During the Thursday morning rush hour, Extinction Rebellion (XR) scored a massive “own goal”, according to critics. Because by targeting a Tube train in east London with a protest, an XR activist revealed an apparent disconnect between the movement and ordinary working-class communities. And the situation soon turned ugly as a result.
The global climate crisis is a massively important issue, and requires urgent action. Business as usual is most certainly not an option. But XR’s protest tactic on Thursday was a big misstep that only did harm to the cause.
After climbing on top of a train at the busy Canning Town station, an activist had drinks thrown at him by furious commuters, before being yanked from the train to the platform floor, much to the apparent delight of the cheering crowd.
One man yelled “I need to get to work, I have to feed my kids”, while others shouted insults at activists. Critics were also out in force on Twitter, angry that the “most sustainable form of travel possible” had been targeted. They also said the action had ‘alienated’ working-class people, and that activists should focus their efforts “on politicians & the top of big corporations & banks” (i.e. “those who create the problem” of climate breakdown):
Dear Extinction Rebellion,
The Tube & all modes of public transport are part of the solution to climate change, not the problem.
Read on...Support us and go ad-free
Can we kindly suggest you stick to protesting against those who create the problem. Not our industry, members + hard working commuters.
— ASLEF (@ASLEFunion) October 17, 2019
#extinctionrebellion protesters got it so wrong this morning:
– yes to disruption
– but not on public transport
– or targeting working class communities
Wish they would keep the focus on politicians & the top of big corporations & banks.
— Alexandra Phillips MEP 💚🍉🌎 (@alexforeurope) October 17, 2019
I'm really sad about this. I didn't want #ExtinctionRebellion to do this, such an own goal. I hope these protesters are ok. Please don't do this again. You are alienating working class people using public transport. Focus on politicians and big finance. https://t.co/c0Wn9fdHq9
— Adam McGibbon 🌍 (@AdamMcGibbon) October 17, 2019
Yo Extinction Rebellion:
1. Change your tactics, we support the cause.
2. Disrupting working class East Londoners doesn’t help anyone
3. Focus on the fossil fuel capitalist class and how to disrupt them
4. Solidarity against the London-wide ban on protest
— Hasan Patel 🌹 (@CorbynistaTeen) October 17, 2019
Others highlighted that, for meaningful change to happen, activists very much “need” working-class people’s backing:
In an era of populism effective political action needs an enemy. The enemy is not working class Londoners who use the most sustainable form of travel possible.
This is why green politics without organised labour will not win. pic.twitter.com/VImuZ91vRL
— Aaron Bastani (@AaronBastani) October 17, 2019
I am all for @ExtinctionR ‘s cause but this is counter productive. Public transport is key in tackling climate change. Pissing off the working class is not going to help your cause. You need them. Stop this. Protest but do it peacefully and proactively.
— Leanne Brown (@LeanneEBrownie) October 17, 2019
A wrong turn for an important movement
Since last week, XR protesters have targeted London City Airport, shut down areas around parliament and the Bank of England, and blockaded Google’s HQ. But many posts on the XR London Facebook page expressed concerns that the Tube stunt was counterproductive and should not have gone ahead.
XR spokesperson Howard Rees told the PA news agency: “Was it the right thing to do? I am not sure. … I think we need to take stock of it.”
The action is the latest in a series from XR, which police have controversially banned from protesting in London. A legal bid to overturn the order is expected to reach the High Court on Thursday afternoon.
British Transport Police confirmed eight people had been arrested on suspicion of obstructing the railway on Thursday, and also urged commuters not to “take matters into their own hands”.
From bad to worse…
That wasn’t the end of the controversy, though. Because XR then apparently compared the Tube protesters to civil rights activist Rosa Parks. In a now-deleted tweet, the official XR Twitter account wrote: “Rosa Parks refused to move from the white section of the bus and our rebels refused to bequeath a dying planet to future generations by failing to #ActNow. Our #InternationalRebellion against the complicity of our governments in the climate and ecological emergency continues.”
Rosa Parks was an African-American activist in Montgomery in the US. She was arrested in 1955 for refusing to give up her seat to a white passenger after boarding a segregated bus.
For many, XR’s tweet added insult to injury:
Sorry…are you equating a bunch of middle class white people intentionally disrupting public transport in predominantly poor, working class, ethnic areas to – *checks notes* – a woman who helped pioneer the civil rights movement so black people could be seen as human beings?🥴 https://t.co/fGgs24Y4Jy
— Steve (@StephanieYeboah) October 17, 2019
Did they just compare themselves to Rosa Parks… Who had PLANNED this action and had a community behind her to support the boycott to limit the damage done to the most affected? Unlike XR? The caucasity. pic.twitter.com/CtkUcXM4pz
— nicole (@NioleLemm) October 17, 2019
Rosa Parks was part of a sophisticated network of black activists who built inclusive strategies for resistance to build *with* people, not against them, not speaking over them. Maybe learn from them? Your leaders are open about their choices + they *are* choices to be ignorant
— tej adeleye (@tej_adeleye) October 17, 2019
Disruption as a form of protest: good. Targeting working class workers using a green form of transport: bad. Invoking Rosa Parks whilst ignoring critique of your very white and racist tactics and rhetoric: truly awful.
— jess BOO-yer 👻 (@jessbowy) October 17, 2019
Others have criticised the comparison for being made during Black History Month.
We desperately need “working class solutions”
Environmental breakdown is a class issue which requires working class solutions. The Labour movement has voted to take leadership on the climate emergency with a response which puts people and planet before profit.
Backing the motion, meanwhile, Fire Brigades Union general secretary Matt Wrack said:
For too long, big businesses and corporate polluters have allowed our planet to burn… Only a comprehensive programme of government and worker-led action can bring us out of this climate emergency…
we need democratic public ownership of not just the national grid, but the big energy companies too…
working class people are the crucial agents to tackle climate change. This is a pro-worker agenda – for working class communities and for workers’ jobs…
Unlike XR’s “own goal”, Labour seems to recognise that the climate justice movement needs working-class communities and organisations on its side – and in a leading role.
Because elitist ‘solutions’ have done so little to deal with the climate crisis, revolutionary change for working communities is essential. And that most certainly does not mean targeting the green public transport these communities rely on.
Featured image and additional content via Press Association
We need your help to keep speaking the truth
Every story that you have come to us with; each injustice you have asked us to investigate; every campaign we have fought; each of your unheard voices we amplified; we do this for you. We are making a difference on your behalf.
Our fight is your fight. You’ve supported our collective struggle every time you gave us a like; and every time you shared our work across social media. Now we need you to support us with a monthly donation.
We have published nearly 2,000 articles and over 50 films in 2021. And we want to do this and more in 2022 but we don’t have enough money to go on at this pace. So, if you value our work and want us to continue then please join us and be part of The Canary family.
In return, you get:
* Advert free reading experience
* Quarterly group video call with the Editor-in-Chief
* Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
* 20% discount in our shop
Almost all of our spending goes to the people who make The Canary’s content. So your contribution directly supports our writers and enables us to continue to do what we do: speaking truth, powered by you. We have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence our vital opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right-wing mainstream media.
With your help we can continue:
* Holding political and state power to account
* Advocating for the people the system marginalises
* Being a media outlet that upholds the highest standards
* Campaigning on the issues others won’t
* Putting your lives central to everything we do
We are a drop of truth in an ocean of deceit. But we can’t do this without your support. So please, can you help us continue the fight?