A fresh scandal hits Theresa May as the Home Office is accused of ‘putting lives at risk’

Theresa May and Home Office sign
Support us and go ad-free

As the Windrush scandal continues, the Home Office has come under further criticism. A damning new report reveals that it puts “lives at risk” with an asylum system that “dehumanises, disempowers and damages” people. Ultimately, Theresa May holds responsibility.

“Lives at risk”

Waiting in The Dark [pdf], a new report by Refugee Action, reveals the “devastating” impact of “Home Office failings”. Stephen Hale, chief executive of Refugee Action, said:

Britain’s asylum system often does immense damage to people who come to this country to claim protection.

The report found that:

Bad practices and poor decision-making are putting lives at risk.

Mariam Kemple Hardy, head of campaigns at Refugee Action, told The Canary that there were “fundamental problems” with a system that deals with “life and death” situations. Lack of legal support, delays in Home Office decisions, and a rising number of appeals against incorrect decisions are devastating for people who have fled to the UK for safety.

Many need treatment for depression and anxiety. But the report also established that Home Office delays take “a tremendous toll on people’s wellbeing”. For example:

Read on...

Support us and go ad-free

During the five years they waited for a decision, Tristan’s wife was diagnosed with a brain aneurism, which the doctors said was brought on by the stress she had experienced since the family had arrived in the UK.

“Damaging, dehumanising and disempowering”

From February to April 2018, Refugee Action surveyed 50 organisations that work [pdf, p28] with asylum seekers. It found:

an asylum system that is too often damaging, dehumanising and disempowering those who rely on it to make life-changing decisions.

Despite Home Office targets to make a decision on asylum status within six months, more people than ever now face a longer wait. According to the report [pdf, p10]:

By the end of 2017, the number of people waiting over six months for a decision on an asylum claim had risen to 14,306, a 25% increase on the previous year. This is the highest annual number of people waiting since public records began, despite the fact that since 2015 asylum applications have been steadily falling.

It found the Home Office has a severe backlog dealing with cases. This leaves vulnerable people “in a state of uncertainty”. Not least because they’re:

living below the poverty line, banned from working and unable to rebuild their lives.

Kemple Hardy told The Canary:

Some people have waited five years for a decision. The government needs to know that the current system is devastating people’s lives.


But one of the most damning aspects of the report shows [pdf, p10] that, even after a lengthy wait, there are concerns about Home Office decisions. Refugee Action found:

indications that quality remains below the standards that are expected from a system whose decisions have such a far reaching impact on those who go through it.

Even when applications are turned down, “over a third of appeals against asylum decisions” succeeded [pdf, p10] at appeal:

meaning that the Home Office’s decision to refuse somebody’s claim was deemed incorrect by the courts.

And this number was even higher for certain nationalities for whom [pdf, p10] “over half of all decisions were overturned”:

in 2017, this was the case for Afghan (52%), Libyan (61%) Somali (54%) and Yemeni (70%) cases.

Kemple Hardy explained that there is something “fundamentally wrong” with the system but also that:

Crucially, the interpreters they’ve been using have not been accurate. I can’t think of anything more distressing than to know that the reason why you’re claiming asylum is not fully understood.

“No empathy”

But this report goes further than damning statistics. Because it’s also based on interviews with 40 asylum seekers. Their voices show the true impact the Home Office has on people’s lives.

Rose, a victim “of human trafficking who was forced into prostitution in the UK”, said [pdf, p16]:

The substantive interview [was] an experience I don’t ever want to experience again in my life. I’d rather die. Because the lady who interviewed me, there was no sign of empathy… She wasn’t putting into consideration the fact that I had been through hell. And in my heart I wished I could let her live my life for one day, what I lived. And maybe she would have empathy to understand where I’m coming from.

According to Samira [pdf, p5]:

It’s shameful if you say you are asylum seeker. It’s not easy… They treat people like liars. They think everybody is lying… It really shocked me. We are human beings, flesh and blood… Stop treating us in an unhuman way.

And others, like Qadir [pdf, p5], explained the simple fact that:

Nobody would leave their own country and apply for asylum for no reason. But right now I have no rights in this country. When I compare myself with others, I am an outsider. I am deprived of the basic rights that others have.


Listening to these voices, it’s clear – yet again – how badly the Home Office and May’s government fail to support some of the most vulnerable people in society. Radical change is needed, and it’s needed now. Windrush shows that public outrage can lead to policy changes – this needs to happen again.

Get Involved!

– Write to your MP and ask them to tell the Home Secretary that our asylum system is in urgent need of reform and follow the #StandUpForAsylum hashtag on Twitter.

–  Support the work done by Refugee Action.

– Join The Canary, so we can keep holding the powerful to account.

Featured image via EU2017EE Estonian Presidency/Flickr and Home Office

Support us and go ad-free

Do your bit for independent journalism

Did you know that less than 1.5% of our readers contribute financially to The Canary? Imagine what we could do if just a few more people joined our movement to achieve a shared vision of a free and fair society where we nurture people and planet.

We need you to help out, if you can.

When you give a monthly amount to fund our work, you are supporting truly independent journalism. We hold power to account and have weathered many attempts to shut us down and silence the counterpoint to the mainstream.

You can count on us for rigorous journalism and fearless opposition to an increasingly fascist government and right wing mainstream media.

In return you get:

  • Advert free reading experience
  • Behind the scenes monthly e-newsletter
  • 20% discount from our shop


The Canary Fund us

Comments are closed