In a House of Commons debate on 14 July about the racist abuse of England footballers in the aftermath of Euro 2020, Coventry South MP Zarah Sultana accused prime minister Boris Johnson and home secretary Priti Patel of “stoking the fire of racism”. Sultana’s accusations included references to Johnson’s column describing Black people as “picaninnies”, and home secretary Priti Patel’s remark stating that footballers taking the knee was simply “gesture politics”. Sultana said that in response, safeguarding minister Victoria Atkins told her to ‘lower her tone’. People took to Twitter to highlight the racism, classism, and misogyny inherent in Atkins’ attempts to silence the young MP.
Sultana states the facts
Sultana’s speech came after England footballer Tyrone Mings called out the home secretary’s ‘pretend disgust’ at the racist treatment of Black players after ‘stoking the fire’ of racism. In her powerful speech, the MP accused the prime minister and home secretary of “stoking the fire of racism” and “giving the green light to racism” in the UK. She highlighted Johnson’s description of “Black people as ‘picaninnies’ with ‘watermelon smiles’” and “Muslim women as ‘letterboxes’ and ‘bank-robbers’”. She also called attention to the prime minister’s refusal to condemn fans who booed England players who took the knee ahead of matches, and the home secretary’s ‘derision’ of their message as “gesture politics”.
Safeguarding minister Victoria Atkins refuted Sultana’s fact-based allegations, saying:
I don’t genuinely think the honourable lady is accusing either the prime minister of this country or indeed the home secretary of racism. That would be a truly extraordinary allegation to make.
After the debate, Sultana took to Twitter, saying that the minister telling her to ‘lower her tone’ was “shameless”. Further clarifying her stance after the debate, Sultana tweeted:
When I confronted Tory minister Victoria Atkins with Boris Johnson's racism – calling black people "piccaninnies" & Muslim women "letterboxes" – she said it's "extraordinary" to accuse him of racism.
Some news for Vicky: He's racist.
The only extraordinary thing is denying it.
— Zarah Sultana MP (@zarahsultana) July 14, 2021
A classic case of tone policing
People soon took to Twitter to call out Atkins’ racist, classist, misogynistic tone policing of Sultana, a 27-year-old British Pakistani woman who attended what she describes as a “rough” school in Birmingham. Explaining that Atkins’ response is a typical of someone seeking to silence marginalised voices, psychologist Guilaine Kinouani said:
To the untrained eyes, roles would switch and Zarah would have become, the irrational, unthinking, emotional absurd interlocutor/agent. Some of us know better and can clearly see how the white MP is trying to locate the disturbance into Zarah as deflection & distraction.
— Guilaine Kinouani (@KGuilaine) July 14, 2021
Underlining the ‘familiarity’ of Atkins’ response, The Canary‘s Maryam Jameela shared:
Victoria Atkins sneering and condescending to Zarah Sultana is so familiar – white women wrap themselves tightly in being softly spoken, measured, gently troubled at racism, calm
racism often comes with a polite veneer – in fact, that's the most British thing I can think of
— Maryam Jameela 🐯 (@yammatron) July 15, 2021
Alex Tiffin added:
Imagine telling the only MP of colour present to talk about racism, to "lower the tone."
Yep, that's Tory Minister Victoria Atkins' response to Zarah Sultana. https://t.co/rVbgoc7YpB
— Alex Tiffin (@RespectIsVital) July 14, 2021
Highlighting that Patel wasn’t present in the House to take part in the debate, Mark Conway said:
Priti Patel was too cowardly to come and answer questions. So she sent her tone police officer Victoria Atkins. Lovely flare of classist “don’t dare speak like that to me.” pic.twitter.com/SWwwESNekc
— Mark Conway (@MarkConway87) July 14, 2021
Urging MPs to support Sultana, Jo Grady shared:
This is racial tone policing packaged as a request for civility in Zarah’s place of work. It is deployed to invalidate her voice. It’s unacceptable, it should be called out by fellow workers (in this case MPs across the bench), and it shouldn’t be left to Zarah to self advocate. https://t.co/VH6InwV4bZ
— Jo Grady (@DrJoGrady) July 14, 2021
Order in the House?
