Politics moves fast these days. But if you remember back to Friday 17 March, you’ll recall that George Osborne – a sitting MP and upper-class odd-job man – was made editor of The London Evening Standard. A move that even Tories were shocked by. And yet several Labour politicians and figures within the party were supportive of the move. Those figures included the ghosts of politics past: Tony Blair and Alastair Campbell.
— Sadiq Khan (@SadiqKhan) March 17, 2017
Par for the course
Campbell went in strong, but admits he was initially taken aback:
Hearing about George Osborne’s new job was not quite on a par with turning on the radio to hear ‘John Major had an affair with Edwina Currie’ – but it’s not far off it.
And he’s right. It isn’t “on a par”. Because Major and Currie was a case of two human beings doing what comes naturally to human beings. Even dreary and grey human beings like Major and Currie.
A sitting MP being made a newspaper editor, however, is a conflict of interest so large that ‘conflict of interest’ doesn’t even cover it. It’s more like a ‘tactical nuclear strike on common sense’.
High but capable
Campbell was also quick to defend the appointment:
There is also the question of whether or not being an MP should be considered a full time job to the exclusion of all others. I have never been wholly persuaded of that one. After all, until the calamitous referendum, he was both MP for Tatton and chancellor of the exchequer with considerable responsibility for running one of the six biggest economies in the world.
The fact that Osborne did two important jobs at once sounds impressive. Until of course you acknowledge that he was probably THE WORST Chancellor we’ve ever had. Although, to be fair, that wasn’t solely because he was over-stretched. It was also because he’s a gurning incompetent with a rancid ideology in a party full of crooks.
Tony Blair, meanwhile, told Andrew Marr something similar to what Campbell had spouted:
I don’t know whether having those jobs is do-able or not but I think it’s a great thing for the Evening Standard, why not? He’s a highly capable guy and it should make politics more interesting.
Which is at least true. Much like how austerity made things more interesting for poor people, and the invasion of Iraq made things more interesting for Iraqis. Although obviously ‘interesting’ is not always equal to concepts like ‘okay’ or ‘non-hazardous’.
Enemy of my enemy
Campbell did have some criticisms of Osborne. In particular of the austerity programme that Labour abstained from opposing:
Here is a man on whose watch the rich got considerably richer while the poor got poorer
Although he ultimately wrapped things up by saying:
If he is true to his beliefs and, more importantly, to the readers, he will use the paper to put the kind of scrutiny on the government Brexit strategy that the Brextremist Lie Machine papers are refusing to do.
With which there are three major problems:
- History has shown us that Osborne either isn’t true to his beliefs, or he’s untrue about what beliefs he actually holds.
- Osborne could use the position to combat every ill in the Western world, and it still wouldn’t be an appropriate role for a sitting MP.
- The people who voted Brexit because they’re worried about corrupt political elites aren’t going to change their minds because a newspaper edited by George ‘corrupt political elite’ Osborne told them to.
Do we want to go back to that?
In the New Labour years, Campbell and Blair were adept at using the media as an extension of their office. They were also skilled at showing that, on a larger level, neither of them could reliably tell right from wrong. And as such, it’s hardly surprising that they’d see no problem with a newspaper being run by the sort of poisonous character that newspapers should really be holding to account.
What is surprising is that media outlets keep giving these New Labour relics print space. And also the total lack of awareness that they show. On the one hand claiming to represent a political centre that is the ‘only rational choice’; on the other getting excited about how a Tory newspaper editor might personally benefit them. And if Osborne did have any journalistic integrity, the first people he’d call out in print would be them.
– See more Canary articles about New Labour.
– Support The Canary here to help us bring you more of the news that matters.
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?