Video shows police at Manchester’s #KillTheBill protest slamming a woman’s head into the side of their van

Police pin Samantha Gibson against a van
Support us and go ad-free

Content warning – this article contains a description of police violence

Shocking footage from Manchester’s Kill the Bill demonstration on 3 April shows police officers slamming a woman’s head into a police van and then folding her body in half to restrain her as she shouts for help.

This violence was used as Samantha was arrested for a minor public order offence. She was later issued with a £90 fixed penalty notice.

A statement seen by The Canary says that the force used to push Samantha into the side of the vehicle broke the van’s wing-mirror.

Mistaken identity

The incident occurred after Samantha’s partner Dave was grabbed by police officers towards the end of the demonstration against the police bill on Saturday 3 April. Police had mistaken Dave for somebody else.

A statement written by Dave describes how he was “dragged” to a van. A YouTube video shows Dave’s arrest:

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free

A statement from Greater Manchester Police confirms that Dave was mistaken for someone else, and claims that he ‘refused to engage’ with officers. The statement reads:

He was arrested when officers had to take action because he had refused to engage with the police to confirm who he was. He was de-arrested as soon as we had enough further information about his identity to de-arrest him

However, Samantha told The Canary that police officers refused to look at Dave’s ID to confirm his identity.

Officer tells arrested man’s partner to “shut up”

After Dave was dragged off, Samantha tried to ask the police what was going on.

A video of what ensued shows that one officer’s response was to tell Samantha to “shut up”. One of the other protesters on the scene can be heard calling the officer’s behaviour “misogyny”.

Samantha’s statement describes what happened when she approached officers to ask about Dave’s arrest:

Due to my shock I was swearing, but standing still. I was asking what was going on, why could they not take his cuffs off, and occasionally using the F word mid-sentence. Suddenly, I was jumped on by a number of officers and told I was under arrest. At this point, I went into a PTSD [Post Traumatic Stress Disorder] flashback

Seconds later, Samantha was pushed by several officers and forcefully shoved against the side of the van. This video clip shows the moment when Samantha was slammed against the van:

Her statement reads:

then my head was smashed into the van wing-mirror with such force that it was folded back against the van, and I saw bits of black plastic coming off it. I later heard that were was glass on the floor below me. I briefly blacked out at this point, my legs gave way, and I wet myself. I had been pushed and pulled between officers who were mostly male and a lot larger than me. I was shouting to police to stop as I have PTSD. I then remember being on the floor shouting for help as officers violently cuffed me, pulled me back up and held me against the van.

While Samantha was pinned against the van and shouting for help, officers could be seen bending her body double. Samantha’s statement reads:

I was bent over almost double for a while, with their hands pressing my head down. I went into a severe panic attack and could not stop crying and shaking.

A statement from Greater Manchester Police claims that:

Officers were met with a high degree of hostility from a minority of people and our preference would always be that protesters dispersed peacefully.

However, the video clearly shows that the hostility and violence was coming from the police. The video shows the protesters chanting “all coppers are bastards” after the police grab Dave and violently drag him to the van, and after Samantha’s head is slammed against the vehicle. But are Greater Manchester police really all that surprised at this public ‘hostility’ to their actions?

The Canary contacted Greater Manchester Police and asked them if they wanted to make a further comment after watching the footage. We had not received a reply by the time of publication.

Injuries caused by the police

Both Dave and Samantha received treatment at hospital for the injuries they sustained during the arrest. Samantha’s statement reads:

I have swollen and bruised hands, forearms and upper arms, scuffed knees, shoulder, back and leg pain, and minor nerve damage in my thumb and wrist (recorded and confirmed by hospital doctor).

Dave’s statement is similar:

I sustained minor wounding to the back of my left hand during cuffing and being manhandled, red marks on both wrists where the cuffs had dug in. My lower back on the right hand side is in intense pain after the handling by police officers, which I believe was caused by the twisting and dragging being affected upon me while I was unable to move my own body freely.

“If this bill goes through they’ll have free rein”

Samantha told The Canary that police violence like this will only get worse if the police bill is passed:

I’ve been an environmental activist since 2014 and I’ve seen a lot of police violence, especially from the Greater Manchester Police.

If they are given more powers it’ll get even worse. If this bill goes through they’ll have free rein.

We need to envision a radically different future without the violence of the police

The proposed policing bill is arguably the biggest attack on our freedoms since the Public Order Acts of the ‘80s and ‘90s. The controversial bill passed its second reading in parliament during March. The bill will – if passed – give the police unprecedented draconian powers to arrest protesters, and will criminalise trespass, effectively outlawing the livelihoods of the UK’s Gypsy, Roma and Traveller (GRT) communities.

The violence felt by those involved in the growing movement against the bill is just another wake up call that we need to talk about police violence. Not only violence against protesters, but the daily violence faced by communities at the hands of the police. This police brutality is felt most acutely by People of Colour and working class communities. We need to stand in solidarity with all those on the receiving end of police violence, and envision a radically different future where we can abolish the violence of the police force and the prison system.

Tom Anderson is part of the Shoal Collective, a cooperative producing writing for social justice and a world beyond capitalism.  

Featured image via YouTube/Screenshot

Support us and go ad-free

Get involved

  • Learn about Black Lives Matter’s call to Defund the Police and read Sisters Uncut’s page on abolishing the police.
  • Check out the Network for Police Monitoring website.
  • Read the Kill the Bill coalition website.

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. Police Scotland regularly assault when they handcuff. One officer twists you down and to the left, the other twists you up and to the right, all the while screaming at you to stop resisting and resort to dragging. The use of walls and vehicles to strike their victim is also a regular occurrence. If you report crime in Scotland, it is normal for the victims to be treated in this manner. I speak from personal experience. The Police Investigation & Review Commissioner is staffed by police officers and is the official whitewashing unit, backed up by Queen Nikki the Poisoned Dwarf, who publicaly stated: ‘ ” The problems of Police Scotland, are for Police Scotland to deal with. ” ‘

      1. Not cool man. “Queen Nikki the Poisoned Dwarf” in response to an article about Police brutality.. in England. If that isn’t Anti-Scottish bias, I don’t know what is. You’d have been as well just coming right out with the super intelligent & original Wee Krankie put-down.

    2. How many male police thugs does it take to batter and wound a single woman. Where do these police members live? Are we safe in our community anymore? I don’t feel safe at all after watching this, we must Kill the Bill.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.