The Guardian reported on 10 September that Labour is now viewed as “the party of quinoa and student protests”. But people on social media weren’t having any of it.
From pie to quinoa
Research by consultancy firm Britain Thinks surveyed voters in two marginal constituencies, Crewe and Thurrock, to understand what drives voter perception. The survey also asked 2,000 further people nationwide.
One question asked participants what food Labour would eat if it was a person. A common answer, the Guardian reports, was “fancy grain” quinoa. Speaking to the paper, Britain Thinks director Deborah Mattinson said:
It was so striking that what people said to us was: Labour used to be working class, it used to be a pie and a pint – it’s now a protesting student. It used to be someone playing the bingo; now it’s someone going on a demo.
In the same study, the Conservatives were described as a “doctor, well educated” and would cook lamb shank on Come Dine With Me. But, as the Guardian mentioned at the end of its article, twice as many of those surveyed saw Labour as being “in touch with ordinary people”.
And users of Twitter have taken the Guardian to task over this apparent bias.
Some have picked up on what they see as a misinterpretation of data:
— Roger ℍ. (@rogerha) September 11, 2018
(1)One single participant in a "Britain Thinks" focus group in Crewe said Labour had gone from "Pie & a Pint" to "Quinoa" (tbh they sound like a very Waitrose LibDem ) this was transformed by the Guardian into "research with swing voters". pic.twitter.com/EQrPYomh6r
— Solomon Hughes (@SolHughesWriter) September 11, 2018
And others attempted to break down the idea that quinoa is inherently anti-working class:
Plenty of working class people know what quinoa is, but the trope that Labour is the party of quinoa-munching liberal Guardian readers is an invention & a favourite of quinoa-munching liberal Guardian readers. Frank is quite right. It's bullshit. https://t.co/gczQY8ZQxB
— Ally Fogg (@AllyFogg) September 11, 2018
Well I had quinoa in my lunch yesterday but I also draw the bingo at the annual Failsworth Labour Party quiz night so it doesn’t always have to be one or the other…
Labour has shifted focus from bingo to quinoa, say swing voters https://t.co/WmzaHbB39k
— Sean Fielding (@cllrsfielding) September 11, 2018
One pointed out the conflicting accusations against Labour in the establishment press:
You see the problem with incitement is this. Labour Party members r accused of being type of Quinoa eating Islington Luvies who dont understand the WC. Whilst on the other hand they are the Fourth Reichs stormtroppers. Now as far as can see neither true! Pissed of with Austerity
— Carl Reid (@CarlRei49848972) September 11, 2018
While many were prosaic in their criticism, seeing the piece as the Guardian taking a chance to have a pop at Labour:
Labour has shifted focus from bingo to quinoa, say swing votershttps://t.co/Whku1E3v4N
— robert jeffery (@robjeffecology) September 11, 2018
This is it! The Guardian is effectively admitting that it has run out of ways of bashing the Labour Party. Never mind the quinoa, let's end austerity and neoliberalism! #nevermindthequinoa #beyondneoliberalism https://t.co/VHztOo0RVH
— Dr. Richard Ingram ???? (@ringram4mad) September 11, 2018
"Labour has shifted focus from bingo to quinoa, say swing voters"https://t.co/YtXZ1kQAOm
— Paul Draper (@TheBlackGate) September 11, 2018
The news didn’t put one person off, though. In fact they celebrated the news:
I like quinoa. So frankly, this is one of the best things I've read about Labour all summer. Forward!
— Alan Lockey (@Modern_Lockey) September 11, 2018
Meanwhile, UK-based pulse and grain producers Hodmedod’s took the opportunity to say domestically-grown quinoa is available:
— Hodmedod's (@Hodmedods) September 11, 2018
It’s a seed
Quinoa has had associations with a middle-class hippie lifestyle since its popularity hit critical mass in the early 2010s. Its popularity with vegan and wholefood consumers became a point of contention. Technically a seed, quinoa’s popularity in the West has masked a number of ecological and social issues for its producers. As a result, quinoa is used to ridicule a sort of self-obsessed, uncaring, middle-class personality.
The Guardian’s attempt to lead the story with this connection simply hands Labour critics and the right yet another tool for criticism, even if it’s based on a shaky view of the data. But the public aren’t fooled by the narrative, and the Guardian isn’t getting away with it.
– Join The Canary so we can keep holding the establishment media to account.
Featured image via Pom² – Wikimedia
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?