At least 11 prominent women’s rights defenders have been arrested in Saudi Arabia. These are people who’ve spent years fighting to end female discrimination, including the right for Saudi women to drive alone.
But in a final twist of the knife, the Vogue Arabia front cover has made this even worse.
This is the first Vogue edition dedicated to Saudi Arabia. It claims to celebrate “the women of the Kingdom and their wide-reaching achievements”. The cover declares it is a “celebration of the trailblazing women of Saudi Arabia”, and also features an image of Saudi princess Hayfa bint Abdullah al-Saud:
This June, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is putting women in the driving seat – and so are we. https://t.co/CaOwxsdQQI
— Vogue Arabia (@VogueArabia) May 30, 2018
But many have taken to social media to challenge this ‘celebration’:
Let's put a princess who never struggled from the driving ban on the cover. Who her family issued the driving ban in the first place, put so many women in jail for driving, and just imprisoned prominent women's rights activists who risked their life and freedom to lift the ban.
— Sara (@sassy1989sara) May 31, 2018
What a shameful insensitive cover! Did you know that KSA put women rights activists in jail last week? So HRH the princess can drive a car, it's okay, everything is cool in the kingdom, and let @LoujainHathloul and friends burn in hell? Shame on you Vogue Arabia and Mr. Arnaut!
— Sanaa (@Sanaalkhoury) May 30, 2018
There appears to be no mention of the jailed activists in Vogue‘s gloss. Yet many of them are women who fought for this princess to pose, alone, in a luxury car:
Meanwhile, at least 11 women's rights activists have been detained in Saudi in recent days https://t.co/tbK4U5iyR1
— Middle East Eye (@MiddleEastEye) May 31, 2018
And that’s not ok. Because the harsh reality is that it’s far from a ‘trailblazing’ edition:
Is Vogue Arabia celebrating the wrong Saudi women?
While the Saudi women who campaigned for the driving ban could face the death penalty, this Saudi Princess is on the magazine cover and being celebrated as "trailblazing" https://t.co/hsfW4dYdrJ
— Osha Mahmoud (@Osha001) May 31, 2018
Disappointed by this Vogue. ! The real on the ground for the longest time ever to fight for women’s right to drive are imprisoned for treason on the hands of the govt that is ruled by the family that this woman on the cover that is part of.
Shame on you!
— 🧜🏼♀️ مرام (@Maramv7) May 30, 2018
There is no independent media in Saudia Arabia, so information has been scarce. But Hala Al-Dosari, a Saudi scholar living in the US, “advocates on behalf of activists there who can’t speak freely for fear of government retribution”. She told the Atlantic:
The same day the announcement was made, the royal court made phone calls to several women who have been active in the campaign, and told them not to speak to the press, not to make any comment on the decision, positive or negative.
Saudi authorities have long repressed activists and dissidents for peaceful activities. Since 2011, the courts have convicted nearly 30 prominent activists and dissidents. Many received sentences of 10 or 15 years largely under broad, catch-all charges designed to criminalize peaceful dissent.
More arrests followed, and those held have also been branded ‘traitors’ and charged with treason. Activists told HRW that:
the seriousness of the allegations and the viciousness of the deeply personalized media campaign are unprecedented and shocking.
UN human rights spokesperson Liz Throssell said:
We urge the Saudi Arabian authorities to reveal their locations, and ensure their rights to due process guarantees… If, as it appears, their detention is related solely to their work as human rights defenders and activists on women’s issues, they should be released immediately.
Now, some people have fixed Vogue‘s cover. They’ve replaced al-Saud’s face with the women who are currently detained:
Hi Vogue Arabia, I fixed it for you! pic.twitter.com/HdY0Fxrv9Z
— چ (@ItsJayyz) May 30, 2018
Hi guys it's the wrong woman, her the right one pic.twitter.com/I5FVAgfCfM
— مسخ (@himchan323) May 31, 2018
Indeed, these are the women who truly deserve to be celebrated in Saudi Arabia.
The driving ban is, in many ways, only symbolic. Because as Amnesty International explains, women and girls in Saudi Arabia:
remain subject to discrimination in law and practice, with laws that ensure they are subordinate citizens to men – particularly in relation to family matters such as marriage, divorce, child custody and inheritance.
So challenging a woman’s right to drive alone was part of a bigger push for feminists who have been:
organizing against Saudi Arabia’s guardianship system, under which women need the permission of a male guardian to do almost everything.
But the Vogue article doesn’t refer to the arrests. Nor does it refer to the ongoing battle for gender equality that Saudi women face. As a magazine that has claimed to champion feminism and women’s rights for over a hundred years, it should hang its head in shame.
– Also, read more Canary articles about Saudi Arabia.
Featured image via screengrab
Since you're here ...
We know you don't need a lecture. You wouldn't be here if you didn't care.
Now, more than ever, we need your help to challenge the rightwing press and hold power to account. Please help us survive and thrive.