Listeners saw right through the set-up pulled by BBC Radio 4 on the morning of 6 April. The Today programme was featuring discussion on Labour’s new policy. The party has pledged to introduce free school meals for all primary school children at state schools in England. Labour would fund the policy through introducing VAT to private school tuition fees.
Broadly speaking, 93% of people go to state school, while only 7% go private.
But Radio 4 managed to invert reality by presenting a transfer of resources from private to public education as somehow damaging to ordinary people. Instead of representing the 93%, Radio 4 platformed parents with children at private school as the victims.
Wow. Radio 4 managed to get vox pops claiming that VAT on private school will punish "working class parents" with kids at private school
— Huw Lemmey (@huwlemmey) April 6, 2017
Despite only 7% of people attending private school, host Nick Robinson mocked Labour for referring to them as the “privileged few”. The show substantiated this by cherry-picking a middle-class mother, who said:
We sacrifice tonnes to send our children to private school. 20% on top would just make it not possible. We haven’t done full private school. It’s been selected years of private school education.
Listeners noted the reversal of reality:
Struggling to sympathise w/the parents of children complaining they won't be able to afford to send their kids to private school #r4today
— Helena Frisby (@helena0491) April 6, 2017
Hilarious. Let's not interview Eton because that would look bad, so let's find some poor middle class couple from Still Ives #r4today
— William Large (@wlarge63) April 6, 2017
Strange BBC #r4today is trying so hard to defend private schools not paying tax
— Ben Fermor (@ben_fermor) April 6, 2017
Most people seemed to be shocked that private schools do not pay VAT in the first place. On top of this, the majority of private schools are designated as charities and enjoy huge tax breaks. Even though only the wealthiest families benefit.
Corbyn should go further
Some argue that private schools should be defended because they take pressure off the public system.
Labour think calling 4class war'll save them. It won't.Private school fee payers save us all the cost of their child's school place.#r4today
— Jo Hugh (@obknit) April 6, 2017
But the very existence of private schools takes resources away from the state system. Typically, state schools receive around £5,000 annually per pupil. Meanwhile, St Paul’s, the school that former Chancellor George Osborne attended, charges around £24,000 annually per non-boarding pupil. So in reality, private schools put more pressure on public schools by allocating disproportionate resources to the rich.
These schools also reproduce a society run by a segregated elite. 71% of top military officials, 51% of leading print journalists, and 74% of judges all come from the mere 7% who attend private school.
Labour has proposed a policy that redistributes wealth from private to public education. Yet Radio 4 managed to invert the situation, as if the rich are the victims. We saw the same type of propaganda when Oxfam announced that eight people own as much wealth as half of the people on Earth. Instead of condemning such grotesque inequality, the media reframed the report as an attack on Bill Gates’ charitable activities.
Don’t let the BBC or the rest of the media move the goalposts to protect an elite they are a part of. Abolish private schools, nationalise their assets, then use their resources to improve education for all.
– Read more from The Canary on BBC bias.
Featured image via Tompagenet
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?