• Disrupting Power Since 2015
  • Donate
  • Login
Friday, May 16, 2025
  • Login
  • Register
Canary
MEDIA THAT DISRUPTS
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
MANAGE SUBSCRIPTION
SUPPORT
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Canary
No Result
View All Result

European rights court hears landmark climate cases against governments for first time

Alex/Rose Cocker by Alex/Rose Cocker
30 March 2023
in Global, News
Reading Time: 4 mins read
165 7
A A
0
Home Global
319
SHARES
2.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Cases against France and Switzerland opened before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) on 29 March. They concerned alleged failings to protect the environment. This marks the first time governments are in the court’s dock for alleged climate change inaction.

The case against Switzerland is based on a complaint by an association of elderly people who call themselves the ‘Club of Climate Seniors’. They’re concerned with the consequences of global warming on their living conditions and health, the ECHR said.

The Club accuses Swiss authorities of various climate change failings. These amount to a violation of the government’s obligation to protect life and citizens’ homes and families.

“We’ve been fighting for years,” said 81-year-old Bruna Molinari, adding:

I hope the court will find in our favour so that Switzerland does better than it has done so far.

The average age is 73 in the Swiss club, which is backed by Greenpeace Switzerland. Around 50 of its 2,000 members were expected in Strasbourg for the hearing.

‘Heat kills’

Alain Chablais, representing the Swiss government, told the court that it was “baseless to claim or suggest that Switzerland is doing nothing”. He added that the ECHR:

has no business becoming the place where national climate protection policy is decided.

However, the plaintiffs’ lawyer Jessica Simor said her clients were “already suffering the effects of climate change” that Switzerland was not doing enough to stop. She added that temperatures were rising “twice as quickly” in the Alpine nation as the global average:

Heat kills… increasing the risks of kidney problems, asthma attacks, cardiovascular difficulties… and causes particularly acute symptoms in elderly people, more especially elderly women.

And France, too

Damien Careme brought the case against France. Careme is a former mayor of Grande-Synthe, a suburb of Dunkirk in northern France. He also argues that the central government has failed to meet its obligation to protect life by taking insufficient steps to prevent climate change.

When he was mayor, Careme brought his case to the French judiciary on behalf of his town but also on his own behalf. He said that climate change was raising the risk of his home being flooded.

France’s highest administrative court ruled in favour of the town against the central government in 2021. However, it threw out the individual case brought by Careme, which he then took to the ECHR.

Corinne Lepage, a former French ecology minister, is one of Careme’s lawyers in the case. She told Agence France-Presse:

The stakes are extremely high… If the European court recognises that climate failings violate the rights of individuals to life and a normal family life, then that becomes precedent in all of the council’s member states and potentially in the whole world.

The European Court of Human Rights acknowledged in a statement that the European Convention on Human Rights does not actually include a right to a healthy environment. It is this Convention on which it must base its judgements. This includes the right to life:

Everyone’s right to life shall be protected by law. No one shall be deprived of his life intentionally save in the execution of a sentence of a court following his conviction of a crime for which this penalty is provided by law.

However, its decision to take the cases was based on the fact that the exercise of the convention’s existing rights could be undermined by harm to the environment or exposure to environmental risks.

A third case

A third pending case, without a date for a hearing so far, was brought by young Portuguese applicants. They’re claiming that climate inaction by dozens of states had contributed to heatwaves in Portugal. Crucially, they also claim that this heat is affecting their other rights.

Although the cases are a first for the ECHR, people have previously taken their governments to court in their national jurisdictions. For example, in 2019 the Dutch Supreme Court ordered the government to cut greenhouse gas emissions. This followed a complaint by an environmental organisation, Urgenda. As the Guardian reported:

After multiple appeals, in December 2019 the Dutch supreme court issued an extraordinary ruling upholding lower courts’ decisions that obliged the government to cut emissions by 25% below 1990 levels by the end of 2020. It was the first time a court anywhere in the world had ordered a government to mitigate global heating by reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

Then, two years later, a court in Paris found the French government guilty of climate inaction. It ordered them to pay for the resulting damages after four NGOs filed a case.

Wednesday’s hearings are only the start of proceedings. The process is likely to take several months before the court hands down its verdicts.

Additional reporting via Agence France-Presse
Featured image via Wikimedia Commons/ CherryX, licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license, resized to 770*403

Share128Tweet80
Previous Post

Thousands of refugees will be packed in former military bases, Tory minister confirms

Next Post

The threat of Artificial Intelligence is what we should all fear, apparently

Next Post
The threat of Artificial Intelligence is what we should all fear, apparently

The threat of Artificial Intelligence is what we should all fear, apparently

UK food aid

UK's broken asylum system sees £3.5bn in UK aid money spent internally

A European badger standing among shrubbery next to a waterbody

Government adds expansive third prong to the badger cull, while claiming a 'phase out'

A barricade at a university entrance over the French pensions from Macron

The French pensions revolt: A view from Marseille

Aerial view of Perenco oil spill in Poole Harbour.

Oil spill in UK natural harbour adds to fossil fuel company's long list of international crimes against people and the planet

Please login to join discussion
Trump has just sparked another major national security row
Analysis

Trump just sparked another major national security row – not that he cares

by Steve Topple
15 May 2025
The far-right's latest attack on Jeremy Corbyn is its most preposterous yet - with Lee Anderson leading the charge
Analysis

The far-right’s latest attack on Jeremy Corbyn is its most preposterous yet

by James Wright
15 May 2025
Starmer Rwanda deportation plan
Analysis

Just when you thought Starmer couldn’t stoop any lower – he does this

by Ed Sykes
15 May 2025
Jewish anti-Zionists IJAN respond to police ban on protest against Israeli ambassador
Analysis

Jewish anti-Zionists IJAN respond to police ban on protest against Israeli ambassador

by Ed Sykes
15 May 2025
Social Media Activism: How Grassroots Movements Are Gaining Power Online
Lifestyle

Social Media Activism: How Grassroots Movements Are Gaining Power Online

by Nathan Spears
15 May 2025
  • Contact
  • About & FAQ
  • Get our Daily News Email
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

The Canary
PO Box 71199
LONDON
SE20 9EX

Canary Media Ltd – registered in England. Company registration number 09788095.

For guest posting, contact [email protected]

For other enquiries, contact: [email protected]

The Canary is owned and run by independent journalists and volunteers, NOT offshore billionaires.

You can write for us, or support us by making a regular or one-off donation.

© Canary Media Ltd 2024, all rights reserved | Website by Monster | Hosted by Krystal | Privacy Settings

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion

© 2023 Canary - Worker's co-op.

Before you go, have you seen...?

Trump has just sparked another major national security row
Analysis
Steve Topple

Trump just sparked another major national security row – not that he cares

The far-right's latest attack on Jeremy Corbyn is its most preposterous yet - with Lee Anderson leading the charge
Analysis
James Wright

The far-right’s latest attack on Jeremy Corbyn is its most preposterous yet

Starmer Rwanda deportation plan
Analysis
Ed Sykes

Just when you thought Starmer couldn’t stoop any lower – he does this

Jewish anti-Zionists IJAN respond to police ban on protest against Israeli ambassador
Analysis
Ed Sykes

Jewish anti-Zionists IJAN respond to police ban on protest against Israeli ambassador

ADVERTISEMENT
Lifestyle
Nathan Spears

Social Media Activism: How Grassroots Movements Are Gaining Power Online

Travel
Nathan Spears

Best Destinations In Spain For A Couples Holiday

Travel
Nathan Spears

Surviving Long Layovers: A Frequent Traveller’s Guide