Owen Smith goes into meltdown on Newsnight after a Labour MP ‘unresigns’ to join Corbyn [VIDEO, TWEETS]
Rotherham MP Sarah Champion has offered Corbyn a letter of ‘unresignation‘. She quit the shadow cabinet in June, giving up her position as the shadow Home Office minister for preventing abuse and domestic violence, during the exodus of MPs from Labour’s front bench. But after a change of heart, she has been accepted back into the Labour leadership team.
Labour party spokespeople, and the mainstream media after them, have speculated whether this could trigger a domino effect amongst shadow cabinet members, turning into a ‘deshuffle‘.
At the time, Champion said:
I have just stepped down from my shadow minister job, but not my responsibilities to my constituents, party or victims of abuse.
Her reasons for stepping down were to do with her feelings about Corbyn’s leadership, but she didn’t consider herself part of the coup:
I can assure you I've not joined any coup, just think Jeremys position is no longer tenable if we're to be effective https://t.co/EiNhp2KH14
— Sarah Champion (@SarahChampionMP) June 29, 2016
When asked to discuss what BBC assistant political editor Norman Smith called the “extraordinary development”, however, Corbyn’s leadership challenger Owen Smith was determined to make out that he was not bothered.
Newsnight‘s James O’Brien pointed out that the no-confidence of Labour MPs in Corbyn and their “desertion” from his shadow cabinet had been Smith’s “ace in the hole”, and that Champion’s return signaled a “crack in the facade” of Smith’s campaign.
But in his own ‘extraordinary development’, Smith immediately tried to downplay the event by saying:
Sarah’s a friend and she’s a great MP, but to be honest, James, we’ve gone beyond MPs now haven’t we, it’s…the MPs are rather irrelevant
He went on to try and gloss over the significance of the ‘unresignation’ saying, while discussing the breaking story on Newsnight:
In reality, Sarah going back in isn’t much of a story, either way
It wasn’t long before social media lit up Smith’s u-turn. For weeks, Labour party members have been told by Labour coup MPs that their views are subservient to those of the party’s MPs. Now, with MPs beginning to the Corbyn team, it appears it is simply anyone who aligns themselves with Corbyn who is, from point of view of the plotters ‘irrelevant’.
Owen Smith when MPs backed his coup: it's all about MPs, not members.
Owen Smith when MPs defect: it's all about the membership #newsnight
— Kerry-Anne Mendoza (@TheMendozaWoman) July 25, 2016
Whaaaaaaatttttt???? Sure mate and ignorance us strength. Treated members with contempt for months now a turnaround. https://t.co/HFSwiDOkmn
— Samantha Asumadu (@honestlyAbroad) July 25, 2016
Owen Smith on #Newsnight says Sarah Champion "just 1 vote in 500000."
YOU WEREN'T SAYING THAT WHEN IT WAS JUST 172 IN 250000, WERE YOU?!
— Alan Matthews (@hazmatt72) July 26, 2016
"Jeremy Corbyn keeps telling people he's got a huge mandate" @owensmith_mp
"That's because it's true"@mrjamesob#newsnight
— shibs (@dr_shibley) July 25, 2016
Asked to distinguish the policy differences between himself and Jeremy Corbyn, Smith defined them as patriotism, a tougher stance on immigration, and his support for nuclear weapons. Or as one Twitter user summarised it:
Vote #OwenSmith for a return to racist crockery, mass detention of migrants and violent border control #Newsnight pic.twitter.com/VOurXy0wSv
— Pukkah Punjabi (@PukkahPunjabi) July 25, 2016
Strangely though, this mornings papers had taken a somewhat different line on events. Yet again, a positive story for the Corbyn camp has been the transformed into another smear. By morning, an unidentified Labour source tried to spin Champion’s return to the front benches as evidence of incompetence, via Paul Waugh of the Huffington Post:
.@SarahChampionMP sent her 'unresignation' email to JC on Thursday. Took a full 5 days for his team to find it, one party source says.
— Paul Waugh (@paulwaugh) July 25, 2016
Waugh then had to clarify:
Another reason for delay: Corbyn's office wanted to speak to @SarahChampionMP in person first to make sure she'd received the emailed reply
— Paul Waugh (@paulwaugh) July 25, 2016
There’s hardly time to keep up with the constant combat. As noted in Smith’s Newsnight interview, we now have only three weeks to go until voting begins in the Labour leadership contest. But with the coup MPs promising an annual repeat until or unless Corbyn resigns, it’s hard to see how Labour can continue without removing those who would rather see the party lose, than win with Corbyn as leader.
You can watch Smith’s full Newsnight interview here:
Read Canary articles about the Labour leadership contest.
Support The Canary‘s independent journalism.
Image via BBC/YouTube (screenshot)
We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support
The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.
The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.
So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.