Corbyn’s brilliant PMQs one-liner exposes the unfairness of the DWP’s most controversial benefit

Jeremy Corbyn and Boris Johnson at PMQs
Emily Apple

Jeremy Corbyn may not have long left grilling Boris Johnson as Labour leader at Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs). But his passion and ability to hold Johnson to account remains undiminished. And on 22 January, he used the opportunity to expose the unfairness of the Department of Work and Pensions’ (DWP) most controversial benefit – Universal Credit.

Corbyn highlighted the fact that many Greggs workers are receiving a £300 bonus. But due to the fact that many of them are on Universal Credit, many will only receive £75.

In a brilliant one-liner, Corbyn told Johnson:

Start your day with The Canary News Digest

Fresh and fearless; get excellent independent journalism from The Canary, delivered straight to your inbox every morning.




if the Prime Minister can answer that question, and show me that’s just and fair, I’ll buy him a vegan roll from Greggs myself.

“The government is punishing, not supporting, people”

Corbyn made it clear that the aim of Universal Credit was to make work pay. But as he pointed out:

when low-paid workers can’t even keep their own bonuses, it’s clear the government is punishing, not supporting, people.

He then asked if the PM will:

do something to ensure that workers at companies like Greggs on low pay will be allowed to keep their bonuses?

Unsurprisingly, Johnson’s response won’t give much comfort to Greggs workers, given that he refused to answer the question directly. Instead, he spoke about “cutting national insurance” and claimed that “people on low pay will be able to keep more of the money that they earn”.

Corporate welfare

As Steve Topple previously argued in The Canary, this could be described as “corporate welfare”. After all, according to journalist Ally Fogg, one worker described it as “hand[ing] £7m back to the govt”.

No wonder Johnson doesn’t want to make any promises regarding the bonus. His government must be rubbing its hands in glee at its sudden windfall.

Ultimately, though, the situation sums up the sorry state of the DWP and Universal Credit. Workers are punished, and the government pockets the difference.

At least with Corbyn at the despatch box, Johnson is held to account for these decisions. We just need to hope that whoever the Labour Party elects as its new leader continues to do so.

Featured image via Twitter screengrab

Since you're here ...

We know you don't need a lecture. You wouldn't be here if you didn't care.
Now, more than ever, we need your help to challenge the rightwing press and hold power to account. Please help us survive and thrive.

The Canary Support
  • Show Comments
    1. Using the words “Corbyn” and “brilliant” in the same sentence is just laughable! As for Corbyn’s “ability to hold Johnson to account” you must be joking! Corbyn has just gifted the Tories an 80-seat majority and at least 10 years in power, so Corbyn and Labour are now utterly powerless.

    2. “At least with Corbyn at the despatch box, Johnson is held to account for these decisions. We just need to hope that whoever the Labour Party elects as its new leader continues to do so.”

      Amen

    3. The DWP contributes back to the Treasury on the back of low wage earners. Allowing the Corporations to increase their profits. Hardly a Benefit to those having to claim extra money for a living wage. Just the same as Housing Benefit should be renamed Landlord benefit. Thanks for nothing Dr Death, regards from a disability claimant.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.