The indignation and downright rage at Dominic Cummings’ actions isn’t going anywhere. And nor should it. People across the country have seen loved ones die alone, cared for children while sick, and been unable to see their families. We have all taken action that goes against our instincts. And we’ve taken that action for the greater good. It’s because we’ve wanted to control the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic that the majority of us have followed the rules. Because the majority of us can work out that it’s not about what’s right for us, it’s about what’s right for society as a whole.
Cummings might deny that he’s done anything wrong or broken any laws. He might not have any regrets. He may think that he took the steps any reasonable parent would – well any reasonable parent who had a whole separate house to travel to on a family estate might take (yep – hands up who that applies to!). However, outside of cabinet members and Daily Mail commentator Dan Hodges, it’s hard to find anyone who agrees with that analysis.
But while Cummings was taking his jaunt to Durham, let’s take a look at what police across the UK were doing on those days. Because they clearly show that there’s one rule for the elite and another rule for the rest of us
Policing the coronavirus
When the new coronavirus powers were introduced, the Network for Police Monitoring (Netpol) and the Undercover Research Group (URG) set up an online diary to:
monitor the everyday impact of the new policing powers and whether they are used proportionately.
And policing has been extreme, and in some cases distressing and horrific. For example, a Black man was tasered in front of his young child at a petrol station in Manchester. As the Guardian reported:
Shortly after he puts the child, who can be heard screaming “Daddy” throughout the footage, on the ground, the man is Tasered by one of the policemen.
Read on...Support us and go ad-free
Meanwhile in London, the Met police used the pandemic as a reason to increase its number of stop and searches despite this being irrelevant to coronavirus law. In some London boroughs, the number of stop and searches was twice as high in April as it was in March.
27 – 30 March
On 27 March, despite his wife having symptoms of coronavirus, and government instructions that the whole household should self-isolate, Cummings drove hundreds of miles to Durham. The following morning, Cummings woke up with symptoms of coronavirus. Durham police confirm that they were made aware that he had travelled there on 30 March.
Here are some examples from the Policing the Coronavirus blog of actions the police took against individuals during those dates. And it’s important to remember that these actions weren’t even taken against symptomatic people or those from symptomatic households as Cummings was. Some were even taken against key workers:
In West Yorkshire, Netpol reported that it had been informed police officers had yesterday stopped two care workers, both in their uniforms, who were sharing a car on the way to work a 12-hour shift together at an old people’s home. The driver was fined £60. The two-metre social distancing rule cannot apply to them, as many residents they support require two carers.
fined six people over the weekend, including for being ‘out for a drive due to boredom’ and ‘multiple people from the same household going to the shops for non-essential items’.
And in Manchester:
A man with a history of mental health problems [has] been ordered to pay a £500 fine, £85 prosecution costs and a £50 victim surcharge after he refused to obey coronavirus lockdown restrictions.
Police were out in force to ensure the rules weren’t broken during a sunny bank holiday weekend. And while Cummings took a drive to test his eyesight (and really, this ludicrous and dangerous excuse is beyond words) this is how the police were enforcing the lockdown.
In Manchester, a man was violently arrested for the crime of “taking a tree from his mum’s house”:
Greater Manchester Police officer making an arrest because someone had "broken the rules" for taking a tree from his mum's house pic.twitter.com/IpCvBl8mTJ
— Netpol (@netpol) April 10, 2020
And the day before Cummings sat on a bench in Barnard Castle, in Glasgow:
a disabled woman returning home very heavy groceries was threatened with a fine for sitting down to rest because she “wasn’t exercising”.
"She was told to stop feeding her baby while out walking in the park as " it's not essential or exercise" pic.twitter.com/4OoxbOEqLv
— Netpol (@netpol) April 10, 2020
Other police enforcement taking place included forcing people to move on:
And in Chesterfield:
police had to issue an apology to a disabled man for [a] ‘misunderstanding’ over gardening after his friend was threatened with a fine for helping him, despite the government advice specifically listing support for vulnerable people as a reason to leave home.
One law for them. One law for us.
The letter of the law is often wrong, misguided, or misleading, whether it’s coronavirus or any other aspect of the legal system. This isn’t a piece arguing that we should all always follow the rules or that there was any justification in the police’s actions. In most of the cases in this piece, their actions were at worst unlawful, and at best misguided and overreaching. And in the case of coronavirus, most of us follow the rules because, however difficult, it’s the right thing to do, not because we’ve been coerced by the state to do it.
But that’s not the point. The point is this is how ordinary citizens, those of us not part of the ruling elite, have been and are being treated. Cummings showed pure arrogance in taking the trip. And in not even apologising, let alone resigning, he’s displayed breathtaking contempt for every single person who has acted not in their own best interests but in the interests of society as a whole.
However, we shouldn’t be surprised. It’s a clear manifestation of the contempt Conservative-led governments have treated us with for over ten years. After all, this is a party that punished the poorest people in society to bail out the richest. It’s a government that instituted a policy of austerity that a report found caused at least 130,000 deaths.
Self-interest is at the heart of Conservative government policy. This has always been clear. Cummings’ actions are just the latest in a long line of government actions that benefit the elite while giving a giant fuck-you to ordinary working people.
The Tories have been fighting a class war against poor and vulnerable people for years. This latest incident is just a stark reminder of exactly how ruthless they are. The question for the rest of us remains the same – what are we going to do about it?
Do your bit for independent journalism
Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.
We need you to help out, if you can.
When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.
You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.
In return you get:
- Advert free reading experience
- Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
- 20% discount from our shop