The government’s list of coronavirus symptoms protects the economy over lives

Health secretary Matt Hancock
Support us and go ad-free

In our flat, we have been living with suspected coronavirus (Covid-19) symptoms for twenty days. Of course, we can’t be tested for it, so like many others in the UK, we can only assume that it is the virus that’s giving us our symptoms.

But according to the NHS, it’s unlikely that I – or my flatmate – have the virus. Like the majority of the public, I initially looked on the NHS’s 111 symptom checker when my flatmate first complained of symptoms. “It feels like I’ve smoked a whole packet of cigarettes,” he’d moaned. “My chest feels really heavy.”

The symptom checker asks the public to answer two questions:

  • “Do you have a high temperature (fever)?”
  • “Do you have a new continuous cough?”

My flatmate and I had neither, so I ticked ‘no’ for both. The NHS told me that “you’re unlikely to have coronavirus.” That was it. In just two questions, I was told that I (and my flatmate) probably didn’t have it.

via NHS 111 Online

Our symptoms

The next day, I developed a sore throat and swollen lymph nodes. Two days after that, I felt an ache around my lung area.

On the night of day five, my flatmate barely slept. The pressure in his chest felt much worse. His symptoms improved significantly over the next few days but deteriorated again on day 10. He had no energy and complained that his chest felt even heavier. On day 11, he developed a very sore throat on top of his other symptoms. There are a number of reports that people often improve and then deteriorate.

Read on...

My flatmate improved significantly between days 12 and 18, although the pressure in his chest remained. But on day 19, he felt terrible again, with more symptoms: shortness of breath, dizzy spells and fatigue.

As for me, the ache around my lung area initially faded to nothing – but has recurred again over the last couple of days.

The woefully incomplete NHS symptom list

We know through social media that the virus affects each individual differently. So why does the NHS website only ask people if they have a persistent cough and a fever?

The World Health Organisation (WHO) has a more comprehensive symptom list:

  • Fever
  • Tiredness
  • Dry cough
  • Shortness of breath
  • Aches and pains
  • Sore throat
  • and very few people will report diarrhoea, nausea or a runny nose

And let’s look at other countries’ coronavirus advice. The Australian government describes symptoms as being a fever, cough, shortness of breath, and a sore throat. It goes on to list severe symptoms as:

  • Persistent shortness of breath
  • Chest pains (a feeling of crushing pressure, a heavy weight pushing down or a tight band squeezing around your chest. The pain may be spreading to the shoulders, back, arms or jaw and it may be felt as a discomfort rather than a pain. The pain can be slight or severe.)
  • Suddenly feeling cold with shivering and fever (rigor)
  • Persistent sweating
  • Persistent severe muscle pain
  • Exhaustion

The website tells you to go to the Emergency Department if you have severe symptoms. So if we were in Australia, my flatmate would have been taken to hospital.

via Australian Government Health Direct


France lists possible symptoms as: a fever, cough, fatigue, breathing difficulties, headache, loss of taste and smell, sore throat, aches, and sometimes diarrhoea.

Even the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) advice is more comprehensive than the NHS’s. First, it lists “a fever, cough and shortness of breath”. It goes on to list emergency symptoms, and states that you should seek immediate medical attention if you have:

  • Trouble breathing
  • Persistent pain or pressure in the chest
  • New confusion or inability to arouse
  • Bluish lips or face

Once again, if we lived in the US, I would be taking my flatmate to get urgent medical advice.

On day 19, I called the NHS’s 111 advice line. I quickly managed to speak to someone, but only after I had stated that yes, my friend did have a fever or persistent cough. The kind person on the other end of the line was much more thorough than the NHS website.

Unknowingly infecting others

Before the government declared the lockdown, I’m sure that many people like me checked their symptoms against the NHS advice. When not finding their symptoms, they may well have unknowingly gone to public places and spread the virus. And now, during lockdown, others with symptoms that don’t include fever or cough may be caring for vulnerable people.

Protecting the economy at all costs

The NHS told The Canary that “public advice over symptoms [comes] from Public Health England so they would be best placed to answer your questions.” The Canary contacted Public Health England, but had received no comment by the time of publication. Why would this government agency deliberately downplay the symptoms? Is it because it wants to continue capitalism as usual for as many ‘essential’ businesses as possible? The Canary has already reported that arms companies are still producing weapons right now.

The government has proved itself to be reckless and incompetent throughout this crisis. Even its dubious advice on how long to quarantine for is at odds with the WHO, which has stated:

“People infected with Covid-19 can still infect others after they stop feeling sick, so these measures should continue for at least two weeks after symptoms disappear.

Only a week after being diagnosed with coronavirus, health secretary Matt Hancock went back to work, opening the new Nightingale hospital.

To keep the economy running, you need workers. And to keep workers, the government may be both withholding information on potential symptoms and flouting WHO guidelines on how long to quarantine for.

Featured image via YouTube -Sky News

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. And many are dying, and will die, as a result of the lockdown – both the economic consequence and depression/ill health from not being able to meet people? I’d wager, a lot more than a dying from the coronavirus.
      We should end the lockdown immediately and allow those who want to isolate to do so voluntarily, perhaps on half pay.

    2. Yes, I can see that a lot of large businesses are anxious to get their workers back. Let’s end the lockdown and get back to work. So what if people die at their posts? Big money is more important, sod the workers. They can always fill the deceased person’s position with another ‘bored sitting at home’ type person. The previous commenter is right, lets throw caution to the wind and help those billionaires and millionaires gain more profit

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.