On 3 March Jeremy Corbyn was assaulted outside Finsbury Park Mosque. But not everyone is taking it seriously. And after responding to the attack, Countdown’s Rachel Riley has been accused of insinuating Corbyn is a Nazi.
The media’s silence on the attack has also been deafening. This suggests bias against the leader of the opposition and hypocrisy when it comes to political violence and abuse.
More than just an egg thrown
Where the assault has been reported, it has been minimised to just an egg-throwing incident:
— Reuters Top News (@Reuters) March 3, 2019
But as journalist Jessica Elgot reported, the incident was more serious:
Understand that the incident with Jeremy Corbyn today is a little more serious than originally reported. No egg was thrown but a man is alleged to have hit Corbyn on the head, while holding an egg in his fist.
— Jessica Elgot (@jessicaelgot) March 3, 2019
And as Skwawkbox has since reported, a Labour Party source has confirmed:
It was an attempt to punch him in the face not just egg him, but thank God little contact was made. Jeremy was shaken but not injured.
Skwawkbox further noted:
The incident took place at the Finsbury Park Mosque – the same mosque attacked by right-wing terrorist Darren Osborne, who admitted he had hoped to kill Corbyn.
And yet despite this serious context in which the attack took place, the media has stayed relatively silent. On both the attack and the subsequent slur.
This raises a simple question: why isn’t the media taking the issue seriously? After all, when then-Conservative MP Anna Soubry was called a “Nazi” and intimidated outside parliament, there was wall to wall coverage and commentary for days.
Rachel Riley goes too far
One person accused of mocking the incident is Rachel Riley. Riley is an outspoken critic of Labour’s alleged antisemitism and a presenter on Channel 4‘s Countdown.
But Riley has provoked fury on social media for tweeting the following:
Good advice. 🌹🥚 pic.twitter.com/oqr0UNFrxU
— Rachel Riley (@RachelRileyRR) March 3, 2019
Riley was presumably critiquing perceived hypocrisy over political violence, such as egg throwing. The red rose and egg emojis were a clear reference to the Labour leader reportedly being struck by an egg.
But people were unimpressed. Especially as Jones’s original tweet concerned an actual fascist and former leader of the BNP, Nick Griffin.
As the mainstream media watchdog Media Lens summarised:
Riley quoting Owen Jones from January on a separate issue to imply that Corbyn, who has been assaulted, hit on the head, is a Nazi. Corbyn's attacker has been charged by police with 'assault by beating'. https://t.co/OGv3TbNFEx https://t.co/ddVxGwH1iE
— Media Lens (@medialens) March 4, 2019
And Owen Jones of the Guardian claimed that Riley was, “de facto” calling Corbyn a Nazi:
If @RachelRileyRR thinks it's acceptable to compare refusing to condemn an anti-fascist egging a Nazi with a rightwing protester egging Corbyn – who she is de facto calling a Nazi – outside a mosque targeted by a far right terrorist who wanted him dead, she has no moral compass.
— Owen Jones🌹 (@OwenJones84) March 3, 2019
Why the media silence?
Riley aside, the wider mainstream media ignoring the details of the attack has been revealing. Particularly considering the moral outrage expressed at the abuse suffered by other politicians recently. Yet again, this is a clear example of the media’s double standards when it comes to Labour.
As former spokesperson for Corbyn, Matt Zarb-Cousin tweeted:
Imagine if Theresa May got punched by a left wing activist…… do you reckon we’d have had half the commentariat tweeting egg puns all afternoon https://t.co/fOoTHF8Ciw
— Matt Zarb-Cousin (@mattzarb) March 3, 2019
And as writer Afua Hirsch commented:
Is it just me or has the attack on @jeremycorbyn been completely trivialised by the media? He was not “egged”, he was punched by a man holding an egg. Reports have made it sound harmless. Can we please take a stand against violence and abuse, is that too much to ask?
— Afua Hirsch (@afuahirsch) March 4, 2019
Member of Labour’s National Executive Committee (NEC), Huda Elmi, condemned the silence across politics:
Corbyn was punched, with an egg in the attackers hand, yet the deputy chairman of the Conservative Party thought it appropriate to celebrate this. Whilst many of us see Rachel Riley as an attention seeker, the lack of condemnation from across the political spectrum is damning.
— Huda Elmi (@hudaelmi_) March 4, 2019
The media’s complicity
The media has a duty to report the attack and condemn it. Especially considering the documented trend of UK media relentlessly promoting negative stories against Corbyn. Hostility towards him is largely its creation.
As one Twitter user added:
People can make all the egg jokes they like, it isn't funny. In this hostile climate, to which the media have more than contributed, they have a morale obligation to step up & diffuse.Instead, they stir the pot.
I just hope we don't have an "I told you so" moment, again.
— Jack D 🌹 (@JackDunc1) March 4, 2019
Others are now genuinely concerned about Corbyn’s safety:
Thank fu*k it was an egg and not something far worse.
The media need to end their lies, smears & dangerous rhetoric and quit with the hyperbole.
If he gets hurt, we know where blame will lie: with the media, the establishment and all those attacking him for their own gain.
— James! (@James4Labour) March 3, 2019
Jeremy Corbyn was today hit on the head by a man holding an egg. The egg made the headlines but the seriousness of the situation has thus far been overlooked. Jeremy’s personal safety matters and there are MPs and media people who need to start acting a lot more responsibly. https://t.co/KVdbbWc63P
— Sarah (@ScouseGirlMedia) March 3, 2019
And this is no laughing matter. At least one Twitter user has suggested Corbyn should be assassinated:
Here's one who wanted the egg to be a bullet pic.twitter.com/WSVFoWL8Fd
— Herr Chop (@HerrChop) March 3, 2019
Jones was damning in his assessment that the media whips up hostility against the left generally:
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: the hatred and bile whipped up against the British left by the mainstream media, and self-described "centrists" and "moderates", is legitimising violence which is going to lead to serious injury and death. pic.twitter.com/ZtuJDrNKFS
— Owen Jones🌹 (@OwenJones84) March 3, 2019
Dangerous and needs to be challenged
Last week the media showed its hypocrisy regarding racism. Its obsessive treatment of Labour antisemitism contrasts with its near silence on Conservative Party Islamophobia. This week it’s selective outrage regarding abuse against politicians.
We live in a media culture saturated by smears and negative narratives about Corbyn. And so it’s unsurprising that a media that thinks him such a villain equally thinks him unworthy of compassion and concern. It’s because of this toxic media culture that people like Riley can make incendiary remarks about Corbyn with impunity.
While the Labour leader operates in such a hostile environment, Labour activists and supporters cannot stress the need to ensure his safety enough.
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?