Woman who can’t read, write, walk or talk ‘declared fit for work’ by DWP

Georgina and Paula Ball
Support us and go ad-free

A 26-year-old woman with a severe disability recently had her benefit payments stopped. Her name is Georgina Ball. And she is unable to walk, talk, read or write.

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) claims her payments stopped because she missed an appointment. An appointment which would have assessed Georgina’s ability to work. The woman’s full-time carer, her mother Paula Ball, denies that any such appointment existed. And she explains their situation in this video:

Georgina’s condition

Georgina suffers from Aicardi Syndrome, which causes symptoms including severe epileptic seizures and learning disabilities. Because of this, she receives Employment Support Allowance (ESA). This benefit is assessed differently dependent on a person’s condition. The government’s own website states that:

You’ll then be placed in one of 2 groups if you’re entitled to ESA:

  • work-related activity group, where you’ll have regular interviews with an adviser
  • support group, where you don’t have interviews

While it may be appropriate to reassess someone whose condition may improve, it’s clearly inappropriate to force someone with a diagnosed life-long condition to keep proving it.

The ‘missed’ appointment

The DWP sent a letter on 23 December alleging a missed appointment. Paula Ball explains [emphasis added]:

Read on...

The [DWP] want her to go to work assessment to prove that she’s fit for work, but as you can see, she’s not fit for work. Their argument is they said they sent an appointment, which I didn’t receive. So when I phoned them I explained to them. They said well explain why she didn’t turn up. So I explained to them, well how can you [ask me to] explain something when I didn’t have the appointment in the first place.

So they stopped the benefits. Because they didn’t receive my letter back to them… I wrote an A4 letter back to them explaining Georgina’s needs and disabilities and what she needs. Recorded delivery. They then sent out a P45 saying she was fit for work. I got back on the phone and explained to them I’d sent them a recorded delivery letter. They actually found it and then said they would set her payment back up and now they’ve sent another appointment for a works assessment in February.

Georgina has had her payments reinstated. But the Balls face another mandatory appointment at the Mann Island Health Assessment Advisory Service on 15 February. This is despite a doctor sending the DWP a letter confirming Georgina’s condition. If she misses this appointment, her payments will once more stop. Paula told them that their disabled toilets would not be sufficient for Georgina, who is doubly incontinent. Despite this, the DWP has not offered them a home visit.

Jumping through hoops

The Canary has previously reported on other people with disabilities who have been let down by the DWP. Obviously, there must be assessments for fairness and accuracy, but as Paula Ball points out:

Georgina’s condition is only going to get worse.

There is no chance of her getting better, she has a poor prognosis of life.

But many disabled people, like Georgina, don’t have people to fight their case for them and are dragged to these appointments and then when they don’t go, they have their money stopped.

I understand that there are people wrongly playing the system and they have to check but they are doing it to the wrong people.

They have all Georgina’s medical evidence in front of them. She will never be able to work.

DWP response

The DWP told The Liverpool Echo:

We review people’s circumstances to ensure they have access to the correct level of support to match their needs.

But we recognise that for some people their conditions are unlikely to change, which is why we recently announced that we will be stopping re-assessments for people with the most severe health conditions and disabilities.

The department also claimed that it made the original appointment because Mrs Ball had not filled out the correct form. Her failure to do so meant that the DWP scheduled Georgina for a three-yearly review.


There seems to be little benefit in the benefit system’s current rigorousness. And yet there are incredibly apparent downsides to it. No reasonable person would think that a person in Georgina’s situation should have to prove what doctors have already confirmed, just for the sake of ticking boxes. But these situations still keep arising.

Get Involved!

– Support Disabled People Against Cuts (DPAC).

– Sign the petition to stop cuts to disabled people’s benefits.

Featured image via video screengrab

We know everyone is suffering under the Tories - but the Canary is a vital weapon in our fight back, and we need your support

The Canary Workers’ Co-op knows life is hard. The Tories are waging a class war against us we’re all having to fight. But like trade unions and community organising, truly independent working-class media is a vital weapon in our armoury.

The Canary doesn’t have the budget of the corporate media. In fact, our income is over 1,000 times less than the Guardian’s. What we do have is a radical agenda that disrupts power and amplifies marginalised communities. But we can only do this with our readers’ support.

So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us.

Support us

Comments are closed