Government calorie labelling plans are “dangerous” for people with eating disorders
Campaigners say government plans to force restaurants to label calories in restaurants risk the health and recovery of people with eating disorders.
Last week, the government announced that businesses in England with more than 250 employees would have to display calorie information on menus and labels from April 2022.
The measures are part of the government strategy to tackle obesity, and include cafes, restaurants, and takeaways.
However, many people shared how the announcement would leave them scared to eat out as they may be triggered by the calorie information.
I am genuinely scared about this. My recovery is shaky at best, I don't think I could eat out if calories were on the menu.
Read on...
— 𝔗𝔞𝔫𝔦𝔱𝔥 (@erikatanith) May 11, 2021
A terrible move. When my son was very ill, M&S Cafe used to be a 'safe' place where he could manage to eat lunch. That all came to an abrupt end when they suddenly started putting calories on all of their signage and menu boards.
— JOHN C (@decostop) May 12, 2021
“Ineffective” and “dangerous”
Eating disorder charity BEAT immediately criticised the move, and is encouraging people to email their MPs to ask them to oppose the legislation.
A study published in 2017 found that women with anorexia or bulimia would order “significantly fewer” calories when items were labelled compared to when they weren’t.
And a review of literature into calorie labelling for the general population concluded that it had little of the desired impact on public health. As a result, the researchers suggested pursuing other methods of tackling obesity.
Another review in 2018 found that some studies did find calorie labelling reduced the amount people ate, but only in a very small amount of low-quality studies.
Calorie labelling on menus is ineffective, and dangerous to people affected by eating disorders.
We’ve drafted a letter asking your MP to oppose this legislation – take action here: https://t.co/PY7VRg9ffk https://t.co/MePBLcgtWl— Beat (@beatED) May 13, 2021
When our clients no longer count calories we know that another amazing milestone of recovery has been reached and the thought of calories on menus makes me so, so angry, at the National Centre for ED's we will it seems continue to mop up the mistakes of our government. #calories pic.twitter.com/wP8qgOLnBs
— Bernie Wright (@HealingMindsTW) May 14, 2021
Exacerbated by lockdowns
A survey of people with, or recovering from, an eating disorder during the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic found that 87% reported their symptoms were worse as a result.
BEAT similarly reported it’s answering significantly more calls to its helpline in 2020/21 than in 2019/20.
Back in June 2020, BEAT warned that government obesity campaigns were making people vulnerable to an eating disorder more likely to develop one, as well as increasing symptoms for people already diagnosed.
like this is just gonna fuel my ed, trigger ppl in recovery, and potentially ruin non disordered ppls relationship w food. put the calories somewhere on an online menu where u have to search it up to find it, dont shove it in ppl’s faces
— xin | 馨 (@urinekcals) May 12, 2021
Life-threatening consequences
Anorexia has the highest mortality rate of any psychiatric disorder. According to BEAT, less than half of patients fully recover from it, with many remaining chronically ill.
Even before the pandemic, hospital admissions for eating disorders had risen by 37% in two years. In 2019, a quarter of the hospital admissions recorded were children.
This strategy for tackling obesity could put thousands of people’s health at risk without much evidence it will help reduce obesity. At a time when people with eating disorders are already reporting worse symptoms, this could be catastrophic.
Featured image via Flickr/Foodfacts pm
We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support
The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.
The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.
So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.
-
Show Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to leave a comment.Join the conversationPlease read our comment moderation policy here.
These people need to get a grip. Knowing what’s in your food in relation to both ingredients and calories is important information. Yet again the Left displaying that they’re for the few, not the many.
On a side note, what an atrocious article. Were you paid by opponents of the legislation to write it?
The usual clap trap from you.
It’s ironic that the government are proposing these measures at a time when the work of Prof Tim Spector (KCL), his colleagues and coworkers has discredited crude calorie counting as a means of weight control. The source of the calories, when they are consumed and the physiology of the individual all play a part.
So not only are these measures likely to cause severe problems for those with eating disorders they are unlikely to have much effect on the general level of obesity.
They will, of course, boost the profits of the big food companies with their supposed slimming low calorie products. More profits for them equates to bigger donations to the tory party. Do I smell a, rat? Surely not.
It’s ridiculous. We need a serious campaign to get High Fructose Corn Syrup out of our processed food right now. We’ve had an obesity epidemic for 2 decades, that followed its introduction around the world, starting in the USA. It is said to be more addictive than heroin. It was designed as a cheapo sweetener via an enzymatic process and blocks Leptin – the hormone that allows us to feel satiated. I found this out from one of Robert Lustig’s excellent lectures on ‘sugar’ some years ago. The manufacturers should be in prison for the deaths and misery they have caused worldwide.
I’m with you all the way. Its the source of the calories not the calories per se that matters. Spector says to avoid all highly processed ingredients, corn syrup is one of those, also modified starch, corn starch, potato starch, glucose / fructose syrup etc. Anything that sounds as though it comes from a lab or factory, not from a field. It’s the food industry that’s responsible for the current obesity crisis, not calories.
And of course it’s much better to ‘label restaurant calories’, than to do anything that might actually HELP, such as mandated school fields (Like the ones the Tories and new labour ‘sold off’ to developers), and reducing the focus on the 4 Rs to add much more PE time.
Heavily subsidised gyms and other sprts venues would also help – if working people had the time to go to them.
As someone for whom most of my life, I have been interested in buying the HIGHEST calorie food, to burn it off, calorie packaging has been very useful. WTF point of it is there in restaurants though?
The problems are really endemic lack of exercise, lack of free time for workers, high cost of private facilities, and deep, never-ending physique destroying stress.
It will be a cold day in Hades before the Tories, either in the Conservative party or New New Labour, give a flying shit about the plight of the poor workers and normal people in this country.
The most they think of us is how to spin a story so it doens’t sound so bad, like it’s for our benefit, lol.