• Disrupting Power Since 2015
  • Donate
  • Login
Monday, May 19, 2025
  • Login
  • Register
Canary
MEDIA THAT DISRUPTS
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
MANAGE SUBSCRIPTION
SUPPORT
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Canary
No Result
View All Result

Calls for Government to reform ‘unfair’ laws on ‘sleep-in’ carers after ruling

The Canary by The Canary
19 March 2021
in News, UK
Reading Time: 3 mins read
165 7
A A
1
Home UK News
319
SHARES
2.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The government has been called on to urgently reform “out-of-date and unfair” laws on payments for “sleep-in” carers, after the Supreme Court ruled they are not entitled to the minimum wage for their whole shift.

The night watch

In a landmark ruling on 19 March, the UK’s highest court dismissed an appeal by a former Mencap support worker against a previous ruling that carers are only entitled to the minimum wage when they are required to be awake for work – and not while asleep.

Lawyers representing Claire Tomlinson-Blake, who was supported by the trade union Unison, argued carers who work so-called sleep-in shifts are “like a nightwatchman”.

The government needs to step in and change the law following today’s #SupremeCourt ruling that #carers, who have to sleep at their workplace in case they are needed overnight, are not entitled to the national minimum wage (NMW) for their whole shift: https://t.co/YJt0gXXvLX

— Unite the union: join a union (@unitetheunion) March 19, 2021

Tomlinson-Blake, who worked in the East Riding of Yorkshire, was paid £22.35 for a sleep-in shift between 10pm and 7am plus one hour’s pay at the then-national minimum wage of £6.70, making a total of £29.05.

At a hearing in February last year, her barrister Sean Jones QC told the Supreme Court that carers like Tomlinson-Blake were getting less than minimum wage.

John Shannon, who worked as an on-call night care assistant at a care home in Surrey, also challenged the 2018 decision by the Court of Appeal that sleep-in carers were not entitled to the minimum wage for the whole of their shift.

The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed Tomlinson-Blake and Shannon’s appeals in a ruling on 19 March.

Supreme Court sleep-in appeal decision is blow for ​everyone in social care, says UNISON https://t.co/N4PoWUayuL

— UNISON – UK's largest union (@unisontheunion) March 19, 2021

In the judgment, justice Mary Arden said a “sleep-in worker who is merely present is treated as not working for the purpose of calculating the hours which are to be taken into account for national minimum wage purposes”.

She added that “the fact that he was required to be present during specified hours was insufficient to lead to the conclusion that he was working”.

Action

The decision prompted calls for the government to take action, not just in relation to laws covering “sleep-in payments”, but also the care sector as a whole.

Unison general secretary Christina McAnea said:

No-one is a winner from today’s judgment.

Everyone loses until the Government intervenes to mend a broken system that relies on paying skilled staff a pittance. This dire situation was ignored by the Government for years before Covid, and again in the recent budget.

Today’s judgment shows ministers can’t disregard the desperate need for major reform a moment longer.

Gail Cartmail, assistant general secretary of the trade union Unite, said the social care sector “has been facing a funding crisis for the last 20 years”.

She added:

It is now time for the Government to step in and change the legislation so care workers receive at least the national minimum wage during the course of the whole night.

Edel Harris, chief executive of the learning disability charity Mencap – which opposed Tomlinson-Blake’s appeal – said that, if the appeals were allowed, care providers could have faced “devastating unfunded back-pay liabilities” of around £400m. She said Mencap understood that “many hard-working care workers will be disappointed”, but added:

It is no exaggeration to say that, if the ruling had been different, it would have severely impacted on a sector which is already underfunded and stretched to breaking point.

Some providers would have gone bust and, ultimately, the people who rely on care would have suffered.

Matthew Wort, a partner at Anthony Collins Solicitors, which represented Care England before the Court of Appeal, said:

While this judgment removes a serious risk for providers, the long-term stability of the UK social care sector hangs in the balance.

The coronavirus pandemic has added significant pressure on providers already on their knees due to funding cuts, many of which are now assessing the viability of their services – to the potential detriment of people who rely on care for their day-to-day needs.

Now is the time for central Government to increase its investment in the social care sector, providing the funding local authorities need to maintain healthy care markets.

Sustainability

A government spokesperson said:

We are aware of the judgment from the Supreme Court.

Care workers perform a vital role and they have worked tirelessly throughout the pandemic to support our most vulnerable, and we are committed to supporting them.

We have provided billions of pounds to support adult social care during the pandemic including on infection and prevention control measures, free PPE, priority vaccinations and additional testing.

