Rather than answering Jeremy Corbyn’s questions on the housing crisis at the first Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs) after summer recess, Theresa May responded with scripted jokes instead.
Devastating figures released over the summer show that £9.3bn of public money is paid directly to private landlords. Does the Prime Minister think this £9.3bn into the private rented market is really money well spent?
Rather than controlling rents and building affordable social housing, the Conservative government is currently handing landlords taxpayer cash for extortionate rents. For the £1.25bn annual grant for social housing, the Treasury saves £4.5bn annually in housing benefit. In other words, building more social housing would reduce the housing benefit bill dramatically.
Attempting to mask the massive handout to landlords, May took a leaf out of David Cameron’s book, telling a scripted joke:
Everything that he says only tells us all we need to know about modern Labour. The train’s left the station. The seats are all empty. The leader’s on the floor. Even on rolling stock, they’re a laughing stock.
But the cheap shot fell flat.
Theresa May needs to sack her comedy scriptwriter or learn how to tell a joke. Cringe. #PMQs
— Owen Jones🌹 (@OwenJones84) September 7, 2016
In #PMQs we see serious issues that really affect people like us being laughed off by the privileged few who will never experience hardship.
— You can call me V (@vspearson85) September 7, 2016
Meanwhile, The Guardian’s Political Editor wrote:
her pre-scripted anti-Corbyn jibes (in response to questions two and three) came over as unprovoked, gratuitous and consequently rather cheap.
Question Two, and a questionable quote from May
For question two, the Labour leader had said:
The former Prime Minister promised there would be a one-for-one replacement for every council house that he’s sold under right to buy. Sadly, the reality is there’s only one for every five sold. Will the Prime Minister give us a commitment on the one-for-one replacement and when it will be a reality?
The government’s own figures show that, since 2012, only one in ten (4,594 of 49,573) council homes have been replaced by Local Authorities. But after brazenly lying and claiming “we have delivered on the one-for-one replacement”, May attempted to divert attention again, with another joke.
Referencing Corbyn asking his Twitter followers for PMQs suggestions, May read out one response suggesting a question for her:
Does she know that in a recent poll on who would make the better prime minister, ‘don’t know’ scored higher than Jeremy Corbyn?
May was soon called out on social media for the Twitter account she quoted:
Vested interests in housing
Conservative policies appear to extract billions from public funds and tenants while handing those billions to landlords. 128 Conservative MPs (39%) are landlords themselves, betraying a direct financial benefit in keeping house prices high.
But this problem spans across parliament, as 22% of Labour and 26% of SNP MPs are landlords, too. One fifth of MPs are private landlords, compared to only 3 in 100 across the electorate.
In January, at least 73 landlord MPs voted against proposals requiring rented houses to be “fit for human habitation”. Labour’s amendment to the housing bill was voted down by 312 votes to 219, which Corbyn used as a point of attack at PMQs this week.
Currently, if you earn the national average salary of £26,500, 91% of England and Wales would be beyond your income. On Wednesday, May made a mistake in trivialising such an important issue with scripted jokes. In opting for pre-prepped zingers over substance, the Prime Minister only betrayed the government’s utter failure to tackle the crisis.
Watch the full PMQs exchange here:
– Check out our other articles on PMQs.
Featured image via Youtube screenshots
Do your bit for independent journalism
Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.
We need you to help out, if you can.
When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.
You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.
In return you get:
- Advert free reading experience
- Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
- 20% discount from our shop