We need real opposition to stop Sajid Javid’s Health and Care Bill wrecking the NHS

Shattered logo of the NHS
Support us and go ad-free

In October 2020 and March 2021, The Canary reported on an attempted right-wing takeover of the Socialist Health Association (SHA) which would silence Labour opposition to NHS privatisation. The SHA was instrumental in establishing the NHS in 1948.

This week, the Tory-sponsored Health and Care Bill passed its second reading in parliament. A bill that, if enacted, could downgrade the NHS to more closely reflect the profit-driven US healthcare system. Meanwhile, as the threat of NHS privatisation has become imminent, Labour seems to be dragging its heels.

If people care about the NHS, now is the time to get active. Because if not, this latest Tory assault will be another nail in the coffin of a public health service that was once the envy of the world.

Under constant attack

Aneurin Bevan, former Labour minister for health who’s credited with establishing the NHS, is reported as saying:

The NHS will last as long as there are folk left with the faith to fight for it.

There’s hardly been a more appropriate time for that statement to be re-aired. Even in the 1940s, Bevan must have been aware of how precarious the NHS’s position was. After all, the British Medical Association (BMA) lobbied GPs not to sign up to it.

The intensification of this opposition took hold during the Thatcher years, before she’d even entered No. 10. Then Tony Blair’s ‘New Labour’, as well as successive Tory governments, continued to attack the NHS. So for the last 40 plus years, the NHS as a publicly run health service has been under attack.

Read on...

If it’s not stopped in its tracks, health secretary Sajid Javid’s bill could see the NHS become little more than a poor relation of the unenviable US healthcare system.

Should it become law, and the numbers in parliament suggest it might, the health and lives of British people are in danger. However, there are still sufficient numbers to make the kind of noise that could block it. So people need to organise to stop further privatisation and return the NHS to full public ownership.

The fight back has already begun

The Canary has already been investigating NHS privatisation and has spoken to anti-privatisation campaigners. Additionally, NHS doctor and campaigner Dr Bob Gill, who’s at the forefront of the fight to protect the NHS, spoke to The Canary. Gill said the NHS has suffered from four decades of “stealth privatisation”. And because the NHS is:

so treasured by the British public, successive governments have had to do this [secretly]

Indebting the NHS to the private sector

Gill explained how the government started by outsourcing “non-clinical services like cleaning and catering” in the 1980s. They then introduced:

the internal market, supposedly bringing pre-market discipline into the NHS and driving up efficiency. Well we know that’s a total scam.

This allowed the government to transform the NHS from “a public service ethos” to a business-friendly one. The Blair government then “doubled down on the internal market” and started outsourcing clinical services like elective surgery.

The Blair years also saw the private sector being allowed to “to saddle the NHS estate, land, and buildings with PFI [Private Finance Initiatives] debt”. According to Gill, PFI debt:

was a deliberate saddling of the NHS with private debt, which would get more onerous over time, and then be used as an excuse to flog off land

And PFI:

also handed over ownership to the private sector. So you had the assets being privatised.

From Dr Bob Gill’s documentary The Great NHS Heist


NHS capacity

Then in 2012, the Health and Social Care Act became law and austerity followed. According to Gill, the NHS’s capacity, that is “the number of beds per head of population, has more than halved since the 1970s”. He explains:

We have the lowest bed capacity per head of population compared to all other OECD countries of similar economic status. We have the fewest number of doctors per head in Europe. And by the time we entered the pandemic, we’d suffered a historic freeze of annual increase in the budget of around 1% on average over the decade, where since 1948 it’s averaged about 4%.

So it then became a:

defunded, repurposed, marketised NHS with a huge hole in the workforce – 10,000 vacancies in doctors, 40,000 nurse vacancies – and then we were hit with a pandemic. So this was a disaster waiting to happen.

In his documentary The Great NHS Heist, Gill laid out the timeline of NHS privatisation from the early 1980s until 2014:

Integrated care systems (ICS)

According to Gill, one of the biggest changes proposed in Javid’s bill is the creation of Integrated Care Systems (ICS). But instead of integrating or improving healthcare, these ICSs will integrate budgets which could be controlled by large private corporations.

Gill believes they’ll effectively be:

based on the US Medicare, Medicaid system – which is dominated by big private insurance companies like United Health, the world’s biggest private insurer – where the government, the taxpayer, puts in the money, but the management of that money is with a private insurer. And they are allowed to make profit…out of the ICS budget.

