According to most commentators, Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn made mincemeat of Theresa May at today’s PMQs. This might go some way to explaining the BBC‘s bizarre behaviour during the Labour leader’s time at the despatch box. Viewers noticed that, while Corbyn was speaking, the BBC was playing back tweets from the Conservative Party’s director of communications, without mentioning her day job.
Corbyn bested May on a number of issue during PMQs, but front and centre was Brexit. Here is just one moment from many where the Labour leader ran rings around his opponent.
— Jeremy Corbyn (@jeremycorbyn) February 28, 2018
From the Westminster press pack to regular tweeters, most viewers agreed this was not a good day for Theresa May or her government.
Laughter on all sides at #PMQs at Corbyn’s jibe against Johnson thinking about Camden-Islington border.Foreign Secretary is a laughing stock
— Tim Walker (@ThatTimWalker) February 28, 2018
That was fascinating. The Prime Minister was asked the simplest and most un-tricksy of questions by Ian Blackford – does she still regard the four nations of the UK as "equal partners", as she did in 2012? She looked perturbed and very deliberately avoided saying "yes". #PMQs
— James Kelly (@JamesKelly) February 28, 2018
Corbyn goes for the JUGULAR #PMQs asks the PM to explain WHAT she MEANS by " ambitious managed divergence*
The PM FAILED to elaborate – resorted to the usual *waffle*
— Clare Hepworth OBE (@Hepworthclare) February 28, 2018
But some viewers watching the BBC‘s coverage of PMQs noticed something odd happening when Corbyn was speaking. The tweets being displayed on the right of the screen weren’t just from journalists and members of the public. One in particular looked very familiar. It came from Carrie Symonds. And Carrie Symonds is the director of communications for the Conservative Party.
— Devutopia #SocSocM (@D_Raval) February 28, 2018
Effectively, the BBC was airing Conservative propaganda while the leader of the opposition was at the despatch box. They certainly don’t air the views of Labour’s director of communications Seamus Milne while the prime minister is speaking.
Later, the BBC was even including tweets from the Conservative Party itself:
Not only the Tories head of comms, but the BBC also put up tweets by the Tory Party while Corbyn was speaking #PMQs! Have they ever put up Labour Party tweets while May speaks?
— Devutopia #SocSocM (@D_Raval) February 28, 2018
Tip of the iceberg
This is not the first time the BBC has been accused of presenting a partisan actor as a neutral one. Last year, BBC Newsnight featured a segment on the NHS in which cancer specialist Dr Karol Sikora called the health service “the last bastion of communism”. While dissenting views on the NHS are a welcome part of the public health debate, it is important to know the financial interests and background of the speaker. The NHS segment opens with Sikora introduced only by name. There is no mention of his experience or interests.
— BBC Newsnight (@BBCNewsnight) February 22, 2017
The BBC failed to mention that Sikora is the medical director of private health firm Proton Partners Ltd, based in the tax haven of the Bahamas. He took part in a series of anti-NHS attack ads for the US Republican Party aimed at killing off President Obama’s healthcare plans. In the videos, it is claimed that NHS rationing boards routinely deny life-saving care to vulnerable British patients. Imperial College London also took legal advice after Sikora made repeated public claims that he holds an honorary professorship at the prestigious institution. He does not. None of this was mentioned before, during or after Sikora’s segment.
And last August, BBC Radio 4 carried out an interview with former Conservative chancellor and renowned climate change sceptic Nigel Lawson. The hosts permitted Lawson, unchallenged, to make false claims to support his position that climate change doesn’t exist. After public complaint, the BBC apologised, and admitted it had breached its own “guidelines on accuracy and impartiality”.
The list goes on.
We need an impartial, publicly funded broadcaster. And the BBC has a tough job to find balance amid chaos. But the corporation cannot play fast and loose with its own principles. In doing so, it not only fails the licence fee payer, it fails its own moral test.
– Join The Canary, so we can keep holding the powerful to account.
– Read and support other independent media outlets:
Another Angry Voice, Media Diversified, Novara Media, Corporate Watch, Red Pepper, New Internationalist, Common Space, Media Lens, Bella Caledonia, Vox Political, Evolve Politics, Real Media, Reel News, STRIKE! magazine, The Bristol Cable, The Meteor, The Skwawkbox, Salford Star, The Ferret.
Fund our Investigations Unit
You can help us investigate corruption, expose injustice and uncover the truth.
As one of the only independent investigations units in the country, we work for you – but we need your help to keep going. We need to raise £10,000 to continue our groundbreaking investigations. Can you chip in?