On 22 November, Amazon CEO and arguably the richest person in the world Jeff Bezos announced a donation of $98.5m to help homeless people. But Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn saw past this supposedly generous act and he made it clear what Bezos must do:
That’s 0.09% of your net worth.
Get the news that really mattersSign me up
Just pay your taxes. https://t.co/KEke1NUE8E
— Jeremy Corbyn (@jeremycorbyn) November 24, 2019
Corbyn is far from alone
Many other people also saw through Bezos’ stunt, so they took to social media to tell people about it:
And those who couldn’t get what the problem was were soon put straight:
Amazon pays little or no tax
Despite revenues of £10.9bn in the UK, it paid just £220m in direct taxation in 2018. And it paid just an additional £10m in corporation tax despite a £358m increase in revenues in the same year. The situation in the US appears to be worse. Because despite being valued at $800bn and taking in $232.9bn in global revenue in 2018, it paid $0 in federal tax. In fact, it was due to get a $129m federal tax refund in 2019.
Corbyn’s taxation policy
Corbyn’s tweet is in keeping with his taxation policy. He warned multinational companies they will have to pay their fair share of tax on all UK operations. Labour believes this will raise £6.3bn for the exchequer in 2024.
Along with shadow employment rights secretary Laura Pidcock, Corbyn plans to clamp down on “enablers of tax dodging”. That seems pretty simple.
Reality check on Bezos’ philanthropy
And while Bezos has pledged $2bn to his Bezos Day One Fund that funds “the work of organizations who help homeless families”, it may not be quite as favourable as it seems.
To begin with, funds such as the Day One suggest it’s acceptable for private donors to tackle the problems of poverty and homelessness as they see fit. But really that’s the job of democratically elected officials. Elected officials are there to make decisions for the greater good, not for the sake of profit or corporate image-polishing.
Secondly, Amazon used its influence in Seattle to kill legislation aimed at tackling homelessness in the city. And despite Bezos’ involvement with not-for-profit organisations in Seattle, the problem of homelessness has worsened.
It’s too serious a problem
Poverty and homelessness can’t be solved through opportunistic donations from philanthropists. It’s far too serious for that. Bezos is unelected, and his track record suggests he’s driven by profit, not the common good. Instead, these serious problems need to be tackled by elected officials who have the needs and interests of the many at heart. And to do so, everyone must pay their fair share of tax.
Since you're here ...
We know you don't need a lecture. You wouldn't be here if you didn't care.
Now, more than ever, we need your help to challenge the rightwing press and hold power to account. Please help us survive and thrive.