Amber Rudd has resigned. After weeks of pressure over the Windrush scandal and her misleading parliament on deportation targets, she has finally gone.
But the response from the BBC was gobsmacking. Speaking about the resignation on BBC Weekend News, anchor Clive Myrie stated:
This, obviously a devastating tragedy for Amber Rudd and for the government in general.
Political correspondent Ian Watson agreed:
Yes… First of all for Amber Rudd personally about her own reputation.
People quickly took to Twitter to address the comments:
BBC News at 10pm tonight: presenter says: “Obviously this is a tragedy for Amber Rudd”. TRAGEDY FOR Amber Rudd – what about the tragedy and detrimental effect for the victims of these despicable actions. The BBC manages the change the emphasis yet again. Poor Amber!
— Tony Mann (@TonyMann2013) April 29, 2018
Appauling comment by the BBC. It is a tragedy for those affected by Windrush, and the hostile environment regarding immigration by the home office. Mrs May set up this tragedy, Mrs Rudd carried out Mrs May's policy directives. Neither of them are risking being deported.
— Debs Woodhall-James (@debswj62) April 30, 2018
Scottish National Party (SNP) MP Hannah Bardell also pulled the BBC up on its comments:
BBC presenter seriously describing Amber Rudd’s resignation as a ‘devastating tragedy’ for her…..
What about the devastation and tragedy her and the Home Office have imposed upon innocent people such as the #WindrushGeneration??
Get a grip BBC.
— Hannah Bardell (@HannahB4LiviMP) April 29, 2018
Others pointed out exactly why this isn’t a “tragedy”:
BBC News describe Amber Rudd's resignation as a 'Devastating Tragedy' She has been found out as a liar, not diagnosed with terminal cancer.Yet more biased reporting from the BBC.
— Mark Draper (@MarkDraper01) April 29, 2018
BBC called this "a tragedy for Amber Rudd"
Losing your job (and she's still an MP, not like she's on the streets) because you repeatedly lied is not a tragedy. It's justice. Being deported from your own country by a racist government is a tragedy. #ToriesOut #AmberRudd #BBC
— Jack Hancock #JC4PM (@1983Jackhancock) April 29, 2018
The real tragedy
As these Twitter users pointed out, Rudd’s resignation was not a “tragedy”. But the suffering that the Home Office policies have caused, under Rudd and before her Theresa May, is a tragedy. From the Windrush generation to the women who’ve been on hunger strike in Yarl’s Wood, and to anyone threatened by the racist ‘go home’ vans, these policies have spread misery across the country.
It’s also a tragedy that the UN has found there is “structural racism” in the UK due to the number of Black Asian and Minority Ethnic people who have died after contact with the police. Another tragedy which lies directly at the door of the Home Office.
And while Rudd’s resignation is welcome, it is a tragedy that the architect of the policies, May, is still in power. Because the blame for the scandal lies directly at her feet and with the “really hostile environment” she wanted to create for immigrants in the UK.
There is nothing tragic about Rudd resigning. And serious questions need to be asked of the BBC when it thinks it’s acceptable to change the narrative in this way.
– Support the Anti Raids Network.
– Support the End Immigration Detention Network.
Featured image via screengrab
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?