Starmer just doubled down on a disastrous weekend of coronavirus pledges

Keir Starmer
Steve Topple

It might be possible that Keir Starmer has a Miley Cyrus song stuck in his head. Either that, or he really is taking a leaf out of Boris Johnson’s ‘crisis management’ book. Because either way, the Labour leader has managed to take a wrecking ball to the party’s coronavirus (Covid-19) position in the space of just over 24 hours.

On Saturday…

First off, as The Canary previously reported, Starmer has backtracked on a key coronavirus pledge originally made by Jeremy Corbyn. In March, the former Labour leader made a commitment that the party’s position was that private renters should get three months rent-free from landlords during the pandemic. But on April 22, Starmer said it should just be a payment deferral scheme.

Then, on Saturday 9 May, Labour Press confirmed the policy to widespread dismay among supporters:

People were so miffed that talk of a ‘rent strike’ has increased:

But, seemingly unconcerned by the disquiet in his own ranks, Starmer grasped the capitalist wrecking ball he just took to private renters, aimed it at the climate crisis, and thrust it with all his might.

On Sunday…

Yes, because Labour’s latest pledge on coronavirus is to bail out the airlines:

In a not-so-clever piece of shambolic PR, the party’s shadow transport secretary Jim McMahon tried to dress this latest clusterf*ck up as a criticism of the government. He said in a statement:

The Government needs to work closely with airlines, airport operators and Border Force to implement practical solutions to stop the spread of this virus. Ill-thought through proposals will fail as soon as they are rolled out, leaving the country back in a precarious situation.

This sort of policy should have been worked through weeks ago. It’s systematic of a Government that was too slow to enter the lockdown, too slow to get vital protective equipment to NHS, social care and other key workers, and too slow on testing and tracing to help stop the spread of the coronavirus.

But the Blair-esque devil is in the detail, and McMahon dropped a massive clanger right at the end:

It will take a long time to recover from the impact of the virus. The Government must come up with a comprehensive financial support package for the aviation sector and its supply chain which supports almost a quarter of a million jobs.

There’s no denying that a quarter of a million people’s livelihoods need protecting. But talk about knee jerk. Because what the Labour Party has effectively done is also side with Richard Branson.

Special fwiends

The corporate mogul, who “pays no tax in the UK” (his people’s words, not ours) has been pleading for weeks for financial support for the airline industry. He was previously rumoured to be getting ready to flog Virgin Atlantic after giving up on his desperate pleas for help to the UK government. He even went as far as floating the idea of putting his private island up as collateral in a bid to get money from the UK public. What a gent. Then, 3,000 redundancies beckoned.

But as Sky News reported on 9 May, Virgin Atlantic could be getting ready for insolvency. It was perhaps Have I Got News For You which summed the situation up best:

Here’s the problem with Labour’s position on the airlines. It can dress it up all it wants as being about the ‘workers’. ‘We’re siding with the workers!’ you can almost hear Starmer whimper from his £1.75m Camden property. Yeah, because the last mass publicly-funded bailout of private corporations in 2008/09 went so well, didn’t it? The likelihood of airlines making workers the priority of public money is slim. It will be shareholders first, second, and third if the government bails them out.

The other elephant in the room is the climate crisis. The coronavirus pandemic could be an opportunity to reboot how we as a species interact with the planet we share with other animals. But instead, Labour seems to think bailing out one of the most polluting industries going is the appropriate answer.

There has to come a time when you say ‘enough is enough’ regarding corporate capitalism. The public can’t keep propping it up forever. Much like the climate crisis, this pandemic could be a chance to reboot our economic and social systems. But that as well seems far too much for Starmer to stomach. So, business as usual it is then – being an ‘inbetweener’ when it comes to political ideology.

Another fine mess

Of course, what sticks in the throat even more is that Corbyn’s 2019 manifesto was far from business as usual in terms of housing, the environment, and nationalisation. Starmer’s actions this weekend give the clearest message yet that he has effectively trashed this forward-thinking, egalitarian legacy.

This lack of vision coupled with snivelling subservience to corporations, unfortunately, appears to now be the norm for Labour. As I previously wrote, it’s clear he’s taking Tony Blair’s triangulation of left and right-wing politics and firmly putting himself somewhere up and to the side of that – by attempting to give some scraps to the poor while keeping the rich very happy. Except Starmer’s position appears to be the flip of Blair’s; that is, couple right-wing social policy with some socialist economics.

But muddling political ideologies is never a good idea; not least when you have a Tory government that clearly lurches to the right. Nor, as Blair’s legacy shows, is triangulation under corporate capitalism sustainable. Because it’s his actions which have ultimately left the UK in the mess it’s now in.

So, it’s unclear what Starmer thinks this ‘fourth way’ will achieve. But currently, he is looking about as competent at the helm of the Labour Party as Johnson is looking in charge of the country. What a mess.

Featured image via Guardian News – YouTube

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. Jeff3 is spot on! Starmer is a plant by the right that will return the Labour Party to the Tony B’Liar days when “New Labour” was really The Tory Lite Party.

      Britain needs a real Labour Party. One that represents the workers and middle income people as much as they represent the wealthy. Mild mannered ‘Clark Kent’ (Jeremy Corby) needs to come out as Superman and start a new party, The Real Labour Party. For the many, not the few.

      Starmer is a fifth columnist, supported by MI5 and the media owners. He is a traitor to the workers that made Britain great. At this moment he would be a better Tory PM than the imbecile Bogus Johnson.

      1. I agree. Jeremy Corbyn (who is three times as liked as Starmer according to the LabourList poll) and all the other True Labour MP’s, members and affiliated unions, should form a United Workers Party. Including wooing Militant (Socialist Party) to join with them.

    2. As a committed Socialist and Corbyn supporter I’m now left with no party willing to represent me. In 2017 I gave the Labour Party over £100 towards its election fund, I now find out that they conned that money out of me so they could stop a decent fair man from becoming our prime minister and really make a difference and instead put a man in as leader who will support the establishment continue to return to business as usual. A Tory wearing a red rosette is still a Tory.

    3. The UK Deep State has neutered the Labour Party. Again. Blair was bad enough but now the MI5 plant Starmer is, and will become, even worse. Britain needs a better Socialist party. Corbyn should start a “Real Labour Party” now so they will be able to cammand respect by the time Britain gets the chance to replace this misbegotten shambolicking Tory party.

      The Real Labour Party – Really for the many and definitely not the few wealthy people financing the Tories.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.