When someone spends 10 years in prison for stealing a phone, you know our justice system is broken

Bars on prison cells

Former Labour home secretary David Blunkett introduced Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP) sentences in 2005. An IPP sentence is when the courts send you to prison for a minimum time period with no definitive release date. A parole board then later decides that date. And while IPPs were scrapped in 2012, it wasn’t retrospectively applied. This means people already in prison under an IPP remain inside, or within the justice system, until some unspecified date in the future.

In 2014, Blunkett said he regretted introducing IPPs and Labour “got the implementation wrong”. United Group for Reform of IPP (UNGRIPP) claims that “8,711 people in England & Wales” received an IPP sentence between 2005 and 2013. Government data shows there were still 1,722 people in prison without any clear release date as of 30 June 2021. According to UNGRIPP, however, the figure is much higher. It told The Canary:

There are 1,722 unreleased, 96% of them are over tariff. Many by 10 or more years. 1,332 are in recall. That takes the total IPP prison population to 3,054 and this discounts the 245 who are in secure hospitals due to the impact of the sentence on their mental health.

Campaigners, loved ones, and people inside prison under an IPP also spoke to The Canary. And while none of those we spoke to disputed their guilt, they believe their never-ending imprisonment is an “injustice”. They spoke about the living hell they’re experiencing as a result of an inhumane system of imprisonment.

The current situation with IPPs

UNGRIPP wants the IPP system to radically change so the person in prison gets clarity on the duration of their sentence and a definitive release date. Currently, they’re working on submissions to the Justice Select Committee. According to the committee, IPPs:

were designed to ensure that dangerous violent and sexual offenders stayed in custody for as long as they presented a risk to society.

Yet none of the people The Canary spoke to were convicted of any such crime. In fact, one man was convicted of stealing a mobile phone. Once a person serves the mandatory sentence in prison, they remain inside:

Read on...

until the Parole Board determines that the person has reduced their risk enough to be safely released (generally by rehabilitative activities) followed by a life licence in the community from which they may be recalled to prison if they breach their licence or reoffend. Ten years after their initial release, IPP prisoners can apply to have their licence terminated.

So they could remain in prison and the justice system indefinitely.

“Labelled and stigmatised”

Ash Ellis has been imprisoned on an IPP. He told The Canary he wants “to see change and justice”. Ellis says he currently suffers:

with severe anxiety and depression due to being labelled and stigmatised as an IPP.

From the age of two until 18, Ellis grew up in care. He said he had done well at school but when:

I left care I didn’t get any support and was homeless which resulted in me threatening a man and his mate in a street robbery.

Since then he says:

I am newly released and I was originally released in 2016 after serving 10 years of a 22 month sentence. Since my release I have been recalled 4 times and seem to be going around in circles with it.

He added:

I have been recalled 4 times due to me panicking about recall and not returning to curfew. I have also been recalled twice for allegations which have not been proven… I’m told I have to go through a process to get out which takes 6 months, that’s how long the parole process is.

And that:

Since being in prison I reunited with my dad after 25 years at my murdered brother’s funeral which I had to cope with in prison. I have served longer than the person who stabbed my brother 22 times and so I feel a huge amount of injustice and so [too] does my dad and my other brother. It is unfortunate I know but the injustice is obviously [affecting] my mental health

16 years and no release date in sight

Shaun Thomas was originally sentenced to two years and eleven months, yet so far he’s served 16 years. He’s currently in a secure hospital. Because of Thomas’s speech impediment and deafness, he can’t complete the “rehabilitative activities” for the parole board.

Under the current system he’ll remain in prison until such time as he completes those courses. He says that during his entire time inside he’s only had one parole board hearing.

Six weeks became more than a thousand days

Another man who spoke to The Canary chose to remain anonymous. He said he was first sentenced in 2008 for just under two years, but he ultimately served four years. After being released, he was recalled two to three months later for “behavioural concerns”.

He was released again but recalled the following October following allegations made by another person. And while those allegations were dismissed in court, he still went to prison for two years and seven months because the probation service said he “had put himself in a predicament”. The parole board said he had to “stay inside and think about what I had done”.

But that wasn’t the end of it. He was recalled at least a further two times to serve nine months and six weeks respectively. Those last six weeks turned into “1,300 days”. He says he was then refused release by the parole board because it found that he:

had not been tested enough [to warrant release, so], you need to spend another 15 months in custody before we will reassess your suitability for release.

