Psychology expert says blaming Russia for Trump was an easy way out for a ‘traumatised’ US society

Gabor and Aaron Maté
Support us and go ad-free

With the completion of the Mueller report, nobody was indicted for colluding with Russia to influence the 2016 election. The report’s findings caused major humiliation for those who have spent the past three years building a conspiracy linking Donald Trump’s campaign to the Kremlin. Indeed, many of those who aggressively pushed the Russiagate narrative are still struggling to let it go.

Looking at individual and collective trauma within US society, however, can help to explain why so many people believed Russia was responsible for the rise of Trump. On 7 May, the Grayzone published an interview between Dr Gabor Maté and his son, award-winning journalist Aaron Maté. In it, they discussed the psychology of Russiagate.

The psychological angle

As Aaron Maté explained:

I don’t think that we can understand what we went through in Russiagate without understanding the psychological angle.

And Gabor Maté is a best-selling author who has produced extensive work in the field of psychology. So he was a good person to analyse that angle. For him, so many people bought the Russiagate narrative because:

Emotionally they were invested in it. It wasn’t just that they wanted to know the truth; they actually wanted the truth to look a certain way. Whenever we want… the truth to look a certain way, there’s some reason which has to do with our own emotional needs and not just with [our] concern for reality.

Trump’s election victory shocked the world. Surveys conducted just three days before the election suggested that Hillary Clinton had a “more than 99% chance” of winning. And many felt that Trump’s conduct was at odds with an (apparently) otherwise liberal country. As Gabor Maté continued:

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free

What does [Trump’s election] say about the divisions and the conflicts and the contradictions and the genuine problems in this culture, and how do we address those issues? You can look at that, or you can say there must be a devil somewhere behind all this; and that devil is a foreign power, and his name is Putin and his country’s Russia.

Now you’ve got a simple explanation that doesn’t invite you… [to] explore your own pain and your own fear and your own trauma. So I really believe that this Russiagate narrative was – on the part of a lot of people – a sign of genuine upset… But rather than dealing with the upset, it was an easier way to… draw off the energy of it into some kind of a believable and comforting narrative.

Donald Trump

As the conversation moved to Trump himself, Gabor Maté described the US president as “the clearest example of a traumatised politician anyone can ever see”. He continued:

He is in denial of reality all the time… His fundamental self-concept is that of a nobody… It’s a compensation for a terrible self-image… What does this all come down to? The childhood that we know that he had, in the home of a dictatorial child-disparaging father… And the fact that such a traumatised individual can be elected to the position of what they call the most powerful person in the world speaks to a traumatised society. And like individuals can be in denial, a society can be in denial.

US interference vs Russian interference

Gabor Maté then explained that we often deal with trauma by projecting our least favourite traits onto other people. This, he claims, is reflected in Washington accusing Russia of foreign interference:

It’s only a matter of historical fact… how the United States has interfered in the internal politics of just about every nation on earth… Not to mention the current interference in Venezuelan internal politics, not to mention… how the United States helped Boris Yeltsin get elected [in Russia in 1989]… Even if the worst thing that’s alleged about the Russians is true, it’s not even one minuscule proportion of what America’s publicly acknowledged it’s done all around the world.


Like any country, the US cannot achieve societal change without an honest and critical evaluation of its own character. Almost three years have been wasted on Russiagate; it’s time for US citizens to look for real answers.

Featured image via the Grayzone

Support us and go ad-free

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. @ 23:55 “The public needs to have some historical memory…” And, he ends with ‘disillusion’ with the state of things is a good thing – as being disillusioned enables objectivity in looking again toward understanding the truth about political, and other personal, scenarios. Did I put that right? This reminds me of my own UK’s membership of the EU where parliament and certain elites is and are stuck in some quagmire of righteous superior knowability that the UK should remain in the EU against a bunch of ‘simple electoral folk’ who, against all expectation, want out and successfully voted democratically in a referendum against remaining in the European Union. The UK hasn’t left the EU after three years because ‘a bunch of elites’ are working hammer ‘n tongs to reverse what ‘the simple folk’ want. Underhand, albeit benign dictatorship, or what? Or, am I being ’emotional’ about this which, as we know from Mr Maté ‘s view, skews objectivity whether to remain or leave the EU? What I’m noticing is that Mr Gabor Maté ‘s analysis of President Trump and the USA can be borrowed to view Britain’s present political impasse re European Union membership. I’d love to hear the father and son discourse on the nature of antisemitism which is a big thing levelled against Britain’s burgeoning left particular being horribly accusatory directly at Mr Corbyn the Labour Party leader who potentially could be the next UK Prime Minister after the EU membership fiasco is finally sorted.

    2. This is the first sentence of the Mueller report: “The Russian government interfered in the 2016 presidential election in sweeping and systematic fashion.” A gentle suggestion: consider reading the report, which is quite terrifying, and amply justifies the Mueller investigation.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.