Nearly one in 10 workers whose wages were covered by the government have said their bosses asked them to work during furlough, which was against the rules of the scheme. At the same time, criminal gangs have syphoned off nearly £2bn in taxpayer funds allocated to help businesses and furloughed workers, according to a new report.
The revelations come in a review of the furlough scheme by the National Audit Office (NAO) which praised civil servants for pushing through employment support schemes at high speed. But the NAO said that, in their haste, they might have left some doors open for fraudsters. Auditors said HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) should have made sure that employees knew their employer was taking furlough cash, so they could challenge potential fraud.
Around 9.6 million people were put on furlough through the Coronavirus Jobs Retention Scheme, while another 2.6 million were helped through the Self-Employment Income Support Scheme. The NAO said there’s evidence that the “schemes provided an effective bridge during the early phases of the pandemic, allowing some people to return to work when the national lockdown eased”.
By the end of July, only around 5 million people were furloughed, while unemployment was broadly stable at 4%. However, the number of people on payrolls dropped by half a million between March and April. And the NAO also found that one in five people who weren’t furloughed still had their wages or hours cut.
The NAO said the furlough scheme was rushed through at breakneck speed at the start of the pandemic. HMRC’s IT team usually needs 18 months to deliver major projects, but the furlough scheme was up and running in four weeks.
But, as a result, HMRC and the Treasury had to accept a “greater risk than normal” of fraud and error. The tax office’s original working estimate was a fraud and error rate of between 5% and 10% for the furlough scheme, meaning nearly £4bn so far in cash terms.
The NAO report now says between 2.5 and 5 per cent of the total money issued to all businesses was “almost certainly” siphoned off by criminal fraudsters. This amounts to between £1bn and £1.95bn.
The auditors said that:
limiting applications to existing taxpayers should have reduced the fraud risk, but HMRC could have done more to make clear to employees whether their employer was part of the furlough scheme.
Now HMRC faces the challenge of how to chase possible fraudulent claims, or payments made in error. The department believes it would take 500 staff members to track down £275m from 10,000 of the most high-risk furlough grants. The department would have to take those workers away from its tax compliance team, which recovers even more public funds per staff member.
It takes 18 months to recruit and train new staff to perform the jobs, HMRC says, so that option is off the table. But this month the department decided to take on private contractors to do some of the work. This is despite the ongoing issues the government has had with private contractors both in the pandemic and historically.
Initially, HMRC considered publishing the names of all employers that had claimed furlough, but it later decided against this, saying it could have deterred too many legitimate claimants. Getting in touch with staff individually to say that their employer was claiming furlough cash to cover their salary, which might have alerted employees that their workplace was making fraudulent claims, was ruled out as too time-consuming.
It means that staff didn’t know if their employer was claiming money to cover their salary, unless the employer told them directly.
HMRC has no qualms against putting such measures in the Jobs Support Scheme, which is due to come into force next month when furlough ends. It will publish the names of employers who claim under the JSS and will notify employees that their workplace has claimed support money to cover their salary.
A government spokesperson said:
The Government’s priority from the start of the outbreak has been on protecting jobs and getting support to those who need it as quickly as possible, and our employment support schemes have provided a lifeline to millions of hardworking families across the UK. We make no apology for the speed at which they were delivered.
Our schemes were designed to minimise fraud from the outset and we have rejected or blocked thousands of fraudulent claims. We will not tolerate those who seek to defraud taxpayers and will take action against perpetrators, including criminal prosecution.
Do your bit for independent journalism
Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.
We need you to help out, if you can.
When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.
You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.
In return you get:
- Advert free reading experience
- Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
- 20% discount from our shop