs) and are put on U-Credit benefits they are whining about the mess it is in and not working for the claimants to help them.
      //
      Some point Tory voter out of work now need to fully understand
      them put on SCAM U-Credit benefits now (because of loss of jobs)
      FACT is you all voted YES for this benefit to be implemented by way of
      Tory party Manifesto paper instruction given them in LONDON you all
      voted for every G.E. time. you voted blindly if you did not read them
      So now you are personally sampling what you voted yes to, so all Tory voters put on it now because of loss of jobs you are part of the problem for not holding your party members (M.P.s + Minister) in LONDON fully to account you all voted for this SCAM U-Credit to unfold and untested right. Your Tory party Minister just ploughed on with it, Do Not forget Tory voter RICH Tory Minister plus rich Tory part funder come up with the SCAM U-Credit to screw claimants out of benefit cash they desperately need now like you lot out of work.
      //
      So before next G.E. I politely suggest all you Tory voters read your own Manifesto paper fully and understand what you are vetoing for at the time O.K. before you ask, I read all party Manifestos paper before voting every time. I aided in removing Labour from power in 2021 G.E. because their Manifesto paper was on the same lines as Tory parties was back then. FINALLY -NO I have never voted for any Tory party members Cllr or M.P.s alike.
      //
      Come next G.E. we free voter will be aiding in removing Tory party from power over SCAM -U-Credit mess plus failing our country now in time of need poverty is rampant in our rich country under Tory rule this must STOP and will STOP next G.E. Tory members Tory voters. NO Labour will not be in power both Labour + Tory can sit on the Opposition benchers together under a NEW Govt party they will Be room for both parties on the bencher when Scotland leave the, U.K. they will not need seats in H.O.Commons Tory party members.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.