Young doctor being told to leave UK ‘defies basic common sense’

The Canary

Campaigners have said the UK’s immigration system “defies basic common sense” after a young doctor who has spent the majority of her life in the country was asked to leave.

Mu-Chun Chiang, 27, has lived in the UK for over 13 years but, due to what she describes as “a nonsensical administrative issue”, her application for a new visa was rejected and the home office told her to leave the UK or risk up to six months’ imprisonment.

“When I got the letter I was shocked, all these things were going on in my head,” Chiang told the PA news agency.

Start your day with The Canary News Digest

Fresh and fearless; get excellent independent journalism from The Canary, delivered straight to your inbox every morning.




“I was worried because we were already understaffed on our ward and leaving all my friends would be really heartbreaking.”

Originally from Taiwan, Chiang lived in Glasgow from 1997 to 2002 with her parents before returning to the UK in 2006 to study – and has lived here since, now working at Aintree University Hospital in Liverpool.

An image of Dr Chiang growing up on Glasgow
Dr Chiang grew up in Glasgow (Courtesy of Mu-Chun Chiang)

After Chiang’s student visa expired in June, her application for a new working visa was rejected in August due to a home office rule which states an applicant’s bank balance cannot drop below £945 in the 90 days beforehand.

Chiang said she had more than that amount saved and the bank account she used for the application had the correct money by the end of each month, but had dropped below for a few days in one of them.

She appealed against the failure by sending details of a separate savings account to show she always had the money required, but this was declined as it was not provided with the initial application.

Chiang then received a letter on Friday from the home office telling her the application was unsuccessful, and that she “must leave the UK now” or she would “be liable to be detained and removed”.

The letter from the Home Office
Dr Chiang read the home office letter on Friday (Mu-Chun Chiang)

The letter said she could be prosecuted, adding that she cannot work or access benefits while in the UK, and despite being on call she has been unable to work at her hospital in Liverpool since.

Her lead employer also called her on Tuesday to tell her that because the letter is dated to September 19 there is a possibility she will not get paid for the shifts she has done since then.

“At a time when our NHS is under immense strain and crying out for more doctors, kicking out a young doctor trained to work in the NHS just defies basic common sense,” Satbir Singh, chief executive of the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants (JCWI), told PA.

“Our immigration system is dysfunctional, complicated and inhumane.

“That someone can be threatened with detention and removal because of a small technical mistake in a visa application highlights the urgent need for the system to be rebuilt from ground up so that people who move here are treated fairly and with humanity.”

After receiving the letter, Chiang’s friend Mina Mesri set up a petition calling for her to be allowed to stay in the UK, which has received over 25,000 signatures in a matter of days.

Her friend also encouraged her to contact a solicitor, and she has spoken with two lawyers this week.

Mu-Chun Chiang and Mina Mesri
Dr Chiang and her friend Mina Mesri who set up the petition (Mina Mesri)

“I’m quite lucky as I’ve got a lot of people supporting me,” said Chiang.

“I know from other people that there have been cases where people have just packed up and gone, because they didn’t know what else to do.”

After PA contacted the home office and Chiang, she said she was contacted by the immigration authority by phone, who told her they would like to review the evidence of her case again.

The home office had not responded to PA’s request for comment by the time of publication.

Since you're here ...

We know you don't need a lecture. You wouldn't be here if you didn't care.
Now, more than ever, we need your help to challenge the rightwing press and hold power to account. Please help us survive and thrive.

The Canary Support
  • Show Comments
    1. Young doctor being told to leave UK ‘defies basic common sense’
      Just this question to ask Boris + his Tory incompetent Minister
      Will you not need the person to staff the new Hospital you are promising us voter yes or no?
      //
      Or is it another lie from Tory Govt for our votes in new G.E. possible in 2019 and your promise of new Hospital will never unfold Boris like the increase in fully trained up and fully vetted Police Officers you and your Minister rant on about Boris.
      //
      So, by look of this article we ill patens of U.K. will or could lose another Good Doctor living in U.K. now WHY Boris???
      You need staff like this in the old Hospital your Govt stripped of staff plus cut more funding to Hospital front line staff.
      Tory Minister need to get their act together now before G.E. TIME

    2. Young doctor being told to leave UK ‘defies,
      basic common sense’
      ///////
      Been doing some home on the increase in Govt member getting fast tracked appointment to have small O,P s done over the time frame when Parliament was shut I found it eye opening what I uncovered how the M.P. + Minister alike do not have to wait for any treatment now.
      ///
      But the old people plus us have our O.P.s put back all the time according to our N.H.S Tory health Minister things are getting better for us JOE/public So can he tell me why the Govt member take our spots from O.P.s now and we are put back to be seen or Operated on now sometime the time frame can be for years for us to wait WHY?
      ///
      To Tory Govt is this problem unfolding now because you Tory Govt intend or are hell bent to sell off our N.H.S. to privet insurances firm in U.S./China/Partisan /India and the like after we leave E.U. in Oct 2019?
      So Govt member are getting their health needs seen now before we leave E.U. so it cost them nothing for the treatment NOW?
      //
      But will cost us all after Oct 2019 W/Day with E.U. a fee at the front desk to be looked at by any N.H.S. Hospital or anything run under N.H.S. C.C.G. serves. This will or could start to unfold I be-leave after Oct W/Day residents of U.K./Wales/ N/Ireland/Scotland as well Tory Govt is using our N.H.S. to complete deals possibly or maybe selling it OFF peace by peace to privet firms outside of U.K. area.
      ///
      If am wrong, please prove ME Wrong Tory Govt tell me plus the rest of the resident of all of U.K. Give us NOW a CAST IRON PLEDGE our N.H.S. will not be sold off
      In any shape or foam Now after W/Day Boris, remembering they is a G.E. on it way in 2019 voters will need this pledge before the G.E. time

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.