The US healthcare system and the denial of care

Gill says the number three cause of death for hospitalised patients in the US is medical error. He believes the hiring of less qualified medical staff, and breaking medical tasks up into “smaller, more straightforward tasks”, causes this. And no matter how efficient that may seem, it can increase the chances of error and patient harm.

When a less qualified member of staff deals with an atypical patient, there’s a risk of harm. So, despite the US spending twice as much on health per head of population as the UK, it has worse outcomes. He says:

They don’t live as long; more of their children die in young age; more of their mothers die in pregnancy. These are hard endpoints that show how well a health system is functioning. That is not a model any rational person, ethical person would follow. Yet our consecutive governments have been following them.

So the managed care system is a way that the American profit hungry corporations… collude to deny care to sick patients

What’s particularly worrying is Gill’s claim that the US healthcare system denies care to people with the greatest need. And it does so because providing such care is costly. This system uses patients’:

medical notes and various other algorithms and computer software. You identify the people who are undeserving, in your eyes, because you want to maximise profit… and you block their access to expensive hospital care.

And how do you do that? Well you set up an algorithm that blocks their access, you close services, you take away their GP surgeries, you present them with less qualified people, and you shut their A&Es. So there’s nowhere for these people to go. And you know the outcome is obvious. So people will be dying of serious illnesses before they get to hospital.

Renationalise the NHS

We need to renationalise the NHS. This puts it back in the hands of British people. However, until such time as that happens, Gill believes section 75 of the 2012 health act must stay. Section 75 allows private providers “in as minority participants in the NHS market to be paid from the NHS budget”. But it does at least require there to be a tendering process, and therefore there’s some transparency.

While this isn’t at all ideal, Gill believes section 75 means there’s some scrutiny of the tendering process, thereby making challenging it possible.

Whereas repealing section 75 would recreate:

the emergency legislation that the government used to outsource the whole pandemic response in multi-billion pound crony deals… There has been blatant corruption. … if you had connections to the Conservative Party, you were 10 times more likely to get a contract.

Do we really want that system for the marketised NHS? I don’t want a marketised NHS, but if we have a marketised NHS, until we renationalise it, we must not repeal section 75. Because that will allow secretive deals to be made. And it will also enable, this is the more worrying thing, it will enable the private sector monopoly within the NHS.

Where’s the opposition?

Gill was scathing of the Labour party’s opposition to the bill. He pointed out that:

they sabotaged their own electoral chances on two occasions. So a significant proportion of the Labour Party… were gunning for their own leader, who refreshingly dared to mention the ‘P’ word when it came to NHS. He mentioned privatisation. He mentioned the threat of a US trade deal, and he paid a very heavy political price. But the current shadow frontbench, from what I have heard, I hear nothing that reassures me that they are genuinely interested in defending the NHS

Similarly Gill was scathing of medical professional bodies and one trade union who he said were:

disconnected from the interests of their members, as we see in many organisations in this country. The BMA, the Royal Colleges, the RCN, and I believe Unison, all rubber stamp the white paper on which this bill is standing.

And he didn’t stop there. Gill has criticised groups that are calling for a repeal of section 75. Additionally, the BMA released a statement in opposition to the bill, but it endorses the creation of ICSs. And it’s arguing for greater representation on ICS boards. So, according to Gill:

They’re arguing for a snout in the trough. That’s what they’re arguing for. They should be calling for a total rejection and renationalisation, and they’re not doing that

The Canary also contacted the Department of Health and Social Care. A spokesperson said:

The NHS is not and never will be for sale.

Our Health and Care Bill builds on the NHS’ own proposals for reform and will ensure a health system that is less bureaucratic, more accountable, and more integrated in the wake of the pandemic.

Our proposals will give the NHS more power, not less, and maintain the NHS’s clinical and operational independence while ensuring the Secretary of State has appropriate oversight and accountability.

What can we do?

Despite the lack of real opposition and the difficulty of defeating this bill, Gill is still hopeful. He says we must:

make it clear to [the public] what is at stake, and who is after our NHS – it is American corporations, who will be extracting wealth from this country – it will be costing us all a lot more in financial terms either through taxation or topping up private insurance to replace what is gone from the NHS.

On an individual level, it will cost us more financially, it will cost us security, it will cost us – on a human level – mass preventable harm and death of patients, our loved ones, our family members, our friends. And this is what our government is doing.

So if the public wants to protect the NHS, it needs to get active now.

Featured image via Flickr – Garry Knight

Get involved

Follow the campaigns to stop the privatisation of the NHS

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us