Beyond the tragedy of the Coronavirus pandemic, there is a glimmer of hope
We live in strange times that bring out the worst in people, such as panic buying, but also the best. And over the days and weeks ahead we will undoubtedly witness tragedies that one way or another affect us all. In the UK we’re also witnessing a major shift in the way government responds to the coronavirus (Covid-19) crisis. Meanwhile, prime minister Boris Johnson’s gung-ho approach has gone and in his TV appearances, he appears out of his depth.
As to the economic and political systems that have exacerbated the crisis, will they fall victim too?
UK government playing catchup
It’s been apparent that the UK government is playing catchup. It wasted valuable weeks – which likely increased the number of deaths – while it toyed with an inappropriate ‘herd immunity’ approach. That approach was reportedly promoted by special adviser Dominic Cummings and the ‘Nudge Unit’, and condemned and questioned by leading clinicians across the UK.
O my prophetic soul:
“Cummings and Vallance were “close allies”… the government had “bet” the future of the UK on advice from a very small group of scientists that for a long time differed from the wider international consensus” #herdimmunity https://t.co/zRrGDYRzWc
— Peter Jukes (@peterjukes) March 21, 2020
A “minister” told Buzzfeed News: that Cummings and Patrick Vallance the government’s chief scientific adviser:
were “close allies” and claimed the government had “bet” the future of the UK on advice from a very small group of scientists that for a long time differed from the wider international consensus, and other members of SAGE.
Peoples’ lives are not a game for scientists, such as those at SAGE (Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies), and ideologues such as Cummings and his associates to play with.
U-turn
The government has since been forced into a u-turn and has introduced stringent but necessary measures that mean the UK’s edging closer to total lockdown. Also, there’s now unprecedented financial support to businesses.
But this is only a start.
Labour’s Zarah Sultana pointed out that time is running out:
The government is beginning to appreciate the scale of the economic crisis, but it's not going far enough, fast enough.
Urgent action is needed for the self-employed, gig-economy workers, small businesses, renters, & a rise in statutory sick pay.
There's no time to waste.
— Zarah Sultana MP (@zarahsultana) March 20, 2020
The government did announce financial support for workers. Two weeks ago, or even a week ago, to associate such a level of support for workers with a Conservative government would have been unthinkable.
But, despite these measures, much more is needed:
It’s dawning on people that there are huge gaping holes in yesterday’s Chancellor’s statement. We must urge him to shift once more to protect the wages of the self employed by including them in the jobs retention scheme & to raise the level of sick pay to the real living wage.
— John McDonnell (@johnmcdonnellMP) March 21, 2020
Setting the agenda
In regard to wages support for workers, for example, Labour proposes that wages of all workers who could lose their jobs should have their wages underwritten by the government. This proposal goes further than that of the government’s in that lower and middle-wage earners should receive 90% and 85% respectively of their wages from the state. Furthermore, Labour proposes that businesses for which the worker works will pay the shortfall, with no worker laid off.
On March 21, Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn also wrote to Johnson, explaining what needs to be done with regard to support for the self-employed, those who pay rent:
Boris Johnson should provide economic security for everyone to get through this.
That means much more help for the self-employed, renters and workers, improved social security and an increase in sick pay, which the Health Secretary has admitted isn't currently enough to live on. pic.twitter.com/24FxgRZMjr
— Jeremy Corbyn (@jeremycorbyn) March 21, 2020
Labour MP Stephen Doughty has also coordinated a letter, supported by scores of cross-party MPs, urging chancellor Rishi Sunak to provide further financial support to charities and similar organisations:
Great to be joined by over 100 MPs and Peers from 7 parties to urge further clarity + urgent action from UK Government @RishiSunak for charities who face £4.3 billion loss in income over next 12wks. Will play crucial role in fight against #Coronavirus and supporting communities. https://t.co/eAdagzsLnv pic.twitter.com/SRS6gRjSyA
— Stephen Doughty MP (@SDoughtyMP) March 21, 2020
Mutual aid goes viral
There are also interventions at grassroots level.
On 14 March The Canary reported on how community groups around the UK have sprung up to offer a level of mutual support within local communities. For example:
If a single mother cannot leave the house and is running low on food, or if an elderly person needs medication, they can contact the Brighton Covid-19 Mutual Aid group.
