The viral finance letter is wrong. Here’s how the government REALLY screws over students.

Support us and go ad-free

Thousands of graduates are venting their anger and confusion at the rising rate of interest and repayment on their student loans. After an open letter from one recent graduate about being ‘mis-sold’ his loan by the government went viral, shared tens of thousands of times, his peers are up in arms. However, Simon Crowther’s claim, that a hike in his interest payments had come about since the government sold the loans to a private company, was incorrect.

The massive changes in student loan agreements has more to do with George Osborne’s wider changes to the terms of repayment, retrospectively, and to student finance in general.

Unfortunately, this intersecting misinformation from both the Chancellor and the viral post has young people confused on two fronts. Rather than highlighting the real issues behind unjust and underhand changes to student finance, this event has only illustrated how crucial and burdensome the acceptance of a huge loan at the age of 18 can really be.

The Misunderstanding

In Crowther’s Facebook post, which contains not only the letter to his MP, Vernon Coaker, in full, but also a copy of his latest annual loan statement, he explains that when he agreed to the loan while still at school he “trusted” that the interest rate would be “0-0.5%”. His rate is now far greater, adding well over £100 every month on top of the thousands he already owes. He declares that he believes this amounts to mis-selling, and that he’s lost trust in the government.


Yet, information about interest rates is made available to all students on the Student Loan Company (SLC) website. The interest rate on a post-2012 graduate’s loan will differ depending on a number of things:

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free
  • whether you are still studying or are graduated for less than a year
  • whether your loan was issued pre- or post-2012 (named Plan 1 and Plan 2, respectively)
  • what the current rate of inflation is
  • how much you are currently earning
  • whether you have communicated with the SLC and provided the correct information about your finances

The Real Changes

All post-2012 (Plan 2) students took out a loan with an interest rate that begins at the rate of inflation (RPI), currently 0.9%, and increases based on how much they earn up to £41,000, at which the top rate is RPI + 3%. Plan 2 students will not begin repayment until they begin earning £21,000 per year, and repayment will be 9% of however much they earn above that amount.

Osborne originally promised post-2012 students that this threshold of £21,000 would increase with average earnings from 2017. He has now frozen that threshold – this is where the breach of the agreement between government and students lies. What it means is that graduates who are earning less in real terms, in relation to inflation and average earnings, will be paying a disproportionate rate and repaying far more in interest in the long term.

These changes are explained in full by the Institute for Fiscal Studies, in a report titled “Budget’s student finance proposals will reduce government spending on higher education, but will raise debt for poorer students and repayments for most graduates”.

In addition to this, of course, the government have scrapped student grants, money given to low-income students that they would never have to repay, and just insisted they take out a bigger loan. The report explains that together these changes have a hugely negative impact on students. Due to the loss of grants:

The poorest 40% of students going to university in England will now graduate with debts of up to £53,000 from a three-year course, rather than up to £40,500. This will result from the replacement of maintenance grants of up to nearly £3,500 per year by maintenance loans worth up to £550 a year more.

Yet the “greatest impact” on graduate repayment will result from the threshold freeze, meaning:

Graduate loan repayments will increase by a further £3,800, on average, per student in 2016 money, reducing the long-run cost to government of issuing student loans by around £1.4 billion per cohort of students.

This change will hit middle-income graduates hardest, as they will end up paying more per year for the majority of the repayment period. We estimate that an individual on median graduate earnings will repay over £6,000 more in total in 2016 money.

Martin Lewis, founder of Money Saving Expert and the government’s former student finance tsar, previously took the government to task over the changes in December 2015 in response to the Chancellor’s autumn statement. He spoke out publicly, writing his own open letter to the government, and hiring a team of lawyers to look into whether the retrospective changes to the loan terms could be subject to judicial review.

Lewis agrees with Crowther that the loans were mis-sold, but not for the same reasons:

…as head of the [Independent Taskforce on Student Finance Information], I told people that in 2017 the £21,000 repayment threshold was set to rise. I refuse to be – with hindsight – the Government’s mule for mis-selling student loans.

Crowther is a social media entrepreneur who has set up his own business in the year since leaving university. He has already been able to get his own mortgage, and used this as a comparison in his ability to interpret and make decisive choices about the loan he was taking. Crowther told the Huffington Post:

This highlights the fact none of us have a clue, when I took a mortgage out I sat down with an advisor – there’s no such thing for a student loan. We were the first year and we had no idea what was going on. You have no option to shop around.

So no matter how the government has misled students about their loan payments, it is clear that the burden of such a huge, complicated and potentially-changeable loan is confusing for new students. The majority are school children when they agree to the terms. There is far too much opacity and uncertainty for them to make an informed decision – not only in the economic concepts and financial terms of loans and debt in general, but also in the instability of our volatile economy as a whole.

Now that graduates are entering a job market which guarantees them little except this instability and uncertainty, it’s no wonder that they feel cheated and frustrated at the increasing amount of money they owe before their careers have even started, or that they are confused about the difficulties which getting an education has brought upon them. The cultural, and governmental, promises made to us about getting a degree are looking less and less worthy of the paper they’re written on.

Get involved!

For more information about student finance, go to the Student Loan Company site.

To find out information about your own student loan, go to the Student Loan Repayment site.

Find out more about loans on Money Saving Expert.

Support independent journalism.


Featured image via Wikimedia Commons

Image via screengrab

Support us and go ad-free

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us

Comments are closed