Just for stealing a phone

Clara White told us her brother Thomas has been inside for 10 years for stealing a phone. He originally received a two-year IPP sentence. During this entire time, he’s been sent to around 10-16 different prisons. He’s also spent a lot of time in segregation units. This has taken a toll on his mental health.

According to White’s sister, every time he was moved he had to start his time in segregation all over again. This led to a longer than expected time in segregation. White says the toll on his mental health was noticeable from their telephone conversations. She said she could tell by the way he was talking and by what he was talking about. She also said her brother was quite religious before entering prison, and that following a long period in segregation he:

became the bible. He started to act out as a disciple. He grew his hair to his elbows and his beard…he draws stick men on the wall and he talks to the stick men and when he does go on some exercise he tells people he’s Jesus Christ.

She said the prison staff said he “was very unpredictable, nobody can go and see him”. But she said they refused to make any connections between his behaviour and the fact they’d kept him in segregation for so long. She said he didn’t have any mental health issues prior to going into prison. However, at the moment he suffers from psychosis, borderline personality disorder, and ADHD.

She said some of the prisons he went to didn’t have the necessary development courses he needed to show the parole board he “was fit for release”. She believes this was a significant contribution to his current length of incarceration. And in the prisons that did have the necessary courses, other prisoners got priority. His mother once went to visit her son in prison, and according to the sister she:

looked around that visiting room for ten minutes and she had to go and ask one of the prison officers, ‘can you tell me which one is my son?’ Because my brother was that unrecognisable not even his own mother recognised him. He’d grown his hair long to his elbows, a big long beard, he weighed about nine stone, he’d had hardly any natural sun, his skin was really pale. His own mother couldn’t find her own son in that visiting room.

She said her mother “has never been the same” since that visit.

A Ministry of Justice spokesperson told The Canary:

The number of IPP prisoners has fallen by two-thirds since 2012 – and is down 9% in the last year. We are helping those still in custody progress towards release, but as a judge deemed them to be a high risk to the public, the independent Parole Board must decide if they are safe to leave prison.

It also denied that IPP prisoners “need to complete a specific development course in order to be released”.

The campaign continues

UNGRIPP is campaigning for a change to IPPs which includes clarity around release dates. It wants the burden of proof that the prisoner remains a “risk to society” to be placed on to the parole board, as opposed to the person in prison. It also wants the IPP sentence to end once the person leaves prison.

The resolve and solidarity of these campaigners in the face of such odds is an inspiration. If more people get behind this campaign, it could help them get what they want for their loved ones.

Featured image via Unsplash – Emiliano Bar

Get involved

We need your help to keep speaking the truth

Every story that you have come to us with; each injustice you have asked us to investigate; every campaign we have fought; each of your unheard voices we amplified; we do this for you. We are making a difference on your behalf.

Our fight is your fight. You’ve supported our collective struggle every time you gave us a like; and every time you shared our work across social media. Now we need you to support us with a monthly donation.

We have published nearly 2,000 articles and over 50 films in 2021. And we want to do this and more in 2022 but we don’t have enough money to go on at this pace. So, if you value our work and want us to continue then please join us and be part of The Canary family.

In return, you get:

* Advert free reading experience
* Quarterly group video call with the Editor-in-Chief
* Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
* 20% discount in our shop

Almost all of our spending goes to the people who make The Canary’s content. So your contribution directly supports our writers and enables us to continue to do what we do: speaking truth, powered by you. We have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence our vital opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right-wing mainstream media.

With your help we can continue:

* Holding political and state power to account
* Advocating for the people the system marginalises
* Being a media outlet that upholds the highest standards
* Campaigning on the issues others won’t
* Putting your lives central to everything we do

We are a drop of truth in an ocean of deceit. But we can’t do this without your support. So please, can you help us continue the fight?

The Canary Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. Must be one of Starmer’s Loopholed Concoctions! Starmer will do ANYTHING to bang up the “Undeserving Poor” for his Beloved 10 Years!
      10 Years for “benefit fraud”, aka not looking disabled enough or not fitting into one of his Loopholed ULTRA SQUARE Boxes!
      10 Years for throwing statues of Slave Traders, Genocidal Maniacs, Racists etc into the ocean etc, etc etc etc etc!
      He did get Jimmy Saville, the Spy Cops and many more off the hook!
      A True Champion for the Elites/Establishment’s TORYDOM Puppetry, First Division!

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.