In an article published by Anarchist Communism before some of the government’s more recent pronouncements, one person described some of the activities of their local mutual aid group:
In the village where I live, Facebook organising has produced more than 350 names in four days, volunteering various kinds of help, including visits to elderly and disabled by local known people, street by street, free exchange of surplus daily necessities, a local shop and a community centre offered for food collection, assembling food parcels and deliveries, free taxi to Iceland to pick up supplies, meals for free school dinner kids, even dog walking (there are 1000’s of dogs here).
Freedom Press published a listing of Covid-19 Mutual Aid groups on 13 March, since then that’s grown and grown across the UK. The Covid-19 Mutual Aid UK website provides a facility so that you can search for your nearest mutual aid group. And TogetherTV provides an interactive map of Covid-19 Mutual Aid groups across the UK.
As for the worst and best, this sums it all up:
When the world returns to normal and we return to retail & restaurants I'm going to remember the good that businesses did & also remember how Philip Green (he's not getting Sir from me) sent all Topshop workers home with no pay, just before govt announced the help for workers. pic.twitter.com/w6crkbrtQi
— Jo Marriott (@JoMarriott11) March 21, 2020
Hope
The coronavirus pandemic has meant that in many parts of the world traditional economic ideologies have been cast to one side. Where governments are of the right, these ideologies have now been replaced by a pseudo, if not real, form of socialism, albeit temporarily.
The real question now is about how those emergency economic measures can be retained to ensure that a more just and equitable society becomes a permanent feature of our lives. If that happens, we may well then be in a position to glimpse a very different, post-capitalist way of life.
There is hope on the horizon. We should not waste the opportunity that now presents itself.
Comments 1
Leave a Reply
The Canary
PO Box 71199
LONDON
SE20 9EX
Canary Media Ltd – registered in England. Company registration number 09788095.
For guest posting, contact [email protected]
For other enquiries, contact: [email protected]
© Canary Media Ltd 2026, all rights reserved | Website by Monster | Hosted by Krystal | Privacy Settings
Isn’t it ironic that only a few months ago we were all engaged in an almost pointless ideological battle to thwart or defend socialist/capitalist policies, and now a non-human entity is forcing the debate, and might well end it? Isn’t it also amazing that a virus (third in a row) seems to know it?
I wonder who else sees it? Have we not over time (as a nation and even as a species) relegated the very best of our nature (wisdom, selflessness, compassion, empathy, logic, reason, kindness, love, non-arrogant self-sufficiency) to being ‘weak’, perfunctory, and uncool? Whilst at the same time raising the worst of our nature (selfishness, arrogant self-sufficiency, intolerance, hatred, pettiness, disdain, violence, greed, cognitive dissonance, and so many others) to the level of ‘Strong’, cool, and desirable?
There is much talk of Socialism Vs Capitalism, much deriding and support of both concepts, and a great amount of contention regarding which is superior or inferior, but the truth is they are both just used as labels, and those labels mean different things to different people.
These terms are mostly used to mislead people these days. The Socialism of today is different to the Socialism of yesteryear (the same applies to Capitalism, and a great number of other ‘isms). Neither is a perfect solution or construct, and neither provides a satisfying answer to all our societal problems, and that is because the best in our nature has been relegated to a subservient, weakened, and derided position in relation to the worst in our nature.
More simply put, as a species we generally know we have basic and simple needs, which if met, generally keep us content. We also know we have basic and simple hates, which if met, generally lead to a whole Pandoras’s box of problems and dangers. Law is there to help us make the right decisions regarding our activities, and as such, forms the backbone of our society.
Power-hungry, greedy people however like complication. Complication provides a fertile ground for all manner of evil, which means they can hide their true intentions, and because they do so, they demonstrate their intent to go against the peaceful intent of law in the first place. Sadly this is so ingrained in society, that we are ‘forced’ to go along with it, even if we disagree with it.
Where are the ‘strong’ and the ‘weak’ now? Along came a virus, and not just any virus, like its two predecessors (perhaps more), it has demonstrated the extraordinary ability to be able to predict the most politically expedient time to make itself known, AND unlike its cousins, seems to have the uncanny ability to have surfaced in the very place 5G technology was invented, and at just the right time to really hamper 5G roll-out, which is in perfect alignment with Washington’s desire (not to mention all the other politically expedient things that are now being rolled out across the Globe because of it).
If this virus isn’t man-made, man-released, or manipulated, it sure has an incredible sense of politically expedient timing, and really should prompt scientists around The World to attempt to communicate with it, as it may well be smarter than us collectively. Maybe the first question they could ask it is if it is a socialist or capitalist virus? I think the answer alone would be mind-blowing, let alone the detail in the answer.