Protesters raise their voices against mega prisons in a ‘historic demo’ in Yorkshire

Siyanda Mngaza's mother
Support us and go ad-free

People from all over the UK descended on HMP Full Sutton in Yorkshire at the weekend in what campaigners called a “historic demonstration”. The protest was the biggest of its kind ever to be held at the prison, and it took place in solidarity with imprisoned men of colour Kevan Thakrar and Dwayne Fulgence.

The protesters are demanding an end to racist violence towards the men. They’re also calling for the abolition of a planned 1,440-bed ‘mega prison’ on the site.

Prisoners cheered from inside the walls as protesters circled the prison, making noise and speeches in solidarity with those incarcerated.

Kevan Thakrar and Dwayne Fulgence

Thakrar has been imprisoned for more than 13 years11 of these have been spent in the UK’s brutal Close Supervision Centres, restricted to his cell for 23 or more hours per day. According to Community Action on Prison Expansion (CAPE), CSCs are:

‘prisons within prisons’, the UK equivalent of the USA’s ‘Supermax’ prisons. They are the highest security and most repressive prison units within the country, where prisoners are held in solitary confinement in an extremely controlled environment for long periods of time.

Thakrar was placed in the CSC system after he defended himself against a racist attack by prison guards in 2010. Sisters Uncut Leeds and CAPE are demanding that Thakrar is immediately transferred to a safer prison to save him from racist violence from both prison staff and other prisoners. In 2019, he was also stabbed four times by a known racist in HMP Full Sutton.

Dwayne Fulgence is a Black Muslim man, also held in segregation in Full Sutton. According to campaigners, Fulgence was brutally beaten by four white officers in racist attack on 22nd April. He was denied any medical assistance as well as access to a lawyer.

Read on...

“Grave concern”

On 10 March 2021, Nils Melzer, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, wrote:

we express our grave concern at the indefinite and prolonged detention of Mr. Thakrar in what appears to be conditions of solitary confinement. Both in this individual case and in terms of general policy, we are particularly concerned at the reported use of prolonged or indefinite solitary confinement in Close Supervision Centers, thus predictably inflicting severe pain or suffering amounting to cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment or punishment, or even torture.

And in May 2021, the UN released a statement expressing concern that UK prisons currently receive an extra £100k annually per inmate for each person held in solitary confinement. Melzer said:

I am seriously concerned that this creates a misguided financial incentive for sending prisoners to CSCs and keeping them there, and it casts doubt on the claim that these decisions are based exclusively on an individualized risk assessment.

Singled out

The Canary’s Tom Anderson believes that Thakrar is being brutally treated because of his vocal resistance to prison conditions. Anderson wrote:

Thakrar has been a long term and vocal critic of the CSC system, so it’s hardly surprising that he’s being singled out for further punishment. He told a friend on the phone that he believes the move to segregate him is a retaliation by the authorities for his resistance to prison conditions.

Anderson continued:

Throughout his sentence, Thakrar has also made consistent complaints against the prison authorities, as well as working with support groups on the outside such as the Anarchist Black Cross and Prisoner Solidarity Network.

Free Siyanda

Among the protesters standing outside HMP Full Sutton was the mother of Siyanda Mngaza. Mngaza was sentenced to prison for four and a half years after she was racially attacked in Wales in 2019.

Mngaza is just 4ft 10″ tall and was badly injured by three people, two of them men twice her age. According to the campaign Free Siyanda, none of her attackers were taken into custody or arrested. Instead, Mngaza was convicted of grievous bodily harm and sentenced.

We don’t need mega prisons

Protesters also descended on the prison to make it clear that they don’t want the government’s planned new ‘mega prisons’. The state plans to create more than 10,000 new prison places nationally – known as the Prison Estates Transformation Programme. And 1,440 of those spaces will be built at the site of Full Sutton prison.

A spokesperson from Sisters Uncut Leeds said:

As we see from the horrific racist attacks experienced by Kev and Dwayne, prisons are not the answer to serious violence in our society – they instead create more violence. The planned mega prison at Full Sutton means throwing more money at violence against people from marginalised communities at a time when essential domestic violence services are critically underfunded and austerity has deprived our communities for over a decade.

They continued:

The Ministry of Justice cares more about profiting from the cheap labour of prisoners than they do about protecting people from harm and poverty. We demand an end to the Prison Estates Transformation Programme now. We want investment in services that help people rather than harm people!

Protests will continue until the government listens

In May, UN expert Melzer announced that he had raised concerns about the CSC system directly with the British government, “and regrettably, so far, the United Kingdom has not provided any response.” Melzer said he will continue to “monitor the situation”.

In the meantime, campaigners will continue raise their voices. For Kevan Thakrar, for Dwayne Fulgence, for Siyanda Mngaza, and for all those incarcerated.

Featured image via CAPE

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. Thakrar is a truly violent piece of shit who deserves to hang. I note you don’t mention in the article his reasons for being in Prison. He executed a father and son with a machine gun, making them kneel before killing them. He slashed a prison guards throat with a broken bottle, allegedly in self defence. A real hero…
      Dwayne Fulgence also murdered a man with by shooting him, although with a pistol rather than a machine gun. The man he shot had stepped in to defend Dwayne’s intended target, but Dwayne shot him anyway. Several days before the murder, he opened fire at his ex partner’s front door. Again, a piece of rope would be the suitable way of dealing with this scumbag.
      The Canary showing yet again they support violent, murderers over law abiding citizens. Why not mention the vile actions of these men that put them in prison? No journalistic integrity behind these articles.

    2. I didn’t make reference to Siyanda in my previous comment as I was unaware of the case. Having now read about it, and spoken to friends who live in Wales I have a better understanding. Siyanda glassed a woman in the face, knocking her unconscious in front of her 9 year old child. Siyanda had previously smashed a glass bottle over her partners head. A violent, domestic abuser who acted like a thug and was quite rightly given a prison sentence. On this occasion, pulling the race card didn’t allow her to escape responsibility for her actions. She was, quite rightly, restrained after glassing the woman, and claimed that this was a racist attack. A cowardly woman who is behind bars, right where she should be.

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.