Chris Grayling’s privatisation of the probation service was so flawed, the government is planning to renationalise it

Chris Grayling and David Gauke
Support us and go ad-free

The government is reportedly planning to renationalise the probation service. Prison reform campaigners have welcomed the news. But it only comes after the Conservatives’ own disastrous reforms to the sector.

Criticised from the outset

On May 10, the Times reported that justice secretary David Gauke was “preparing to renationalise probation”.

Former justice secretary Chris Grayling handed over a large part of the probation service to private companies in 2014. Grayling broke up 35 state-run probation trusts and gave 21 privately-run companies responsibility for low- and medium-risk offenders. High-risk offenders remained under supervision of the state.

Grayling claimed the £800m privatisation process would help tackle high reoffending rates. But his plans were criticised from the outset. The Observer reported in 2013 on an internal assessment made for the Ministry of Justice (MoJ). It wrote:

On a scale of one to 25, where 25 is the highest likelihood of something happening, the assessment gives a maximum score to the probability that there will be a “reduction [in] performance” under the new system. It states that this will see the “potential for service delivery failure increase” and that there is a very high chance of “operational confusion”. As a result, offenders will pose a “higher risk to the public” and there will be “poorer outcomes” for victims and communities.

Furthermore, reoffending rates have increased. Between July 2013 and June 2014, just prior to Grayling’s scheme, the MoJ said 24.9% of adults reoffended. But data for April to June 2017, the most recent available, showed 29.2% of adults reoffended.

“Optimism bias”

This appeared to have been borne out by a recent review by the public accounts committee (PAC). On 3 May, it said that the government:

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free

created an underfunded and fragile probation market and we are not confident in its ability to cope with further provider failure. … The Ministry [of Justice] failed to realise that a payment by results model was not appropriate for probation or that reoffending was not a good measure of performance for CRCs.

The PAC also noted that part of the problem came from the MoJ’s “optimism bias”. As a result, it said that “unnecessary risks” were taken with public money.

The PAC asked the Ministry of Justice to offer a plan for the sector by June. Although a final decision hadn’t yet been made, the Times said renationalisation of the privately-run rehabilitation companies is Gauke’s preferred method of achieving this.

“We will face another rush to act”

Frances Crook, CEO of prison reform charity the Howard League, welcomed the news. She said the charity “recommends [a] national strategy with local delivery linked to other services”. Meanwhile, shadow justice secretary Richard Burgon said the Tories must ‘commit fully’ to bringing probation back into state ownership. Former chair of the Parole Board for England and Wales, Nick Hardwick, said renationalisation “would be welcome” too. But he also pointed out that any plans must be careful about separating “support” of offenders from “supervision” of offenders.

Professor of criminology, James Treadwell, voiced concern that “we will face another rush to act” in solving the probation service’s problems. There’s no doubt then that Gauke must listen before he acts on this issue.

Featured image via Chris McAndrew / Wikimedia

Support us and go ad-free

Do your bit for independent journalism

Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.

We need you to help out, if you can.

When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.

You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.

In return you get:

  • Advert free reading experience
  • Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
  • 20% discount from our shop


The Canary Fund us
  • Show Comments
    1. Chris Grayling’s privatisation of the probation service was so flawed, the government is planning to renationalise it.

      Well Grayling, you have also trashed our transport after you became the T/ Minister. You’re party Minister, this article also says you trashed the probation service as well.

      “I have also taken note you are in hiding now, I have not seen you Mr. Grayling in House of Commons Why?”

      You have just been sending your puppet to answer for your dirty deeds with the transport deals in back rooms of the Government.

      You personally made that cost us, the taxpayer millions of pounds to put right, your crooked deals and also your incompetent to hold any Job in Government now, when are your leaving your post Mr. Grayling?

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.