A hideous act of ‘vandalism’ in an English village sums up the state of the country right now

Cubbington pear tree
Support us and go ad-free

On 20 October, HS2 cut down a 250-year-old award-winning pear tree to make way for its high speed railway. While the iconic tree certainly isn’t the only victim of the project, the reaction to its destruction does sum up perfectly the state of the country right now. Because it exposes how divorced the country’s leadership is from its own citizens’ needs and desires.

A national treasure

The ancient tree, which had stood tall near the village of Cubbington for the last 250 years, won the Woodland Trust’s Tree of the Year poll in 2015. Over 20,000 people signed a petition against its destruction, and Stop HS2 protestors set up a camp in nearby woodland in opposition to the felling plan. But the public’s wishes went unheeded. On 20 October, HS2 ended the tree’s 250-year-long life in a matter of 90 minutes:


Read on...

In response to the 20,000 signature-strong petition, the Department for Transport said:

HS2 Ltd explored all possible options to avoid removing the tree, but due to its age and condition, removal cannot be avoided.

But, as Warwick and Leamington MP Matt Western highlighted, the HS2 did re-route its line to preserve a nearby golf course in Kenilworth. Western said:

HS2 Ltd has much to answer for, including why the 18th hole on a golf course could be saved but this [wondrous] pear tree could not.

No forgiveness

The public outcry over the tree’s destruction came thick and fast. Local Charlotte Griffin commented:

That tree represented so much. It was a huge part of the community, it was a symbol, an icon, like having a famous statue or building in your neighbourhood. It’s the loss of the heritage, the landscape, biodiversity.

It breaks my heart to be honest. I’m lost for words, really.

Cubbington resident John Taylor, meanwhile, said:

The tree has meant so much to people around here and to see it reduced to twigs in a matter of minutes is just heart-breaking. …

When the grief passes, people around here are going to be very, very angry. This vandalism of nature will never be forgiven or forgotten.


Many people also took to social media to express their dismay:

Both the Woodland Trust and RSPB England also voiced their anger over the felling:

Enraging a country

Clearly, people across the country wanted this iconic tree to remain standing. But it’s not just their desires that the Conservative government and HS2 have ignored. It’s their needs too. We are in the middle of climate and biodiversity crises. To tackle these existential emergencies, we urgently need to prioritise ecological health and security. In short, we have to stop destroying our natural spaces – especially as the UK is already “one of the most nature-depleted countries in Europe”.

Citizens increasingly understand that. But the country’s decision-makers are letting them down. That’s why, as professor Ben Garrod pointed out, this latest act of ‘vandalism of nature’ has angered many in the country:

If people direct that anger into action, and pressure their elected representatives to end this ecological carnage, the Cubbington pear tree’s destruction could be a catalyst for change. That would be a fitting legacy for the 250-year-old national treasure, and would ensure that its death wasn’t in vain.

Featured image via Daniel Meggitt / YouTube

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. ‘..ecological carnage….death in vain….’ It’s a tree ffs. I’m against HS2 but this is pathetic journalism.
      A pity the Canary’s beloved Corbyn didn’t speak out on it more rather than saying ‘We supported the construction of HS2 in the sense of it improving the rail infrastructure of the whole country.

      1. “It’s a tree”. Just a tree, eh? Without them the planet will become uninhabitable, but more importantly, this is slowness versus speed. The processes of the universe, and of life, are slow. We have taken a wrong turn. Speed is what has brought us wealth and we are blinded by it. We are in the midst of a pandemic because of the way we treat animals. The mad practices of wet markets in China where a spatchcock attitude to animals prevails is what has brought us to this pass. As the rainforests are destroyed, so we have contact with species we have never encountered. All animals carry viruses. As we expose ourselves to them, in a rapid way, we expose ourselves to diseases against which we have no immunity. Covid is bad, but imagine if it killed ten times more victims. We have grown arrogant. We are not masters of nature but part of it. “It’s a tree”. Yes, but it had been here 250 years, a lot longer than you or me. We risk the end of the human adventure if we embrace your glib attitude.

      2. “It’s a tree ffs”. That there folks is the right-wing mindset in a nutshell. It’s only wood, doesn’t do anything, just sits there getting in the way, golf course important, 250 year old tree not haha chop it dann, let’s go to the footie, pathetic journalism, I hate women, all lives matter.

        We’re never gonna move forward with this kind of ignorance holding us back.

    2. This is an Analogy of what is wrong with the world, those men acted on an order from The Elites, then they were cutting down that tree with the same hatred and sarcasm as the Soldiers in Iraq, Syria, the Bomb Makers who make their Master’s Bomb, because a wage packet is worth more than thousands of children in Palestine and Yemen, after all it’s just a Job!
      Greed RULES ALL!
      We are 97% They are 3%!
      Shove your iPhone, Microsoft, Google, Facebook, Amazon, Twitter, Borders, Loopholed Laws, etc, etc, etc WE DON’T WANT IT! WE DON’T NEED IT!
      Open Source Government NOW!
      Open Source Industry NOW!
      Open Source Economy NOW!
      As LKJ so wisely sang and here read son of 1st Generation Windrush, just had to add Tings for Windrush:
      Dr Linton Kwesi Johnson reads Tings at Windrush

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.