There’s more to Turkey’s invasion of northern Syria than the media’s reporting

Turkish invasion of northern Syria
Support us and go ad-free

Dr Celal Cahit Agar is a lecturer at St Andrews University, School of Management. This article was co-authored with Steffen Böhm, professor in organisation studies at the University of Exeter Business School.


Turkey’s recent invasion of northern Syria – i.e. “Operation Peace Spring” – sought to displace largely Kurdish communities and establish what Turkish leader Recep Tayyip Erdoğan calls a 20-mile ‘safe zone’ alongside the Turkish-Syrian border. This has faced widespread international condemnation. But the commentaries on Turkey’s latest attack have mostly focused on the history of the Turkish-Kurdish conflict and its relation to Turkey’s alleged national security concerns and the Syrian refugee crisis. And they overlook two crucial reasons for the invasion – the economic crisis in Turkey and Erdoğan’s political challenges at home.

Economic crisis in Turkey requires radical actions beyond monetary solutions

One of the less highlighted rationales behind Turkey’s invasion of Syria is that Erdoğan’s regime is seeking to lift the economy out of the ongoing economic crisis. In fact, Turkey’s debt-driven economy has long been suffering from the structural pressures of currency-exchange-rate valuation risks and liquidity risks. The crisis has been further deepening this year, as the Turkish lira has lost value against the US dollar, the stock market has continued to decline, and government borrowing costs have become more expensive than ever before.

Furthermore, as the Fitch report underlines, Turkey’s current policy responses to the deepening economic crisis have fallen well short of stabilising the currency and economy, leading to predictions of a deepening recession unless Turkey could make a “greater effort” beyond “incomplete policy responses” to balance the large current account deficit and external financing requirements.

Here, the Turkish construction industry requires particular attention as it has been the locomotive of the Turkish economy, particularly for the last decade and a half. Nonetheless, despite being the largest employer in Turkey and the second biggest contractor in the world, long gone are its shining days.

The Turkish construction industry has been facing an oversupply crisis, demanding new profitable spaces to explore and develop. Turkey’s ‘safe zone’ plan, meanwhile, promises a $26bn-worth new market for the industry, which could boost the recovery of the Turkish economy. As a matter of fact, and quite unsurprisingly, Turkish cement firms’ shares rose for two straight days on expectations of a much-needed building boom, which Erdoğan has been looking forward to for a long time.

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free
‘National security’ as a handy tool to ease Erdoğan’s political woes at home

The second rationale that needs to be stressed here is the management of political challenges at home through a new cross-border war against the Kurds. The ‘Kurdish question’ has always been a practical tool in the hands of the ruling political elites in Turkey to maintain their political power and to ease political turbulence by reunifying right-wing nationalist civil society and political organisations under the flag of Turkish chauvinism. As we outlined previously, in the case of Academics for Peace, this handy solution has been put into practice by Erdoğan particularly after the June 2015 Turkish general elections, when Erdoğan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) failed to win a majority in parliament for a single-party government.

It’s clear that the same logic of practice has been put into action with Turkey’s military attack on the Kurds in Syria to silence growing critical voices in the midst of a worsening Turkish economy. Nevertheless, what makes Turkey’s historical anti-Kurdish strategy distinctive in the case of Syria is the geographical ‘location’ of the war. In fact, the implementation of Turkey’s historical anti-Kurdish doctrine beyond Turkey’s border allows Erdoğan to manage the political challenges faced by the regime.

In contrast to the political and military oppression of Kurds in Turkey, a cross-border operation offers a wider political ground to establish an expanded consensus between conflicting parties, since it has been portrayed as the ‘national’ interest of the Turkish people that should be defended against the ‘others’, regardless of the differences in their political opinions and class positions. As the developments in the political spheres of Turkey have shown, Turkey’s invasion of Syria has successfully united the ruling and opposition parties against the “eternal enemy” in Syria.

Building his anti-Kurdish war strategy, Erdoğan not only re-consolidates his declining power by recovering his coalition with the nationalist MHP (which has become more fragile, particularly after the 2019 Turkish local elections which saw the AKP lose key cities like Istanbul and Ankara), but he also capitalises on the Syria war by forcefully ‘acquiring’ pro-Kurdish HDP municipalities in Kurdish-majority provinces and towns in Turkey, as he simply ordered a number of Kurdish mayors to be put on trial and replaced.

It’s also obvious that, by locating the frontlines of its anti-Kurdish war beyond its national boundaries, Turkey minimises unfavourable social, political, and military outcomes of its anti-Kurdish strategy at home. More importantly, however, Erdoğan’s preference for the military presence of Turkey in Syria under the pretext of ‘national security’ provides a guaranteed seat at the table in any future negotiations over the geopolitical future of the Middle East.

Overall, Turkey’s political and military agenda in Syria cannot be understood fully by focusing solely on the Turkish-Kurdish conflict. Bigger issues are at play. The war is timely as it provides an answer to economic and political woes at home. The geopolitical future of the whole Middle East is at stake; and vested interests in Turkey want to be a part of this.

Featured image via ANF

Support us and go ad-free

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. Good accurate assessment of the simplicity of a voters mind to allow this to happen.
      Erdogan shouldn’t have any seat at the table for negotiations. He created this mess.
      This reasoning of using military force to have any crediblity at all is seriously flawed logic.
      Shows as well how the socially clever narrow minded egomaniac Erdogan is only concerned with the pursuit of power, and hasn’t the practical intelligence to rule a modern society. Wherever they rule becomes a disaster economically.
      Maybe his plan would of worked when everyone were just farmers, and iliterate. Then a huge army reigned supreme, and keeping the army well fed without any critique was doable.
      But not always.
      Things didn’t work out for the King of Sweden who persisted in a war against Peter the Great of Russia in the 18th century who ignored any critique into his reasoning. After losing a war for over 20 years he was so loathed by his populace, his fate was an unmarked grave for the misery he inflicted upon his own country.
      Or Cromwell who was dug out of his grave, and then hung, and quartered to be dragged by horses until dead?
      The challenge is to nip these people in the bud.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.