The Local Government Association (LGA), which intervened in the Supreme Court case, also welcomed the ruling. But the chairman of the LGA’s community wellbeing board, councillor Ian Hudspeth, said:

Today’s decision does not remove the need for a sustainable funding settlement for adult and children’s social care, which includes important decisions on the workforce such as pay, recruitment and career development.

The Government should bring forward its proposals on adult social care funding as soon as possible.

Share128Tweet80
Previous Post

The government wants to recruit EVERYONE to counter-terrorism

Next Post

Ian Hislop exposed the Tories BS live on Question Time

Next Post
Question Time on 18 March

Ian Hislop exposed the Tories BS live on Question Time

Kill the Bill banner

'Kill the Bill' protests are happening across the country this weekend

Mohamud Hassan

Mohamud Hassan’s family are still fighting for justice. And they're not alone.

Elections watchdog contacts Tories over Boris Johnson's Downing St flat revamp

Split image showing William Shawcross and extracts of letter from Muslim organisations

Muslims are boycotting the Shawcross review and resisting Prevent. We can't do it alone.

Please login to join discussion
Liz Kendall lying to parliament over DWP PIP cuts
Analysis

Kendall caught misleading parliament four times in 23 minutes over DWP PIP cuts

by Steve Topple
18 May 2025
Israel's famine in Gaza: 93% of the population are now food insecure
Analysis

Israel’s famine in Gaza: 93% of the population are now food insecure

by Alaa Shamali
18 May 2025
المجاعة في غزة: 93% من السكان يعانون الآن من انعدام الأمن الغذائي
Analysis

المجاعة في غزة: 93% من السكان يعانون الآن من انعدام الأمن الغذائي

by Alaa Shamali
18 May 2025
Montage of Jason. Top left: Jason in face mask and with eye mask looking up from bed. Top centre: Jason on his most recent birthday, in hospital with a mask on his head like a party hat. Top right: cannula on Jason's hand. Bottom left: gross-looking mash potato and cauliflower in a bowl. Bottom centre: Multiple water jugs on a table with a cup. Bottom right: Jason's hand swelled up severe ME
Long Reads

A care home is leaving a severe ME patient dangerously dehydrated after multiple other failures

by Hannah Sharland
18 May 2025
On 15 May, Turkey hosted Ukrainian and Russian representatives for peace talks - yet it won't move on peace at home
Analysis

Turkish regime should focus on peace at home rather than posturing about peace abroad

by Ed Sykes
18 May 2025
  • Contact
  • About & FAQ
  • Get our Daily News Email
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

The Canary
PO Box 71199
LONDON
SE20 9EX

Canary Media Ltd – registered in England. Company registration number 09788095.

For guest posting, contact [email protected]

For other enquiries, contact: [email protected]

The Canary is owned and run by independent journalists and volunteers, NOT offshore billionaires.

You can write for us, or support us by making a regular or one-off donation.

© Canary Media Ltd 2024, all rights reserved | Website by Monster | Hosted by Krystal | Privacy Settings

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • UK
    • Global
    • Analysis
    • Trending
  • Editorial
  • Features
    • Features
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Money
    • Science
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Travel
    • Sport & Gaming
  • Media
    • Video
    • Cartoons
  • Opinion

© 2023 Canary - Worker's co-op.

Before you go, have you seen...?

Liz Kendall lying to parliament over DWP PIP cuts
Analysis
Steve Topple

Kendall caught misleading parliament four times in 23 minutes over DWP PIP cuts

Israel's famine in Gaza: 93% of the population are now food insecure
Analysis
Alaa Shamali

Israel’s famine in Gaza: 93% of the population are now food insecure

المجاعة في غزة: 93% من السكان يعانون الآن من انعدام الأمن الغذائي
Analysis
Alaa Shamali

المجاعة في غزة: 93% من السكان يعانون الآن من انعدام الأمن الغذائي

Montage of Jason. Top left: Jason in face mask and with eye mask looking up from bed. Top centre: Jason on his most recent birthday, in hospital with a mask on his head like a party hat. Top right: cannula on Jason's hand. Bottom left: gross-looking mash potato and cauliflower in a bowl. Bottom centre: Multiple water jugs on a table with a cup. Bottom right: Jason's hand swelled up severe ME
Long Reads
Hannah Sharland

A care home is leaving a severe ME patient dangerously dehydrated after multiple other failures

ADVERTISEMENT
Business
Nathan Spears

Smart Delivery Positions Mr Nang as a Leader in Australia’s Cream Charger Market

Lifestyle
Nathan Spears

Social Media Activism: How Grassroots Movements Are Gaining Power Online

Travel
Nathan Spears

Best Destinations In Spain For A Couples Holiday