Commissioner says children in care ‘failed by the state’ as private companies make huge profits

Children playing
Support us and go ad-free

Thousands of children in care are being repeatedly moved between residential homes or living in unregulated accommodation, reporting “disgusting” and prison-like conditions, a report has found.

“Irrational system”

Some children feel “dumped” in children’s homes in areas they haven’t heard of. While hundreds of children who need a place can’t get one anywhere in England, the children’s commissioner said. Anne Longfield said those falling through the cracks of an increasingly “fragmented, uncoordinated and irrational system” risk becoming victims of criminal or sexual exploitation.

She has published three reports setting out how children’s residential social care is failing some of the country’s most vulnerable children. The government’s failure to heed previous warnings suggests a “deep-rooted institutional ambivalence”, she believes.

The government said it would launch its independent care review “as soon as possible”.


The report Crisis in residential care: how children are being betrayed by the state is the culmination of three years’ research. It concludes that there are thousands of children the system “doesn’t know what to do with”.

Read on...

Moreover, it found there were 8,000 children who had three different homes within a single year as of 31 March 2019.

And it noted:

  • “Frequent and unwanted moves”.
  • Children being uprooted to places they couldn’t identify on a map.
  • Children being moved into children’s homes that were filthy, rat-infested and felt “overly institutional”.

One teenager said she was placed eight hours from her hometown and wasn’t able to see her mother for months. Another girl never made the effort to unpack. Because she knew she would be “passed on somewhere else in a few weeks” like a “parcel”.

Of all the children who were in care in 2018/19, around one in eight – 12,800 children – spent some time in unregulated accommodation. These homes, 79% of which are provided by the private sector, aren’t inspected.

The report concludes:

Local and national leaders have behaved for far too long as if shutting their eyes will make this problem disappear. It hasn’t, and it won’t.

The private sector is profiting

Another paper looked at instability in children’s care. It found that one in 10 children in care moved home at least twice over 2018-19. And a quarter moved twice over two years.

Some 6,500 children lived in at least four different homes over two years. And 12-to-15-year-olds were most likely to experience multiple moves.

The commissioner’s final report examined the growth of private companies providing foster placements and children’s homes. The number of children in private sector homes grew by 42% between 2011 and 2019. This was as local authority provision couldn’t keep pace, the report found.

Best estimates suggest certain large providers are seeing an average profit margin of around 17% on fees from local authorities. Which can amount to more than £200m a year, the report said.

Longfield said there are questions about whether the financing of some large private providers through private equity could create future debt. She added that the “opaque” system needs probing to understand ownership, accountability, and costs within the sector.

The commissioner is calling for councils to use their capital budgets to increase their homes’ capacity. But she said the Department for Education has the ultimate responsibility. It needs to ensure that councils have the resources to discharge their obligations, and to forecast provision. But it has “failed in each”.

The government must rapidly set out a strategy to improve capacity, stability, quality and costs in residential care. And a central body should assess current and future need, she added.


A Department for Education spokesperson said:

The Education Secretary has been clear that no child should be denied the opportunity for a loving, stable family life, or be ‘bounced around’ the care system in accommodation that does not meet their needs. We have also set out that children under the age of 16 should not be living in unregulated homes.

Our bold, broad and independently-led Care Review will launch as soon as possible, and will support improvements in the children’s social care system. This will build on the millions we have invested in secure children’s homes and in projects designed to increase capacity and improve how places for these children are commissioned.

Longfield said a high court judge had told her in October that a child in care, whose life was in danger, couldn’t get a care home place. She said:

These shocking cases used to be rare but are now routine, and I am worried the whole system is becoming immune to the devastating effect this is having on children who may have previously been abused and neglected, or have serious mental or physical health needs. These children are being failed by the state.

The growing reliance on private providers, some of whom are making millions, is another symptom of a system failing to prioritise the needs of children. Both the Government and councils have failed in their responsibilities by leaving it to the market.

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us