Jewish professor tells people like new peer John Mann to stop ‘weaponising antisemitism’

Professor David Graeber and John Mann
Support us and go ad-free

Theresa May’s ‘Resignation Honours’ list came out on 10 September. And it elevated former Labour right-winger John Mann – now the government’s “antisemitism tsar” – to the House of Lords. Mann has long been pushing the narrative of a ‘crisis’ in the Labour Party.

Meanwhile, a Jewish professor has written a scathing article asking people like Mann (who is not Jewish) to stop ‘weaponising antisemitism’ to attack Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn.

“A clear and present danger”

London School of Economics professor David Graeber wrote:

I am 58 years old, and for the first time in my life, I am frightened to be Jewish.

He explained:

our political class has come to a consensus that the greatest threat to Britain’s Jewish community is a lifelong anti-racist [Jeremy Corbyn]…

For almost all my Jewish friends, this is what is currently creating the greatest and most immediate sense of trepidation, even more than the actual Nazis: the apparently endless campaign by politicians like Margaret Hodge, Wes Streeting, and Tom Watson to weaponize antisemitism accusations against the current leadership of the Labour party. It is a campaign – which however it started, has been sustained primarily by people who are not themselves Jewish – so cynical and irresponsible that I genuinely believe it to be a form of antisemitism in itself. And it is a clear and present danger to Jewish people.

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free

And directing himself to politicians pushing this narrative, he said:

I am begging you: if you really do care about Jews, please, stop this.

“Our strongest allies”

Graeber highlighted that:

Antisemitism can be found on almost every level of British society…

Surveys show that antisemitic attitudes are more common among supporters of the ruling Conservative party than Labour supporters. But the latter are in no sense immune.

But he also stressed:

There is evidence that in the first two years under Corbyn (20152017)… the prevalence of antisemitic attitudes among Labour supporters were sharply declining.

And slamming the right-wing smear campaign against Corbyn’s party, he said:

exploiting Jewish issues in ways guaranteed to create rancor, panic, and resentment is itself a form of antisemitism. … It creates terror in the Jewish community. It deprives us of our strongest allies.

Crying wolf “while real wolves are baying at the door”

Graeber also insisted that the anti-Corbyn attacks are all the more dangerous because of the growing power of the far right, saying:

As the racist right gains power and legitimacy across Europe, the very last thing we need is to leave the public with the impression the Jewish community are a bunch of hypersensitive alarmists who start screaming about Auschwitz the moment they disagree with the exact wording of policy statement. It’s crazy to cry wolf while real wolves are baying at the door. It’s even crazier when those you’re crying wolf about are the very people most likely to defend you against them.

According to recent reports:

The number of right-wing extremists in custody under terror laws last year increased to the highest level on record, official figures show.

If fascists start targeting “Jewish left intellectuals such as myself”, Graeber stressed:

Corbyn and his supporters will be the first to place their bodies on the line

And pleading with people pushing the smear campaign to “stop making things worse”, he asserted:

My safety is not your political chess piece.

Stamp out all racism. Stop using it as a “political chess piece”.

Numerous reports and polls show that antisemitism exists across society; but it’s most common among far-right groups. Mainstream media outlets, however, have faced accusations of “misleading”, ‘distorted’, and “inaccurate” coverage which exaggerates the scale of antisemitism allegations in the Labour Party – a party which has taken consistently firm action in recent years. As Graeber said:

Antisemitism accusations against Labour reportedly relate to 0.06% of the party’s 500,000+ members.

Islamophobia, meanwhile, seems to be endemic in the Conservative Party. The ruling party has faced numerous allegations of antisemitism and other forms of racism, too. Tell Mama says that in the days after anti-Muslim comments from current PM Boris Johnson the number of Islamophobic hate crimes rose by 375%. Yet it seems John Mann – now in charge of ‘independently’ challenging antisemitism – has a blind spot on the above; he has made almost no comments about it on Twitter. He also previously faced criticism for his own behaviour towards the Gypsy Traveller community.

As Graeber says, the far right is currently “baying at the door”. So we don’t only need to defeat racism; we also need to call out the politicians playing dangerously cynical political games. Because far from helping, they’re making things even worse.

Featured image via Wikimedia – Thomas Altfather Good / YouTube – BBC News

Support us and go ad-free

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. While one may congratulate Labour MP John Mann now as Lord Mann – one can’t help but feel his elevation to The Lords by a former Tory prime minister is to be regarded a political and pernicious ploy to ‘give a poke’ by Mrs May at the Labour party – and particularly, to embarrass the Rt Hon Jeremy Corbyn MP leader of HM’s opposition Labour Party against whom John Mann MP has delivered such personal ongoing bile.

    2. Graeber is quite right. It is a very dangerous game. Stalwart anti-racists like Corbyn and Chris Williamson are portrayed as antisemites. Many members of the same ilk have been suspended or expelled. Meanwhile, the real racists are gaining ground. Graeber is right, if the fascists come for the Jews or anyone else, we will be the first to stand in their way. There is a problem, however. If Chris Williamson stands up to fascists, the public, misled by the foolish accusers and the supine media, will ask: “But isn’t he an antisemite?” By defining those of us who face down all racism as racists because we criticise the Israeli State and Zionism, the accusers are removing the strongest bulwark against the far-right. What is the likely public reaction? Won’t many people be too confused to know what to believe? Won’t that play into the hands of the far-right?
      The fact has to be faced: apologists for the Israeli State and Zionism are willing to sow lies and confusion to uphold their position. The result will not be the safety of Jews in the UK, but an opportunity for fascists to attack, in every way. This dirty game, played to undermine Corbyn because he upholds the rights of the Palestinians, will not result in Jews being able to cast the Labour Party as antisemitic and to call on it for help when fascists engage in their nefarious actions. John Mann is not Jewish, it appears. His stance is grossly irresponsible and is basely motivated. Most people on the left in the UK are anti-racists. Corbyn is. Williamson is. By trying to uphold an indefensible position on Israel/Palestine, the accusers ensure only the increasing insecurity of Jews in the UK.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.