The Tories just got a stark warning to ‘learn the lessons’ of the past

Rishi Sunak and Boris Johnson
Steve Topple

The Trades Union Congress (TUC) has issued a stark warning to the government over the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic. It comes amid growing concerns about the state of the UK economy and a possible recession. And the TUC is very clear as to what path the government needs to take. And it involves not making the same mistakes of the past.

Economic chaos

City A.M. reported that the UK economy is in free fall. Data for March showed that gross domestic product (GDP) fell by a record 5.8%. The deputy governor of the Bank of England warned that unemployment could hit 1980s levels. And the boss of the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) said April’s figures could be dire. All this led chancellor Rishi Sunak to warn that:

We are likely to face a severe recession, the likes of which we haven’t seen

But so far, the Tory government’s plan looks worrying. The Canary previously reported that Sunak’s initial ideas for protecting the economy include potential public-sector pay freezes, an end to pension increases, and tax rises. But as we noted:

In short, if a government raises public sector pay and reduces taxes, people have more money to spend. In an economy like the UK’s, where it is reliant to the tune of hundreds of billions of pounds on people buying stuff, it would seem economically incompetent to restrict this.

Now, the TUC has proposed an alternative ‘road map’ for economic recovery. And it doesn’t involve pay and pension freezes.

“Unprepared for coronavirus”

In a press release, TUC general secretary Frances O’Grady warned that we needed to ‘learn the lessons’ of the previous decade that left the UK unprepared, economically, for the pandemic. She said:

The UK’s weak economy and ten years of cuts left our country unprepared for coronavirus. Only the dedication of millions of individual workers kept our country going.

Let’s learn the lesson. Together, we can work our way safely out of this recession.

The TUC has researched how the UK economy recovered after previous recessions. And it found that the strongest economic recoveries were, on the face of it, due to high public spending. For example, the strongest recovery was after the stock market crash of 1929 and great depression:

TUC Economic Recoveries Anaylsis

The worst economic recovery was after the 2007/08 financial crisis, a period of Tory-led austerity. So the TUC says that, to make sure the economy does bounce back after the pandemic, the government needs to spend to invest.

A six-point plan

The TUC noted that:

The evidence from the post-war recovery is that this investment for growth recovery plan can pay for itself. Millions of working families with higher disposable income create the economic demand needed for strong growth and healthy public finances. Stronger public services and an effective safety net will support people to start and grow businesses, and will better protect against a future pandemic.

And it has a six-point plan:

  • “Decent work and a new way of doing business: new business models based on fairer employment relationships”.
  • “Sustainable industry: economic stimulus for a just transition to net zero carbon. Rebuilding the UK’s industrial capacity with modern tech and training in new skills”.
  • “A real safety net: reforms to social security to provide help faster and prevent poverty”.
  • “Rebuilding public services: bringing our public services back to full strength, with decent pay for those who looked after us in the crisis, and a new focus on good jobs and direct employment in social care”.
  • “Equality at work: specific actions to make sure women, disabled people and BME groups do not suffer disproportionately from the impact of the coronavirus recession”.
  • “International solidarity: new international rules must prioritise decent jobs and public services for all”.
The devil in the detail

You can read the TUC’s full report here. It outlines measures which the TUC believes are needed to ensure a fair economic recovery for all. Some of these include:

  • Improved collective bargaining for workers.
  • “Corporate governance reform”, including making sure that companies employing over 250 people have at least a third of their boards made up of workers.
  • Overhauling the social security system, including ending conditionality related to claiming welfare and sanctions.
  • Increasing sick pay to around £320 a week; that is, the rate of the real living wage.
  • A jobs guarantee scheme, funded by the government, which would “provide a minimum six months job with accredited training, paid at least the real living wage, or the union negotiated rate for the job”.
  • Solving the “crisis in childcare”.
  • Investing in and “rebuilding” public services including ending outsourcing to private companies and extra funding for education.

But on top of the report, the TUC also discussed separately the realities that the pandemic has exposed in UK society.

“Glaring inequalities”

As policy and campaigns support officer Alex Collinson wrote, coronavirus has put into sharp focus the gaping inequalities that exist in our country. He noted that:

Covid-19 is far from the great leveller some would have us believe. The virus doesn’t discriminate – but the UK labour market certainly does.

Some people have been lucky enough to spend the last two months working from the comfort of their homes on full pay. Others have had no choice but to continue working as normal, either because of the type of work they do or because they can’t afford not to.

Some will have saved hundreds on reduced transport costs. Others have been so strapped for cash that they’re having to get by without essential goods, take on debt, or turn to our broken social security system for help.

Low-paid people are more likely to have to go to work, more likely to be furloughed and less likely to receive a good level of sick pay. …

This crisis has exposed – and exacerbated – glaring inequalities in the UK labour market.

But it’s not just within the labour market that these inequalities have been amplified.

The forgotten others

For example, learning disabled people have been dying of coronavirus at a higher rate than people in care homes. It’s led one charity to say learning disabled people had been “forgotten” during the pandemic. Then, financially, many single parents reliant on welfare will have been hit harder than two-parent families. Also, charities have accused the government of putting disabled people’s lives at risk with its approach to the pandemic. And the government has now thrown homeless people and rough sleepers under the bus. The point being that all these groups were already hit hardest by the previous rounds of Tory austerity. Now, their issues have just been compounded.

Learning lessons

O’Grady summed up the report by saying:

At its heart is good jobs. Jobs in a reborn UK manufacturing sector… in a social care sector finally getting some respect. Jobs in the green tech of the future. Let’s rebuild our country through hard work, determination and investment in all our futures – not cuts to spending, deregulation and tax breaks for millionaires and bosses.

Now, the ball is in the government’s court. Either it can repeat the same mistakes of the previous decade, or it can take stock of how previous actions led us, in part, to the economic and social crisis we’re now in. Because there is clearly another way. And the TUC believe it’s one that would benefit us all.

Featured image via Guardian News – YouTube

We need your help ...

The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.

Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.

We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.

Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?

The Canary Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. The Tories are not ‘making mistakes’ and they are not ever going to ‘learn from the past’. They are on an ideological mission that, in their minds, can have nothing getting in its way. Their policies are deliberate and they work – for the tiny elite which they serve. That is why, after the Covid-19 health crisis, lessons will not ‘be learned’. The crisis will be taken advantage of to not only continue but accelerate their neoliberal agenda like the privatisation of health and education, the reduction of workers’ wages and the evisceration of rights.

    2. Frances ‘I won’t turn down a payrise to £175k pa’ O’ Grady? Any Union Boss who genuinely believes they are entitled to that level of pay is a true trougher. She just needs to live in a Council House and refuse to leave like Bob Crow for maximum scumbag points. Like old Len, she couldn’t care less about workers, just lining her own pockets and pushing student politics such as boycotting Israeli goods.
      Hardly a stark warning either. More like Lefties try to get their way despite being pumped at the last two elections with them and their economic policies being firmly rejected.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.