People have reacted with scepticism to an Iain Duncan Smith article in the Mail advocating a return to the office.
In the weekend’s Mail on Sunday, Duncan Smith wrote an opinion piece titled In the 1940s they kept coming to the office – even when Hitler’s bombs were raining down. In the article, he argued that it was time for people to get back to the office, saying our city centres are “half empty”, hurting both productivity and businesses nearby offices.
However, many people pointed out the fundamental reason people didn’t work from home (WFH) in the 1940s:
[wearily fetches megaphone] THE HOME WIFI CAPABILITIES WERE FAIRLY FUCKING BASIC DURING THE NON-CONTAGIOUS BLITZ pic.twitter.com/BKb5QpNRQ9
— James Felton (@JimMFelton) October 10, 2021
1. No they didn’t
2. If they did it would have been stupid because bombs came at night.
3. They didn’t have the internet in the 1940s
4. Stop making things about the war. The war was shit. pic.twitter.com/bsGRryGOFp
— thedeathofbuckley (@deathofbuckley) October 10, 2021
Wait til Iain Duncan Smith hears about the internet. It's going to blow his mind. pic.twitter.com/vLdlMHpsKe
— Otto English (@Otto_English) October 10, 2021
Others pointed out some other differences between now and the 1940s:
I'm absolutely in favour of IDS's battle cry to go back to the office like it's the 1940s but we have to do it properly
– smoking pipes at your desk
– 2 hour lunches with 4-5 pints minimum
– no computers
– single salaries that can pay a mortgage
— jon (@AScribbledEagle) October 10, 2021
According to the ONS, around a quarter of people worked from home at some point during 2020 – a number that goes up substantially to nearly half of workers in London.
While offices are now reopening, many are choosing to remain at home. There’s been an increasing demand for flexible working, and thousands expect that they’ll never return to the office full-time.
However, similar to Duncan Smith, bosses of big firms like Goldman Sachs have called home working an “aberration”.
The positives of WFH
But as many people highlighted, the ability to work remotely makes employment much more accessible for disabled people.
Disability activist Ruby Jones said that she had been able to have a full-time job for the first time due to being able to work from home. She told the BBC how remote working allows her to work without getting seriously exhausted due to her Ehlers-Danlos syndrome.
IDS: we need to get disabled people working
Society: *starts making WFH much more of a norm, thus making loads of jobs much more accessible*
IDS: NO NOT LIKE THAT, I MEANT SOMETHING CRUEL AND PUNISHMENT BASED
— It's Pipes, Mum! Pipes Is Here! (@Scriblit) October 10, 2021
I wouldn't have a shot at a career, much less the job I do now, if working from home wasn't an option.
If London based jobs are accessible due to working from home, that changes the game for graduates https://t.co/Z5tXaqvwXJ
— George Fairhurst 📉📈 (@FabianFairhurst) October 7, 2021
In the article, Duncan Smith wrote:
When I think of all the brave civil servants who went to work in the 1940s, determined to do their bit regardless of the threat from falling bombs, I wonder what has happened to us as a nation.
Why are Brexiters and Tories obsessed with The Blitz? It was 80 years ago. The only lesson to be learnt is that people who lived through it knew that we could not return to the inequalities of the past so the welfare state and the NHS were born.
That was building back better.
— The Eve of St.Agnes 🇮🇪🇪🇺🌍🌹☘️ (@AggieRyan) October 10, 2021
It shouldn’t need pointing out how many things make our working situation different to the 1940s. Considering this, harking back to a past war that placed us in an entirely different situation to a global pandemic is a pretty useless attempt to play on nostalgia.
Featured image via Chris McAndrew/Wikimedia Commons
Do your bit for independent journalism
Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.
We need you to help out, if you can.
When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.
You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.
In return you get:
- Advert free reading experience
- Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
- 20% discount from our shop