A Tory minister’s assertion about the current state of the “union” was a low moment. This was even by the Andrew Marr Show‘s usual standards. Because he managed to insult the intelligence of every person living in Scotland.
Dowden slips on Marr
The ‘united’ bit of the United Kingdom has been hitting the headlines again. Former Scottish first minister Alex Salmond has started his own pro-independence party. In Wales, Plaid Cymru has been pushing Welsh independence. And in recent months in the north of Ireland, polls have shown a majority support for a vote on reunification. So, enter culture secretary Oliver Dowden on Marr to lay waste to the idea of national self-determination.
The host put it to him that Welsh first minister Mark Drakeford said:
the Union is… under greater threat than at any time in his life. Do you agree with that?
I think we have a very, very serious choice. The Scottish people have a very serious choice at the elections coming up in May.
Oliver Dowden gets asked to comment on a comment made by Mark Drakeford on the “threat” to the Union – and starts banging on about Scottish independence. Did he realize Drakeford is Welsh FM? #Marr
— Germans for ScotRef (@Germans4indyref) March 28, 2021
Either Dowden doesn’t realise that Drakeford is a Welsh politician, or he thinks that only Scottish independence is an issue. But it certainly isn’t just in Scotland where self-determination is looking more likely. Because a recent ITV poll found 40% of Welsh people supported their nation’s independence.
Either way, Dowden continued on Marr with his union clusterfucking.
Was there a Scottish Indyref?
He then said about the “choice” in May’s elections:
do we get on with the job… of defeating Covid… Or do we get caught up in yet more constitutional wrangling, when we thought we’d addressed this four or five year ago, back in… in fact it’s more than that now isn’t it, seven years ago when we had the referendum
Good to see that Scottish politics is so emblazoned on Dowden’s mind that he knows when the first Indyref was. It’s actually around six and a half years since it happened.
Dowden’s confusion also applied to the broader situation in Scotland.
Nothing has changed
He continued his drivel on Marr by saying:
Things haven’t changed since then.
Yeah, many people would disagree with that:
Honestly if your going to speak about Scotland on national TV get yourself clued up first!
— Marty Bhoy #DissolveTheUnion (@martybhoy1979) March 28, 2021
And then Dowden says "Things haven't changed" since the Scottish referendum, except for Covid.
Excepting, of course, for Brexit, which Scotland didn't vote for.
Marr isn't very good at exposing Tory mendacity, is he? #Marr
— Johnny Ninefingers (@j9fingers) March 28, 2021
#marr @OliverDowden On the union…”things haven’t changed since then “…..except a bunch of conmen and racists dragged us out of the EU, put a border in the Irish Sea, crashed the fishing industry, trashed exports….. you meant apart from that I guess ?
— mark heuchan (@scottishmarko) March 28, 2021
So, what does Dowden think has changed since 2014? He told Marr:
Covid. And it’s important that we get on with dealing with that.
Marr asked him again if he thought the union was under threat. Dowden gave a flicker of Tory reality with his answer:
I think there is a real risk here. And the way to deal with that risk is to make sure that you vote for the Conservative Party and unionist parties that are committed to ensuring that our precious union… should be preserved
‘My precious’ sums up the Tories’ attitude to the union. That is, they think Scotland, Wales, and the north of Ireland belong exclusively to them – and no one else should be in control. But when Dowden can’t even get his basic facts right on the situation north of the border, live on Marr, it actually reveals the Tories’ contempt for the other nations.
Do your bit for independent journalism
Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.
We need you to help out, if you can.
When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.
You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.
In return you get:
- Advert free reading experience
- Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
- 20% discount from our shop