• Our Values
  • Support us
  • Countries ▼
    • UK
    • US
    • Global
  • Sections ▼
    • Trending
    • Exclusive
    • Investigation
    • Opinion
    • Feature
    • Off The Perch (Satire)
    • Cartoons
    • Podcast
    • Review
  • Topics ▼
    • Science
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Outing The Past
The Canary
The Canary
  • Our Values
  • Support us
  • Countries ▼
    • UK
    • US
    • Global
  • Sections ▼
    • Trending
    • Exclusive
    • Investigation
    • Opinion
    • Feature
    • Off The Perch (Satire)
    • Cartoons
    • Podcast
    • Review
  • Topics ▼
    • Science
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Outing The Past
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Youtube
    • RSS
Home
US
Analysis

As US politicians plot power grab, the Supreme Court hears from angry voters

March 28th, 2018 Michael Vick Michael Vick Analysis, Global, US

Spread the word:

Facebook Twitter
As US politicians plot power grab, the Supreme Court hears from angry votersAnalysis
Supreme Court of the United States

US politicians continue to plot power grabs. But now, the Supreme Court is hearing from angry voters on the issue, and could make a real difference.

The chance for a sea change

The Supreme Court will weigh in on partisan redistricting for the second time this term. This time, the case comes from a state where Democrats hold the edge.

The plaintiffs in the case, seven Republican voters in Maryland, say Democratic politicians violated their their First Amendment rights by targeting them for removal from their district based on their votes (free expression) in prior elections.

Let’s set an example for Washington and the rest of the nation and show that partisan gerrymandering has no place in our democracy. Enough is enough; all Marylanders deserve to have their voices heard and their votes counted.https://t.co/V8BNEyfqWR

— Governor Larry Hogan (@GovLarryHogan) March 28, 2018

The Maryland case differs from one the court heard five months ago. In that case, Democratic voters in Wisconsin said an entire state plan violated their rights under the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.

The two cases offer the chance for a sea change in US politics. The Supreme Court has never ruled on the issue of partisan map drawing — so-called ‘gerrymandering’ — leaving the matter to politicians. But a recent string of partisan maps have made the issue hard to ignore.

Pennsylvania’s high court struck down its state’s maps this year. Meanwhile, Republicans targeted state legislative seats in 2010 in order to rig the system on a national scale.

Pennsylvania voters learn more about independent districting commission from California model – WPMT FOX43 https://t.co/pzKB2zeLi2

— Fair Districts PA (@FairDistrictsPA) March 28, 2018

Voters favor independent redistricting

A recent poll suggests voters would support the justices if they struck down partisan maps.

The poll found that voters of both major parties and independents oppose partisan map drawing. Roughly two thirds of Republicans and independents and 80% of Democrats want the Supreme Court to set clear rules limiting party bias in district maps.

Nearly three out of four voters said they wanted districts drawn without party bias. That figure held even if it meant their favored party wouldn’t win as many seats.

Partisanship on the rise, but some states offer solutions

Even as fights between the main parties boil over nationwide, some states have already moved to independent map drawing.

California’s rules offer a test case in how democracy can work when voters pick their politicians, rather than the other way around. Voters there took state legislative and congressional maps out of the hands of politicians in 2008 and 2010 with ballot measures. State maps now fall to a panel of five Democrats, five Republicans and four people from neither major party. Majorities of all three groups must approve any changes to California’s maps.

California is not alone. In thirteen states, a bipartisan or non-partisan panel draws maps. Iowa uses non-partisan legislative staff to draw its maps.

The Supreme Court should step in to save democracy

Voters — not rigged maps designed to ensure one party’s dominance — should determine the outcome of elections. It’s time for the Supreme Court to rein in partisan gerrymandering and restore power to the people. My op-ed with @thetrevorpotter: https://t.co/X5w25i2hiN

— Sheldon Whitehouse (@SenWhitehouse) March 28, 2018

In an age of rising partisanship, and with ever greater numbers of US citizens calling themselves independents, political power grabs from both major parties must give way to nonpartisan redistricting.

Voters are demanding reform. And the Supreme Court should step in to save democracy from partisan hacks.

