The government is trying to rewrite coronavirus history. We mustn’t let it.

Emily Apple

Right from the beginning, the government’s strategy over coronavirus has been a mess. Whether it’s herd immunity, testing, or personal protective equipment (PPE), it has failed time and again to deliver a coherent plan and meet its own goals.

This shambolic response has caused deaths. It’s caused the virus to spread through the UK in a ferocious manner. And it could have been avoided if our government hadn’t lost precious time talking about herd immunity and not taking action.

But our leaders would rather we didn’t talk about that. They’re trying to shift the narrative. In reality, they’re gaslighting the public by rewriting history to omit their failures.

In normal circumstances, this should be a time for mass protests, and people on the street holding the government to account. But these are not normal circumstances. While the time when we can take to the streets again feels like a long way off, we must not forget. And we mustn’t let the government rewrite history.

Manufacturing news

The government is tightly controlling the news agenda. Its daily press briefings are not keeping it accountable; they’re allowing it to recycle soundbites. While lobby journalists don’t always do the best job, they have – at times – tried to ask some decent questions. It’s just the questions aren’t answered; and because it’s a press conference, there isn’t the scrutiny of an actual interview.

On one occasion, one journalist asked for an explanation of the science behind a decision. The response, as always, was “we’re following the science”. But even if this wasn’t a ludicrous answer in itself, as public health professor Helen Ward wrote in the Guardian:

The government assures us that its decisions and timing are based on science, as if it is a neutral, value-free process resulting in a specific set of instructions. In reality, the science around coronavirus is in its infancy and developing daily, with researchers across the world trying to understand how the virus spreads, how the body responds – and how to treat it and control it.

This means that, every day, we’re subject to a massive state propaganda exercise masquerading as public information and accountability. Meanwhile, government ministers appear to avoid interviews where they’d face any kind of scrutiny. As Newsnight presenter Emma Barnett noted on 15 April:

the point is that they aren’t coming on programmes like this outside of the daily briefing

Blue Peter badges

It’s not even as though the daily briefings contain much information at times. For example, on 15 April, health secretary Matt Hancock launched a new brand. Yes, in the middle of a pandemic, he thought carers would appreciate getting a new badge.

But this isn’t Blue Peter. A badge does nothing to alleviate the problems in social care. In some parallel universe, you’d be forgiven for thinking that Hancock was about to unveil better pay and conditions for carers. But no. Working for the minimum wage (or less if you include travel time) is apparently reward enough if you’ve got a shiny new badge.

Too little, too late

The government acted too late to save the UK from the worst of the pandemic. As the former chief scientific adviser David King told Newsnight:

If we just look at what happened back in March, when we had known about the coronavirus epidemic for some time; we’d certainly watched it happening in China, watched how the Chinese got it under control at the end of January into February. And way into March… before we went into lockdown, we saw Cheltenham, and I believe 250,000 people attended the horse races at Cheltenham in mid-March. And at the same time in Ireland, which appears to be doing a lot better than us, the St Patrick’s Day celebrations were cut right back.

The UK had a chance that it failed to act on; a chance that has probably led to thousands of preventable deaths.

Instead, Johnson and his cronies decided to flirt with herd immunity, telling us our loved ones would die rather than taking the action needed to stop the spread.

‘It’s all China’s fault’

But the UK government would rather rewrite history and blame China. Michael Gove stated on 29 March that:

It was the case … [that] the first case of coronavirus in China was established in December of last year, but it was also the case that some of the reporting from China was not clear about the scale, the nature, the infectiousness of this.

While China is far from blameless in the epidemic and did initially suppress news of the outbreak, the lockdown and the spread of the virus was public knowledge by late January. Italy, meanwhile, reported its first case on 31 January, the same day the UK also reported its first two cases.

The figures from 31 January paint a damning picture of our government’s response to the crisis. For example, Japan had 14 cases on 31 January and Australia had nine. At the time of writing on 16 April, Japan had seen 178 deaths and Australia 63. The death toll in the UK, meanwhile, stands at a horrific and tragic 13,729 fatalities.

These figures don’t improve when looked at in terms of deaths per million of the population. In the UK, this figure is 190. But in Japan, it’s 1, and in Australia, 2. Meanwhile, in Ireland, where King noted measures including cancelling St Patrick’s Day celebrations took place earlier, it’s 90.

