‘Threat to life’ still priority in Whaley Bridge dam drama, residents warned

The Canary

A minority of people refusing to leave their homes amid fears of a damaged dam bursting are “taking their lives into their own hands”, a police chief has warned.

Thirty-one residents, including a “small number” who were initially evacuated but have since returned to their homes, remain in 22 properties in the evacuation zone in the town of Whaley Bridge despite warnings of catastrophic consequences if the the dam at Toddbrook Reservoir collapses.

On Monday, Derbyshire’s police and crime commissioner, Hardyal Dhindsa, acknowledged that locals had faced a “big disruption” as the around-the-clock operation to return to normal as quickly as possible continued but he stressed the number one priority remained “threat to life”.

Start your day with The Canary News Digest

Fresh and fearless; get excellent independent journalism from The Canary, delivered straight to your inbox every morning.




Summer weather August 5th 2019
Work is carried out to drain the Toddbrook Reservoir (Danny Lawson/PA)

Speaking to up to 100 people packed into Taxal and Fernilee Primary School, he said: “It’s a big disruption for you all and I understand that, the emergency authorities understand that and we want to get back to normality as quickly as possible but please bear with us because the number one priority is life and threat to life.

“We don’t want anyone to be devastated.

“We want to make sure we protect the properties of everybody.

“That is going to be difficult when there is an evacuation.

“There is a minority number of people not wanting to leave their properties and they are taking their lives into their own hands.

“Police officers are going out to encourage them to come away until it is totally safe.”

Also addressing the meeting, Labour MP for High Peak, Ruth George, said it was hoped that inspections would be able to take place on Tuesday afternoon or evening as water continued to be drained from the reservoir.

She said: “I think they have dropped it about four metres now which is really good to see but they want it to go down another four metres so it is below the level of where the hole in the front of the dam is so that they know it is safe and then they can get the engineers properly looking at it and say ‘right is the whole structure safe?’.

“They are aiming, if all goes well and if we don’t get any rain, that some time tomorrow afternoon or evening that they might get to that level that they can inspect and then a decision will be made.”

Dhindsa added: “Obviously there will be some sort of review into what happened, whether it could have been averted but that is for later until we secure the site and the water level is low enough.”

Summer weather August 5th 2019
Labour Leader Jeremy Corbyn looks at the Toddbrook Reservoir (Danny Lawson/PA)

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn attended the meeting and also viewed the ongoing repair work at the reservoir.

He said: “Incredible response by the community, the volunteers and I think really in co-ordination between the Environment Agency, the Canals and Rivers Turst, the county council, local authorities, police, RAF, everybody… really efficient.

“What you see is this incredible spirit around working so well together.

“I went out to talk to the construction workers who are repairing the dam.

“Well you have to just admire the skill of dropping a lot of aggregate in pinpoint accuracy and then back filling with concrete and further aggregate which they are doing now.

“Impressive but obviously the water levels have got to go down.

WEATHER WhaleyBridge
(PA Graphics)

“That’s happening and hopefully people will be able to return to their homes but of course there has to be then the question of long term repair to the dam and the safety of it in the future.”

Asked if he thought an inquiry should take place, Corbyn replied: “Yes there has to be an inquiry.

“An inquiry to make sure all the co-ordination worked effectively and everything I have seen shows it did but there are always lessons to be learned.”

More than 1,500 people have been evacuated from the town since Thursday following heavy rain.

Fire chiefs have said specialist engineers have monitored the dam wall 24 hours a day with lasers and are reassured by their assessment, with a seven-day estimate for how long people would be out of their homes a “worst case scenario”.

On Monday, Colin Winterbottom, station manager at Derbyshire Fire and Rescue Service, said that “around 30-40%” of the water at Toddbrook Reservoir had been removed over the last five days, adding that another day of work will “probably see the dam down to a safe level”.

Since you're here ...

We know you don't need a lecture. You wouldn't be here if you didn't care.
Now, more than ever, we need your help to challenge the rightwing press and hold power to account. Please help us survive and thrive.

The Canary Support
  • Show Comments
    1. Is it any wonder this has happened when the management of rivers and canals has been outsourced to a charity ‘the Canals & river trust’. Private eye have run a fair number of pieces about the mismanagement of this undertaking. Is this charity up to the management of vital infrastructure such as dams?

    2. When watching press announcements made on TV by senior police officers, firemen, and other emergency services, I was impressed by their calm efficiency, their understanding of the nature of the problem faced, and concern for its impact upon residents.

      Visitation upon the residents and emergency workers by one B. Johnson was a further trial for all concerned but it was shrugged off manfully. Fortunately, they were spared disruption of their efforts by Charles Windsor and his moll; a pleasure yet to come?

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.