Streatham Labour just gave Chuka Umunna a ‘people’s vote’. But it wasn’t the one he wanted.

After a tight vote, Labour members voted in favour of democratic party reform in Streatham. But one person unlikely to be happy about it is Streatham’s centrist MP – and arch Corbyn critic – Chuka Umunna.
What was at stake?
The Canary previously covered the build-up to the vote in detail. Put simply, it determined whether Streatham Constituency Labour Party (CLP) should adopt an All Member Meeting system (AMM) which allows all members to vote to decide local labour policy. The existing general committee system (GC) had allowed a relatively small group of delegates to determine policy on behalf of all members.
The following tweet gives some insight into the proposed reform:
DEMOCRACY FOR STREATHAM#JC4PM2019 #GTTO pic.twitter.com/ph7aREVUhP
— davjam #GTTO #JC4PM2019 (@davjam8) January 31, 2019
Read on...
And many on the left in Streatham Labour believed this existing system permitted a small clique of Umunna’s allies to control the CLP:
In Labour, our members decide our policies – not unaccountable elites. That’s why St Leonard's in Streatham is voting to move to One Member One Vote or All Members Meetings. Make sure your voice is heard by coming to vote on Thursday. Read more https://t.co/xSHtP9CqiQ
— Streatham St Leonard's Labour (@StreathamSLLab) January 28, 2019
The possibility to easily move to an AMM system was permitted under Labour’s Democracy review which was championed by Jeremy Corbyn’s democratic reforms of the Labour Party. Significantly, this win could pave the way for a reselection process for Umunna, Streatham’s current MP. And as The Canary previously reported, Umunna has become despised by the left of the Labour Party due to his constant attacks on the current leadership.
A tight vote
The vote took place on 31 January with around 500 people in attendance:
At the @StreathamLabour AMM meeting. Well over 500 people here. Largest CLP meeting I've ever attended. Whatever happens tonight in the vote #Streatham Labour is looking proper healthy. #OneMemberOneVote pic.twitter.com/lmFhjgUxzk
— Martin Abrams 🐝🌹 (@Martin_Abrams) January 31, 2019
Huge hall of Labour members have come to vote on proposals for 'all members meetings' in Streatham CLP. There is still a big queue outside. This is what a mass movement looks like pic.twitter.com/XFZDzLmwSd
— Tom Peters (@tbtpeters) January 31, 2019
The final result was tight:
Result of vote in Streatham Constituency Labour Party on whether to move from a delegate structure to using All Member Meetings (AMMs) ~
190 (50.9%) ~ Yes
183 (49.1%) ~ NoThe CLP will now be run through AMMs that any CLP member can attend. This replaces the old delegate system
— Stats for Lefties (@LeftieStats) January 31, 2019
But was welcomed with euphoric scenes:
#StreathamCLP just voted to move to an all member system!!!!! pic.twitter.com/J2A5RXpR27
— 🐬Orcinus Orcallum🐬 (@CallumMair) January 31, 2019
Others saw the funny side of the outcome:
I think when Chuka Umunna called for a People’s Vote, he didn’t mean in Streatham…
— EL4C (@EL4JC) January 31, 2019
And Owen Jones, who campaigned for the outcome, congratulated the CLP:
well done you massive heroes!
— Owen Jones🌹 (@OwenJones84) January 31, 2019
An Important result for mass political participation
For many in attendance, the proceedings demonstrated why AMM is essential for greater political engagement. Tom Munday of the New Socialist remarked on the quality of speeches it permitted members to make:
Got to say- that was far more interesting than just about every meeting I've been to…
Streatham Left did themselves proud with some cracking speeches, particularly from new/young members, completely torpedoing the narrative that delegates are better for their representation
— Tom Munday (@tommundaycs) January 31, 2019
And for one member, this meant looking forward to attending future meetings:
Happy with small victory at the Streatham CLP I will be attending monthly meetings from now on
— maria palomares (@mpalomares2) January 31, 2019
Others commented on how the CLP had been run prior to the vote:
Even those in support of delegate structure commenting on 'how badly the CLP has been run', often it seems with the intention of keeping new members and ideas locked out.
— Tom Peters (@tbtpeters) January 31, 2019
Bitter centrist backlash
But unsurprisingly, not everyone was happy with the result – namely the so-called centrists of the party. Some in attendance heard disparaging comments aimed at members seeking democratic reform:
Overheard at Streatham AMM: ‘I wish the party had said that: “we’re full”.’ Didn’t hear the first part of the sentence but quite clear what he means. Anti-mass membership. Anti-labour as a real force for social change. Says it all.
— Woke Matron (@WokeMatron) January 31, 2019
And arch-Blairite and Labour right winger, Luke Akehurst, suggested the reforms somehow undermined minorities currently represented within the current delegate structure:
I thought Streatham was one of the most ethnically diverse areas in the UK, 42% non white? These folk seem a little bit un-diverse…. https://t.co/Qb9HJO2gfT
— Luke Akehurst (@lukeakehurst) February 1, 2019
And that it harmed Labour’s union links:
It's what two mass movements look like when they both mobilise. There were 183 votes against the 190 cast for breaking the union link and removing equal representation of women. https://t.co/YhsFPufUgH
— Luke Akehurst (@lukeakehurst) February 1, 2019
But Streatham socialists didn’t take these charges lying down:
Of all the rubbish filling up my timeline this morning, the argument that 'hundreds more women and trade unionists being given a vote reduces the representation of women and trade unionists' has to be the strangest. It was tried last night, I'm glad the majority disagreed. https://t.co/5bYpUx0RN0
— Tom Peters (@tbtpeters) February 1, 2019
And elsewhere, union members praised the opportunities for representation the AMM structure may provide.
The Blairite ship is sinking fast
The bitter reaction to the result by Labour’s centrists reveals a faction in terminal decline. It is a spent force, lashing out at democratic reforms that they fear undermine their historic domination. And, now democratically relieved from power, they can no longer so easily prop up their preferred candidates.
And as Skawkbox reported, the same result also occurred in Wimbledon CLP on the same night. But by a far larger margin. Let’s hope this is the start of things to come.
Featured image by Youtube and tbtpeters.
We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support
The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.
The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.
So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.
-
Show Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to leave a comment.Join the conversationPlease read our comment moderation policy here.