The BBC tries to lay a trap for one of Corbyn’s top team members. It goes terribly wrong [VIDEO]

Support us and go ad-free

The BBC tried to lay a trap for one of Jeremy Corbyn’s top team members. But on 2 August, it went terribly wrong.

Venezuela’s political crisis

Chris Williamson, Shadow Minister for Fire and Emergency Services, spoke about the current political crisis in Venezuela on BBC Newsnight. There is a political struggle underway between the anti-government, right-wing, Washington-linked opposition leaders and the left-wing government. Violent clashes between protesters and pro-government forces have resulted in over a hundred fatalities.

Smear campaign

At present, both Conservative and Labour pro-establishment forces in the media are exploiting the political crisis to smear Corbyn. They insist that, because the Labour leader once praised the socialised healthcare and housing policies of Venezuela, he must now condemn President Nicolás Maduro. For them, it’s apparently no matter that Labour has already issued a statement urging “everyone in Venezuela, on all sides, to end the bloodshed immediately”.

The trap

On BBC Newsnight, the smear campaign continued with a trap for Williamson. Host Evan Davis began with a loaded question:

You either really have to face it that Maduro’s in the right now, which is one way out, or you were in the wrong to support him earlier…?

But Williamson cut through Davis’s black-and-white world with a nuanced answer:

Well that’s an unfair characterisation… clearly the circumstances have changed substantially in Venezuela… The collapse in the oil price… and these violent protests which have been aided and abetted by the United States of America who have been funding opposition groups and have a very shady record going back many decades of interfering in Latin America, right back to Chile where President Nixon said he was going to ‘make the economy scream’.

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free

“Very shady record”

Williamson points out the crucial context of US hostility seldom mentioned in the Western media:

  • The US has sought to destabilise oil-rich Venezuela for many years. Successive Venezuelan presidents have used the country’s natural resources for the benefit of citizens rather than bowing down to multinational corporations.
  • America is ideologically opposed to any form of socialism, especially right on its doorstep.
  • The US is experiencing geopolitical anxiety over a fast-growing China, a key ally of Venezuela. Since 2007, China has loaned around $57bn to Venezuela.

But the US is good and Venezuela is bad!

Rather than acknowledging such context, the BBC‘s Davis said:

So your response to seeing opposition leaders bundled out in the night and taken away and arrested, is to condemn the United States?

Again, Williamson challenged the question:

Not, not at all… that’s unfair Evan… I’m not here as an apologist for the Venezuelan government. Clearly they’ve made mistakes, they didn’t do enough to diversify the economy. But look, they’re under incredible pressure and there’s a very one-sided… view of the situation there, very often in the British media. I’m yet to hear any criticism of the right wing opposition, or indeed the United States… it can’t be right… in a situation where there is a massive crisis in Venezuela to impose sanctions on the country. Surely it would be far better to… try and bring the sides together, to facilitate talks and to encourage the right-wing opposition to stop these protests on the streets.

The Labour Party has outright condemned the violence on “all sides” in Venezuela and drawn attention to the government’s “responsibilities”. By contrast, pro-establishment media like the BBC incorrectly suggest the government is behind all the violence in Venezuela. Even The Guardian heavily implies that over a hundred deaths are a result of the state, when really five deaths at the hands of police have reportedly been confirmed so far.

Another trap

Apparently trying to reduce the debate to political labels, Davis later interrupted Williamson to ask:

Do you think you’re closer to Chávez, Maduro in your political philosophy or Tony Blair?

The MP for Derby North wasn’t having it:

I think the point is: when a government is doing good things as… under Hugo Chávez, huge reduction in poverty and investment in healthcare, housing… that’s surely a good thing we should celebrate… So… trying to put up these false dichotomies about ‘Oh you know, are you closer to Blair or… Maduro?’ I think it’s kind of an irrelevant question really.

On BBC Newsnight, Williamson’s intervention was a refreshing antidote to a UK commentariat biased towards US-led imperial interest in Venezuela. He refused to let the BBC reduce a nuanced debate to a simplified story of goodies and baddies. More of this please.

Watch the exchange here:

Venezuela must be seen in its proper context

I was on Newsnight yesterday speaking about the ongoing situation in Venezuela. It's clear that the government there has made mistakes; I'm not an apologist for everything that happens there. However, the crisis must be seen in its wider context of other factors, including economic interference and violent street protests. The current one-sided media onslaught does a disservice to people's intelligence.

Posted by Chris Williamson MP on Thursday, 3 August 2017

Get Involved!

– Ask Theresa May and your MP to support the peaceful and democratic deescalation of tensions in Venezuela.

– Join or support the Stop the War Coalition. Show your support for Veterans for Peace, who are fighting for peaceful solutions to the world’s problems. And take action with the Campaign Against Arms Trade.

– Support The Canary if you appreciate the work we do. Also see more Canary articles on Venezuela; and for more Global articles, follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

Featured image via screenshot

Support us and go ad-free

Do your bit for independent journalism

Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.

We need you to help out, if you can.

When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.

You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.

In return you get:

  • Advert free reading experience
  • Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
  • 20% discount from our shop


The Canary Fund us

Comments are closed