Sharing a montage video comparing scenes of MPs and ministers shouting and jeering in parliament with Sultana’s clear, measured speech, Russ Khorma responded to Sultana with:
Just for context so that we all know exactly the level that Victoria Atkins was expecting Zarah to 'lower her tone' to…. pic.twitter.com/V2pBfm26lV
— Russ Khroma (@russkhroma) July 14, 2021
Agreeing with this sentiment, Sian Norris shared:
Victoria Atkins' response is really offensive – asking Zarah Sultana to "lower the tone" and referring to Sultana's comments as not being "measured" – when Sultana delivered her views calmly and clearly.
Considering this is the space where white men holler and boo. https://t.co/zYeqC9JiA4
— sianushka (@sianushka) July 14, 2021
Recalling the moment when former health secretary Matt Hancock suggested Labour MP and A&E doctor Rosena Allin-Khan should consider her “tone” in the House of Commons, another Twitter user added:
Today, Victoria Atkins told Zarah Sultana to "lower the tone.” Matt Hancock similarly tone policed Rosena Allin-Khan. Yet, it’s perfectly acceptable for the rest of the house to belch as loud as they wish. This micro-aggression is a way to say, “know your place.” #everydaysexism
— Shuaib. (@ShuaibKhan26) July 14, 2021
Highlighting that respectability politics will not help us to disrupt and dismantle systems of racist oppression, Lauren Corelli shared:
zarah here doing everything right to be “measured” + “respectable” in the eyes of the institution and bureaucrats — and it’s still not enough. the powers that be will never be moved by politeness and calm conversation — they will only ever be moved by force + our collective will. https://t.co/3jZfha8wvK
— lauren corelli (@corelliLAUREN) July 14, 2021
Nothing new here
Atkins’ attempt to derail this urgent conversation is a classic deflection technique. But whether it acknowledges it or not, this government is racist. On 14 July, the Runnymede Trust accused the government of being in breach of numerous human rights obligations under the UN treaty on racial discrimination. In November 2020, an inquiry by the Joint Committee on Human Rights suggested that Black people’s human rights aren’t being respected in the UK.
The government’s own statistics lay bare the structural racism that exists in education, employment, housing, healthcare, policing, the justice system, and beyond. But it felt emboldened to publish a report that denies its existence. In response to the report, the UN accused the government of attempting to “normalise white supremacy”. Once again, the Tories have demonstrated that they have no intention of tackling the racism that is ingrained in our society. That’s why we need bright, bold MPs like Sultana to hold them to account.
Featured image via @zarahsultana/Twitter
We need your help to keep speaking the truth
Every story that you have come to us with; each injustice you have asked us to investigate; every campaign we have fought; each of your unheard voices we amplified; we do this for you. We are making a difference on your behalf.
Our fight is your fight. You’ve supported our collective struggle every time you gave us a like; and every time you shared our work across social media. Now we need you to support us with a monthly donation.
We have published nearly 2,000 articles and over 50 films in 2021. And we want to do this and more in 2022 but we don’t have enough money to go on at this pace. So, if you value our work and want us to continue then please join us and be part of The Canary family.
In return, you get:
* Advert free reading experience
* Quarterly group video call with the Editor-in-Chief
* Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
* 20% discount in our shop
Almost all of our spending goes to the people who make The Canary’s content. So your contribution directly supports our writers and enables us to continue to do what we do: speaking truth, powered by you. We have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence our vital opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right-wing mainstream media.
With your help we can continue:
* Holding political and state power to account
* Advocating for the people the system marginalises
* Being a media outlet that upholds the highest standards
* Campaigning on the issues others won’t
* Putting your lives central to everything we do
We are a drop of truth in an ocean of deceit. But we can’t do this without your support. So please, can you help us continue the fight?