Figures showing when measures were taken in different European countries in relation to the third recorded death from the virus also paint a picture of how slow the UK was to respond to the pandemic.

As Ward wrote in her Guardian article:

It’s now clear that so many people have died, and so many more are desperately ill, simply because our politicians refused to listen to and act on advice. Scientists like us said lock down earlier; we said test, trace, isolate. But they decided they knew better.

Oh, but it’s okay, Boris Johnson is out of hospital

While there have been establishment journalists attempting to hold the government to account, that’s limited. The Sun‘s Good Friday headline about Johnson’s release from hospital is perhaps the most despicable example.

On the day that the UK recorded the highest number of deaths in a day of any European country, the Sun published the headline:

BORIS IS OUT (Now that really is a Good Friday!)

Yes, as the UK reeled from the news that a further 980 people had died the day before, the paper wanted us to celebrate the life of the one man whose inaction has added to this death toll.

Clap for carers

On 16 April, households across the UK will once again gather on their doorsteps to clap and cheer for carers. While this is good, it isn’t enough. Our carers, our doctors, our nurses, our supermarket workers and our public transport workers all need more than a round of applause. Instead, they’re still underpaid, and they’re still not receiving the PPE they need to do their jobs safely.

As US nurse Emily Pierskalla wrote:

If I die, I don’t want to be remembered as a hero.

I want my death to make you angry too.

I want you to politicize my death. I want you to use it as fuel to demand change in this industry, to demand protection, living wages, and safe working conditions for nurses and ALL workers.

Use my death to mobilize others.

Use my name at the bargaining table.

Use my name to shame those who have profited or failed to act, leaving us to clean up the mess.

Don’t say “heaven has gained an angel.” Tell them negligence and greed has murdered a person for choosing a career dedicated to compassion and service.

These words have just as much resonance in the UK. Everything about this crisis and the way it’s unfolded is political. The people who’ve made the decisions that have cost lives need to be held to account.

We must never forget nor forgive what those in power have done. We must fight for better wages and conditions for all those who’ve kept the country functioning during this pandemic. And we mustn’t let our politicians get away with rewriting history and erasing their role in the spread of this deadly virus.

Featured image via BBC/screengrab

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. Its the same stragtegy of Trump what the Tories have done. Its remarkable how close they are yet one never hears of how this is.
      The herd immunity theory has been proven to be false according to the Canadian Government.
      It does resemble however a eugenics program to to release the burden from the rich of the “welfare class” they seemed to be plagued with. One must not forget the enthusiasim of Mosley during the early days of WW11 emulating Hitler as his hero in his public marches. Many in the aristocracy approved of Hitler as well.
      Its well to remember this aristocracy in its decisions through two WW wars caused tens. tens of millions of innocent people’s death without learning any lessons I can see but for the fear of a unbridled nationalism few understand the nature of our social mass chemistry. Konrad Lorenz has come close to the truth.
      Even in Canda the Conservative Party under Steven Harper made a move to increase the retirement age to 67 from 65 to save money. What materialists.
      Seventy percent of those who have worked in industry to the age of 65, are dead within two years.
      What a savings to the Conservative treasury! The outcry was too strong to allow this to happen with such a despised Prime Minister.
      I can see this herd immunity was a eugenics program upon the old, weak,vulnerable in keeping with past attitudes of the aristocracy about a social death.
      Its rooted deeply in our bizarre psyche this low regard for the living when our minds are thrilled by the eternal, or the waving of the flag. I think every time one praises the waving of the flag they lose 2 of their 3 brain molecules.
      But the identity of a culture is a precious value to people, yet it is taken advantage of those who are drugged by social power.
      So call the Tories to account on their Eugneics program disguised as herd immunity.
      They didn’t try the herd immunity theory with typhoid, cholera, the plague. Wake up you people of the fog.
      One watches people marching elatedly off to war in documentaries, yet 2 years? later the reality of a utter disrespect for life shows its ugly truth.
      I don’t think the status quo has learning anything about why the enlightenment of which they were known for in the 18 century, and remains a mystery still to all of us. Presr3vation of t

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.