A Labour MP just accused anyone who takes issue with capitalism of antisemitism

Siobhain McDonagh

During an interview on BBC Radio 4, Labour MP Siobhain McDonagh appeared to equate anti-capitalism with antisemitism. And speaking to The Canary, another Labour source condemned her comments as “absurd”.

“To be anti-capitalist you have to be antisemitic”

McDonagh accused people who take issue with capitalism of being unable to take antisemitism seriously, saying:

I’m not sure that some people in the Labour Party can. Because it’s very much part of their politics, of hard left politics, to be against capitalists and to see Jewish people as the financiers of capital. Ergo you are anti-Jewish people.

Presenter John Humphrys then asked:

In other words, to be anti-capitalist you have to be antisemitic?

McDonagh replied “yes”, before saying:

Not everybody, but there is a certain… there’s a certain strand of it. These people are not Labour, have never been Labour, but we now find them in our party.

In response, a Labour source told The Canary:

It is absurd and damaging to equate challenging the inequalities and injustices of an economic system with antisemitism.

Ongoing issue

This is an ongoing problem. McDonagh is far from the only anti-Jeremy Corbyn figure to misuse the term “antisemitism”. Labour MP Jess Phillips recently accused Young Labour of antisemitism for tweeting the phrase “Joan Ryan Gone – Palestine Lives”. But correcting the record, grassroots group Jewish Voice for Labour told The Canary:

Joan Ryan is a non-Jewish MP whose activities as chair of Labour Friends of Israel have pitted her repeatedly against supporters of justice for Palestine… Yoking her resignation with the slogan “Palestine Lives” seems entirely justifiable and carries no hint of hostility towards Jews. The fact that the tweet seems to have been removed is a reflection of the gagging of pro-Palestinian voices that Ryan and her allies promote.

In a similar vein to McDonagh, Jewish Chronicle editor Stephen Pollard backtracked in September 2018 after suggesting Corbyn was being antisemitic for calling out the bankers who caused the financial crash. The Jewish Chronicle has relentlessly published articles accusing Labour of antisemitism. But many of the allegations against Corbyn rely heavily on misrepresentation.

It’s not just that allegations like these smear citizens who take issue with the banking industry and inequality. They also risk undermining genuine instances and genuine concerns about antisemitism in Labour and wider society.

In short, McDonagh needs to check herself before going on BBC Radio 4 again. Because she is insulting millions of Britons who take issue with the status quo.

Featured image via YouTube – Siobhain McDonagh

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. I heard the interview this morning & I can assure you that she didn’t “appear” to say it, she did say it & then was allowed to have a free range to rant by John Humphry’s, not once was she challenged over anything she said or even interrupted, amazing, the BBC doesn’t even try to pretend to be impartial these days.

    2. If she’s saying that anyone who is anti-capitalist is also anti-semitic, does that mean that she’s saying that all Jewish people are capitalists? I only ask because making blanket assumptions about people based on the race or religion sounds rather racist/bigoted, possibly bordering on anti-semitic.

      I think somone should inform Tom Watson.

    3. A shepherd-boy, who watched a flock of sheep near a village, brought out the villagers three or four times by crying out, “Wolf! Wolf!” and when his neighbours came to help him, he laughed at them for their pains. The Wolf, however, did truly come at last. That Wolf being Mrs May’s Hostile Environment.

      When are these accusers going to realise who the real enemy is?

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.