Featured image via Brittany Hogan/Flickr

Become a Canary member to support fearless independent journalism

Support The Canary with a monthly donation

  • Tags
  • Democracy
  • Democrat
  • gerrymandering
  • Maryland
  • Pennsylvania
  • redistricting
  • Republican
  • SCOTUS
  • supreme court
  • Wisconsin

Spread the word:

Facebook Twitter
Next article Police arrest protesters as they promise Anna Campbell ‘we will fight on’
Previous article Watch the appalling behaviour of Tory MPs as Caroline Lucas asks a question about election fraud at PMQs

Related Articles

Young girl shows anti-princess power by challenging sexist stereotypes at school Global

Young girl shows anti-princess power by challenging sexist stereotypes at school

Labour MP David Lammy smashes the racist backlash to the Windrush crisis Global

Labour MP David Lammy smashes the racist backlash to the Windrush crisis

Minister flounders as Scottish MP puts government on the spot over Saudi bombing of Yemen Global

Minister flounders as Scottish MP puts government on the spot over Saudi bombing of Yemen

People are refusing to stomach The Guardian's latest propaganda on Syria Analysis

People are refusing to stomach The Guardian's latest propaganda on Syria

If you weren’t already feeling a little bit sick about the BBC’s royal baby coverage, you will now Global

If you weren’t already feeling a little bit sick about the BBC’s royal baby coverage, you will now

The royal baby was delivered by the same NHS workers that Theresa May and Amber Rudd might deport Discovery

The royal baby was delivered by the same NHS workers that Theresa May and Amber Rudd might deport

Despite desperate calls for global action, the world continues to invest in fossil fuels Analysis

Despite desperate calls for global action, the world continues to invest in fossil fuels

The Pulitzer prize has finally woken up to the power of hip hop Global

The Pulitzer prize has finally woken up to the power of hip hop

Peter Hitchens takes Andrew Neil apart over Syria bias on BBC This Week Global

Peter Hitchens takes Andrew Neil apart over Syria bias on BBC This Week

Facebook Comments

STAY CONNECTED

The Canary

THE LATEST HEADLINES

Young girl shows anti-princess power by challenging sexist stereotypes at school

Young girl shows anti-princess power by challenging sexist stereotypes at school

A trade union just made a bit of a commotion right outside PMQs

A trade union just made a bit of a commotion right outside PMQs

Despite what the DWP says, the reality of Universal Credit is ruining lives

Despite what the DWP says, the reality of Universal Credit is ruining lives

A Conservative MP says homelessness is 'appealing'. Sky News makes him eat his lousy words.

A Conservative MP says homelessness is 'appealing'. Sky News makes him eat his lousy words.

Homelessness is almost 10 times worse than government figures suggest, says charity

Homelessness is almost 10 times worse than government figures suggest, says charity

and DON’T MISS These stories

Theresa May announces plan to pay 'army of voters' to elect Conservatives at next election

Theresa May announces plan to pay 'army of voters' to elect Conservatives at next election

Nick Robinson has issued a short statement to everyone who thinks the BBC has a problem with bias [VIDEO]

Nick Robinson has issued a short statement to everyone who thinks the BBC has a problem with bias [VIDEO]

Trident's profit trail leads right to the heart of Westminster

Trident's profit trail leads right to the heart of Westminster

Anti-terror fighter says 'we have to stop selling weapons to Turkey' if we want peace in Syria

Anti-terror fighter says 'we have to stop selling weapons to Turkey' if we want peace in Syria

A Japanese company has revealed how artificial intelligence will revolutionise work

A Japanese company has revealed how artificial intelligence will revolutionise work

  • Our Values
  • Membership
  • The Team
  • Jobs
  • Contact
  • Corrections & Complaints
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Back to top

The Canary

Independent Media | Campaigning Journalism

  • Our Values
  • Membership
  • The Team
  • Jobs
  • Contact
  • Corrections & Complaints
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Website hosted by: Krystal Website Hosting
© Canary Media Limited 2015-18. All rights reserved.
Canary Media Ltd, PO Box 3301, Bristol, BS5 5GD. Registered in England. Company registration number 09788095. Email: hello(at)thecanary.co