The hunting ban is an utter failure and a recent court case shows why

Running fox
Support us and go ad-free

A Somerset magistrate found the huntsman of Blackmore and Sparkford Vale Hunt (BSV) not guilty of illegal hunting. And the verdict reveals how much of a farce the hunting ban really is.

Not guilty

Anti-hunting groups Hounds Off and Somerset Wildlife Crime filmed the BSV hounds chasing a fox through a churchyard. The incident, which took place in Charleton Horethorne, Somerset, happened on 23 February 2019. It went to court on 22 January 2020, where a magistrate found the huntsman Peter Mark Doggrell not guilty of offences under the Hunting Act.

Video by the two anti-hunting groups, which was also shown in court, shows the pack of hounds going into cry as they chase a fox through the churchyard. The huntsman and other hunt staff make no attempt to call hounds off the fox. In fact, as The Canary previously reported, the footage:

shows a huntsman using his horn as hounds stream through a field next to the churchyard. The two horn calls resemble “doubling the horn” and “blowing away”, which encourage hounds to hunt.

Despite this, the magistrate found Doggrell not guilty. And it comes down to the flawed wording of the Hunting Act.

The Hunting Act

SomersetLive reported that Doggrell said the hounds that day were following a trail. He also said that trained hounds would “make the same noise as hunting a trail as they would a live animal”. Furthermore, Doggrell claimed that he was not aware of a fox in the churchyard. He also claimed that the horn calls ‘encouraged’ the hounds to “re-group”.

The Hunting Act doesn’t require hounds to kill a wild mammal in order to for an offence to be committed. It only requires that a person “engages or participates in the pursuit of a wild animal” and that “one or more dogs are employed in that pursuit”. However, a 2009 court case clarified this further. The case, which involved three members of the Devon and Somerset Staghounds, established that hunt staff must be pursuing an “‘identified’ wild mammal“.

Read on...

In other words, the prosecution must prove the hunt actively encouraged its hounds to chase a fox, hare, deer, or other wild mammal. This could be done either by showing hunt staff encouraging hounds onto the animals, such as through horn calls. Or it could be done by showing the hunt was aware that hounds were chasing a wild mammal but made no attempt to stop them.

This was proven in the case against the Thurlow Hunt in March 2019. Beds & Bucks Hunt Sabs said the huntsman on the day could clearly be heard encouraging the hounds to hunt using his voice, and the district judge agreed.

However, Doggrell’s defence shows that ‘trail hunting’ is designed to win court cases, not to provide an alternative to bloodsport.


While there’s no fixed definition of trail hunting, a guide by the Countryside Alliance provides insight into how it’s been designed. The pro-hunt lobby group says trail hunting intends to “simulate traditional hunting”. Hunts achieve this using a “quarry-based scent”, or a scent made with a fox. A witness for BSV said the hunt made its trail from fox urine, although at least one other hunt has claimed it boils dead foxes.

The Countryside Alliance also says that the huntsman and whippers-in “do not know exactly where the trails have been laid”. It follows this up by stating that “there isn’t a set route or a finishing time” for trails. In other words, hunt staff are protected by the excuse of ignorance in case hounds chase a fox or other mammal. Trail layers also can’t be charged because they are not in control of the hounds.

Not fit for purpose

Doggrell’s defence rested on ignorance of what his hounds were doing. And it’s a defence encouraged by the wording of the Hunting Act. Reacting to the verdict, Somerset Wildlife Crime said:

A very disappointing result in what should have been an open shut case of illegal hunting. …

The law isn’t working, this case signifies exactly why we need a recklessness clause added, then British wildlife would be afforded the protection they were meant to benefit from when the Hunting Act was passed 15 years ago.

The hunting ban is not fit for purpose. One viewing of Hounds Off and Somerset Wildlife Crime’s footage will prove that. Until the kennels are shut down permanently, hunt saboteurs and monitors remain the only people holding these hunts to account.

Featured image via Hounds Off/Vimeo

Get involved

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us
  • Show Comments
    1. Seahorse powder is made from ground seahorses and is used for a variety of health benefits. Here are some of the advantages associated with the consumption of seahorse powder:

      Boosts the Immune System: Seahorse powder is believed to have immune-boosting properties, which can help improve the body’s ability to fight off infections and diseases.

      Improves Respiratory Health: Seahorse powder is often used to treat respiratory problems such as coughs and asthma. It is believed to have a calming effect on the lungs, making it easier to breathe.

      Enhances Sexual Health: Seahorse powder is also used as an aphrodisiac and to treat male sexual dysfunction. It is believed to increase sexual potency and improve libido.

      Promotes Cardiovascular Health: Seahorse powder is believed to have cardiovascular benefits, including reducing blood pressure and improving circulation.

      Helps with Joint Pain: Seahorse powder is often used to treat joint pain and arthritis. It is believed to have anti-inflammatory properties, which can help reduce pain and swelling in the joints.

      Improves Skin Health: Seahorse powder is believed to have anti-aging properties and is often used in skincare products. It is thought to help improve skin elasticity and reduce the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines.

      Contains Essential Nutrients: Seahorse powder is rich in essential nutrients such as protein, calcium, and magnesium, which can help support overall health and wellbeing.

      It is important to note that while seahorse powder has been used for centuries in traditional medicine, scientific research on its health benefits is limited. As with any herbal remedy, it is important to consult with a healthcare professional before using seahorse powder for medicinal purposes. Additionally, it is important to consider the ethical implications of using seahorses for medicinal purposes, as many species of seahorses are endangered due to overfishing and habitat loss

      We Supply Dried seahorse for sale, Ox Cow gallstones, Dried fish maw ,Cuttlefish Bone, Dry Swallow Bird Nest and many other seafood from Denmark. Our prices are moderate and we ship worldwide. Contact us at

    Leave a Reply

    Join the conversation

    Please read our comment moderation policy here.