The Tories appear to have leaked the controversial ‘Tier 4’ plans to a journalist whose main Twitter account is “out of order“. Because well before Boris Johnson announced more stringent pandemic restrictions, Twitter knew the full details – courtesy of a Rupert Murdoch editor. But this editor shared the news via a “secondary” account. All in all, the chaos is peak 2020.
Hi, I’m Carolin64723572. I have breaking news.
Looking at the time stamp, it appears Caroline Wheeler was one of the first journalists to share the details of the government putting London, the South East, and the East of England into a Tier 4 category of restrictions. The Sunday Times deputy political editor tweeted at 1:32pm on 19 December:
BREAKING: Christmas cancelled for London, South East and East, as areas moved into new Tier 4 with “stay at home” message by law. Christmas bubbles only allowed for Tiers 1 – 3 on Xmas Day with “stay local message”. International travel not advised. Latest plan. @cazjwheeler
— Caroline Wheeler (@Carolin64723572) December 19, 2020
Her colleague Gabriel Pogrund quickly shared it at 1:38pm. The Spectator‘s Isabel Hardman wasn’t far behind at 1:45pm. BBC political editor Laura Kuenssberg followed at 2:16pm, then ITV‘s Paul Brand at 2:29pm.
And as we now know, Wheeler’s news was indeed correct. But what was curious about the situation was that she tweeted it from what one journalist called a “very suspect-looking” account. Other people on Twitter noticed this:
Why is Caroline Wheeler of the Times tweeting from an account that looks as if it's a bot?
— junesim63 (@JuneSim63) December 19, 2020
Many big journalists retweeting this right now. Note the account has only one tweet and claims to be Caroline Wheeler, Deputy Pol Ed of the Sunday Times. While what it suggests seems realistic, let's wait for some corroboration. https://t.co/v3wVJaO9r6
— Daniel Hordon (@danielhordon) December 19, 2020
Freelance journalist Katherine Denkinson reported that the account was indeed Wheeler’s:
Govt incompetence aside, the very suspect-looking acct breaking the news does belong to Caroline Wheeler. I emailed her Sunday Times address to check and she confirmed it. #CovidChristmas pic.twitter.com/DXx119GSsZ
— Katherine Denkinson (@KDenkWrites) December 19, 2020
Wheeler herself confirmed this:
Sorry for any confusion over my account. I’m locked out of my normal account @cazjwheeler as it’s linked to an old email. Please @TwitterSupport can you sort it out? Have been asking for help for months…
— Caroline Wheeler (@Carolin64723572) December 19, 2020
So, what’s the issue?
sorry, they’ve leaked the news to a journalist who’s locked out of her own account? this country is a joke
— edie (@multiplebears) December 19, 2020
Oh, and this:
That Caroline Wheeler didn't tweet for an entire year! Then suddenly is on Twitter, having to use a secondary account to spread the Governments leaks for them. Outrageous, embarrassing and transparent asf.
— Sir Antifa QC (@CineBlah) December 19, 2020
Wheeler’s tweet, and the subsequent flurry of other Westminster journalists repeating the details, is full-on “client journalism”.
What a bunch of clients
Client journalism is where the government uses reporters for its own agenda. Peter Oborne wrote about this for openDemocracy. He noted an example where both BBC and ITV political editors Laura Kuenssberg and Robert Peston quoted an unnamed government source in 2019. Here the news they put out was, as Oborne said, “fake”, with no basis in fact. But the two corporate journalists pushed it anyway.
Oborne explained why this happens. He said corporate media outlets:
yearn for privileged access… And they are prepared to pay a price to get it.
This price involves becoming a subsidiary part of the government machine. It means turning their readers and viewers into dupes.
This client journalism allows Downing Street to frame the story as it wants. Some allow themselves to be used as tools to smear the government’s opponents. They say goodbye to the truth. Social media has provided new ways of breaking the boundaries of decent, honest journalism.
But the situation with Wheeler and that tweet is even more batshit, for want of a better phrase.
Tier 4 + weird client journalism = peak 2020
The UK has become accustomed to the Tories leaking info to journalists like Kuenssberg and Peston. It is par for the course in a world where the notion of a free press hasn’t actually existed for decades. Or, as Noam Chomsky called it in 1988, the idea of Manufacturing Consent – where the media serves to further the interests of the establishment class. But for the Tories to leak the Tier 4 info to a journalist with no functioning main Twitter account is bizarre.
Were they trying to make the ‘is Wheeler’s account a bot or not’ the story? Did they not realise she didn’t have access to her main Twitter account? Who knows. Interestingly, the Sunday Times article on Johnson’s announcement was by Wheeler and Pogrund. It was published at 6pm on 19 December. And it pushed the Tories’ line that the “mutant coronavirus” strain was to blame for Christmas being cancelled.
But the leak in itself, and then the press conference, created panic in London and an exodus of people from the capital. Overall, events on 19 December summed up this Tory government: incompetent, chaotic, farcical but still pretending it’s in control. And they also summed up the establishment corporate media: servile and lickspittling to the bitter end.
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?