BBC Newsnight reported on the aftermath of parliament’s ‘Super Saturday’ session on 19 October. In particular, it detailed the ire politicians faced from protesters as they left parliament that day.
Its presenter Emily Maitlis made passing mention that MPs “from both sides” came into contact with the public. But its accompanying clip only showed contact between protesters and Conservative politicians, despite footage existing of someone confronting a Labour MP.
The clip – and the “throwaway” mention of what other MPs faced – explains why many see the broadcaster as a mouthpiece for the Tories.
Blink and you missed it. Here's how @maitlis presents the abuse against @HackneyAbbott over #BrexitVote Film of #ReesMogg film of #Gove film of #andrealeadsom – Diane – throwaway line at the end. 'MPs of all stripes..' really? #BBCBias pic.twitter.com/j2HuLw8uXO
— Fintan BSc (Hons.)🌹🌈 (@fintanmccarthy) October 20, 2019
Conservative contact with the public
Politicians headed to parliament on 19 October for more voting on Brexit issues. As such, protesters on both sides of the Brexit divide were out in force that day, including those involved a million-strong march calling for another referendum. A number of MPs decided to leave parliament via foot that day. The protesters didn’t stay quiet as they passed. Maitlis explained that:
protesters [were] showing the passion and raw emotion that Brexit has unleashed when MPs from both sides came into contact earlier today with the public
The programme then proceeded to show a clip of that contact between protesters and Jacob Rees-Mogg, Micheal Gove, and Andrea Leadsom. It showed Rees-Mogg and Leadsom subject to chants of “shame on you”. One protester called Gove an “education wrecker”. The police flanked all of them as they walked.
After the clip finished, Maitlis added:
You’ve seen a couple of MPs who had to walk with police guards. Diane Abbott was another one who was confronted.
The other confrontation
Maitlis is quite right, another protester did confront Diane Abbott. Footage of that is publicly available too:
— Stéphanie Bosset (@39_stephs) October 19, 2019
In that confrontation, a protester subjected Abbott to thinly veiled sexist and racist comments. The man asked the MP if she had “Jeremy Corbyn’s slippers on”, insinuating the two had been in intimate settings together. He then said, “you and Jeremy Corbyn need to go on a nice holiday somewhere and stay there”. This differs from a racist ‘go home’ comment but reeks of the same sentiment nonetheless.
But the BBC didn’t include this confrontation in its clip, it only showed those faced by Conservative politicians. This didn’t go down well with the public:
— George Otieno (@otienozzie) October 20, 2019
What a set up! Yet the real attack on Diane was ignored!
— 💜🐙🦕🦎🐢🐬🌹🌲🌎🌈⭐️ (@June_r57) October 21, 2019
Shocking bias..again. But Gove thoroughly enjoyed it, eh? With that inane grinning.
— Moira B (@BatesMoira) October 20, 2019
That BBC Newsnight didn’t include what Abbott endured in its clip hasn’t done it any favours. By only documenting what Conservative MPs faced, it’s cementing a belief many already hold: that the broadcaster is biased towards the governing party. Because although MPs of ‘all stripes’ did indeed have ‘contact’ with protestors, it only properly detailed what happened to the Conservatives.
Featured image via screengrab/Twitter
We need your help ...
The coronavirus pandemic is changing our world, fast. And we will do all we can to keep bringing you news and analysis throughout. But we are worried about maintaining enough income to pay our staff and minimal overheads.
Now, more than ever, we need a vibrant, independent media that holds the government to account and calls it out when it puts vested economic interests above human lives. We need a media that shows solidarity with the people most affected by the crisis – and one that can help to build a world based on collaboration and compassion.
We have been fighting against an establishment that is trying to shut us down. And like most independent media, we don’t have the deep pockets of investors to call on to bail us out.
Can you help by chipping in a few pounds each month?